The implementation of Article 252 of Law No. 1 of 2023 concerning the Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP) criminalizes individuals who claim to possess supernatural powers that can cause illness, death, or mental or physical suffering. This study examines the evidentiary challenges faced by law enforcement officials in East Java in prosecuting such spiritual offenses within a society still deeply influenced by Javanese mysticism. Using a socio-legal approach, this research analyzes the normative construction of Article 252 as a formal offense, the evidentiary framework under the Criminal Procedure Code, and the sociological realities of East Javanese society. The findings reveal that while the formal offense construction strategically avoids the metaphysical causality problem, evidentiary challenges remain multidimensional: absence of direct witnesses, inability of forensic science to prove supernatural causality, potential for multiple interpretations of the phrase "supernatural powers" that may violate the lex certa principle, and risks of compromised presumption of innocence due to social pressure and judicial bias. This study recommends strengthening operational definitions in the article's elucidation, establishing special evidentiary guidelines by the Supreme Court, and ensuring fair trial commitments from all law enforcement officials.
Copyrights © 2026