This article examines how religious authority and intellectual autonomy are positioned in the paradigm of wasathiyah-based Islamic education. The problem is that moderation is commonly framed as a disposition to be instilled, which leaves unexamined how learners evaluate religious claims and the authorities that make them. The study employs a critical literature review of 20 journal articles and 10 books, analysed thematically in five stages from purposive selection to conceptual synthesis. The findings show that wasathiyah is predominantly operationalised as values and character; that religious authority is being reconfigured, not displaced, by digital media; that pesantren and Islamic higher education institutions function as hybrid spaces where traditional authority meets academic governance; and that critical thinking is pursued mostly as a general skill, often instrumentalised against extremism. The article argues that moderation acquired through deference alone is structurally as fragile as extremism acquired through deference alone. It proposes the Authoritative Autonomy Framework (Kerangka Otonomi Berotoritas), built on accountable authority, guided evaluative autonomy, and the ethics of disagreement, which redefines autonomy as the capacity to evaluate rather than to issue rulings, and authority as that which can be examined. The implications concern curriculum, teacher education, and indicators of religious moderation.
Copyrights © 2026