This conceptual review develops an agency-preserving framework for generative artificial intelligence (GenAI)-supported adaptive learning. Its starting problem is that personalized assistance and improved performance during AI use do not necessarily demonstrate greater learner autonomy. The analysis critically compares selected theoretical accounts, published educational studies, reviews, and human-centred governance guidance relevant to personalization, self-regulation, and human responsibility. It distinguishes conversational responsiveness from personalization and from instructional adaptation based on evidence of learners' needs. The proposed conditional loop connects diagnostic fit, graduated assistance, meaningful learner choice, verification of generated information, independent-transfer checks, and educator accountability. Contrasting published findings indicates why assisted task completion must be evaluated separately from learning that persists when support is withdrawn. The contribution is a testable conceptual decision criterion, not a validated intervention or estimate of effectiveness. Because the review did not use a documented exhaustive search or formal study appraisal, the conclusions are interpretive and context-bounded. Future research should examine the loop's mechanisms, moderating conditions, and measurable indicators of independent reasoning and self-regulated learning. Abstrak Kajian konseptual ini mengusulkan kerangka pembelajaran adaptif berbasis kecerdasan buatan generatif (GenAI) yang menjaga agensi peserta didik. Persoalan utamanya ialah bahwa personalisasi dan peningkatan kinerja ketika AI digunakan tidak otomatis menunjukkan kemandirian belajar. Kajian ini membandingkan secara kritis argumentasi teoretis, tinjauan pustaka, hasil penelitian pendidikan, dan panduan tata kelola yang dipilih karena relevansinya terhadap personalisasi, regulasi diri, dan tanggung jawab manusia. Analisis membedakan respons percakapan, bantuan yang dipersonalisasi, dan adaptasi yang didasarkan pada bukti kebutuhan belajar. Kontribusi yang diajukan berupa siklus bersyarat yang menghubungkan diagnosis kebutuhan, bantuan bertahap, pilihan peserta didik, verifikasi informasi, pengujian kemampuan mandiri, dan akuntabilitas pendidik. Sintesis menunjukkan bahwa keberhasilan tugas dengan bantuan GenAI perlu dibedakan dari transfer pengetahuan tanpa bantuan. Kerangka ini merupakan proposisi konseptual yang belum diuji secara empiris, bukan hasil penelusuran literatur sistematis atau estimasi efektivitas. Penelitian berikutnya perlu menguji mekanisme, batasan konteks, dan indikator kemandirian belajar dalam berbagai desain pembelajaran.
Copyrights © 2026