This study aims to analyze strategies for building competitive advantage in private Islamic educational institutions through a multi-site study approach at an urban upper-middle segment school and a lower-middle segment school. Using a descriptive qualitative approach, this study collected data through observation, in-depth interviews, and documentation involving principals, vice-principals, excellent program coordinators, and teachers. The research findings reveal three primary outcomes: (1) Differentiation strategies, two contrasting models were identified: the urban school adopts a market-driven approach adaptive to global mobility, whereas the lower-middle school opts for a value-driven focusing on the steadfastness of religious value identity; (2) Resource-Based View perspective, the urban school successfully converts tangible resources and modern facilities into core competencies, while the lower-middle school demonstrates a positive anomaly where financial constraints instead trigger managerial creativity in optimizing human resources and intangible assets; and (3) Public accountability, both schools utilize participatory, performance-based mechanisms as an anchor to build quality transparency and sustainable social legitimacy within the community. This study contributes to extending the strategic management framework, demonstrating that the competitive advantage of educational institutions is not monopolized by financial power but is determined by the precise alignment between internal institutional capabilities and the socio-cultural expectations of the market. The limitation of this study lies in its restricted focus on the regional competition of private Islamic schools; therefore, future research is suggested to test this alignment model on a broader geographical scale or within non-religious educational institutions to validate the generalizability of the findings.
Copyrights © 2026