Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 17 Documents
Search

Pathways of Continuity: Indonesia’s Role in Southeast Asia’s Refugee Governance Atin Prabandari; Emma Seruni Ketaren; Balya Arung Segara
Insignia: Journal of International Relations Vol 12 No 2 (2025): November 2025
Publisher : Laboratorium Hubungan Internasional, FISIP, Universitas Jenderal Soedirman

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.20884/1.ins.2025.12.2.17940

Abstract

This article interrogates the enduring character of non-binding, sovereignty-centric refugee governance across Southeast Asia by analyzing the role of Indonesia within two principal displacement episodes: the Indochinese refugee crisis (1975–1996) and the ongoing Rohingya crisis. Applying the analytical lens of historical institutionalism and foregrounding the notion of path dependency, the account demonstrates how operational norms forged under the Comprehensive Plan of Action—including temporary humanitarian shelter, conditional burden redistribution, and the construal of displacement as a temporary aberration—have resurfaced in Indonesia’s present-day posture. Archival records, policy tracts, and a selective review of the secondary literature furnish a reconstruction of Jakarta’s stewardship of the Galang Island camp and an assessment of its recent practices toward the Rohingya, encompassing semi-offshore rescues and deference to international humanitarian actors. The inquiry substantiates profound institutional and normative continuities that circumscribe Indonesia’s capacity and readiness to construct durable, rights-respecting protection frameworks, notwithstanding a shifting geopolitical and humanitarian tableau. By embedding Indonesia’s trajectory within the regional governance matrix, the study illuminates historical legacies that continue to inform Southeast Asian refugee policy and underscores the constraints afflicting reactive, episodic cooperation in the face of protracted displacement. Keywords: Indochinese refugee, Indonesia, refugee crisis, refugee governance, Rohingya refugee, Southeast Asia
Indonesia and ASEAN’s Refugee Deadlock: Between Regional Commitments and National Sovereignty Atin Prabandari; Emma Seruni Ketaren; Balya Arung Segara
Indonesian Perspective Vol 10, No 2 (2025): (Desember 2025)
Publisher : Universitas Diponegoro

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.14710/ip.v10i2.76956

Abstract

This paper critically evaluates Indonesia’s involvement with ASEAN in the governance of refugees, contextualizing this within a regional impasse associated with an enduring prioritization of national sovereignty over collective obligations to promote humanitarian response. The paper examines Indonesia’s participation in the Bali Process, its bilateral refugee management efforts and its response to the Rohingya crisis to assess whether Indonesia is a positive or negative influence on the development of a cohesive ASEAN refugee framework. The results underscore the fragmented nature of ASEAN’s approach, driven by the principles of non-interference, the securitization of migration, and the lack of binding legal obligations, that stand in the way of the development of a structured and rights-based approach to asylum. As high-profile as Indonesia has been in demonstrating humanitarian leadership in some crises, it adopts restrictive domestic asylum policies that preclude engagement in foreign policy advocacy for regional solutions. The study contends that unless the region is able to transcend sovereignty-based limitations and adopt necessary institutional reforms, ASEAN’s standing regarding refugee governance will remain compromised.
Affective Pragmatism: Political Memory, Emotions, and Indonesia's Selective Humanitarianism in Refugee Governance Atin Prabandari; Balya A. Segara; Emma Seruni Ketaren
Nation State: Journal of International Studies Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): Political Memory, Emotions, and the Politics of Exclusion in IR
Publisher : Faculty of Economics and Social Science, Department of International Relations, Universitas Amikom Yogyakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.24076/nsjis.v9i1.2675

Abstract

This article explores Indonesia’s ambivalent approach to refugee governance through the concept of “Affective Pragmatism.” This concept addresses the tension, which is not accidental but structural, between emotion-driven humanitarian commitments and fear-based concerns regarding border security. While the 1951 Refugee, Convention calls for universal protection, Indonesia promotes humanitarian diplomacy, at the regional level through the Bali process, while maintaining tight control over domestic asylum policies. Drawing on constructivist and postcolonial theory, this article seeks to demonstrate how political memory, particularly the legacy of the 1955 Bandung Conference, has shaped Indonesia’s affective response to various humanitarian crises. In this article, the Rohingya are incorporated into a shared narrative of empathy and postcolonial trauma, while other illegal migrants face indifference and rejection. By linking affective pragmatism to debates on the contestation of norms and the politics of exclusion, this article offers a framework for understanding how emotions and memory create an uneven landscape of protection and contribute to the evolving debate on refugee governance in Global South countries, including Indonesia.
Indonesia and ASEAN’s Refugee Deadlock: Between Regional Commitments and National Sovereignty Atin Prabandari; Emma Seruni Ketaren; Balya Arung Segara
Indonesian Perspective Vol 10, No 2 (2025): (Desember 2025)
Publisher : Universitas Diponegoro

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.14710/ip.v10i2.76956

Abstract

This paper critically evaluates Indonesia’s involvement with ASEAN in the governance of refugees, contextualizing this within a regional impasse associated with an enduring prioritization of national sovereignty over collective obligations to promote humanitarian response. The paper examines Indonesia’s participation in the Bali Process, its bilateral refugee management efforts and its response to the Rohingya crisis to assess whether Indonesia is a positive or negative influence on the development of a cohesive ASEAN refugee framework. The results underscore the fragmented nature of ASEAN’s approach, driven by the principles of non-interference, the securitization of migration, and the lack of binding legal obligations, that stand in the way of the development of a structured and rights-based approach to asylum. As high-profile as Indonesia has been in demonstrating humanitarian leadership in some crises, it adopts restrictive domestic asylum policies that preclude engagement in foreign policy advocacy for regional solutions. The study contends that unless the region is able to transcend sovereignty-based limitations and adopt necessary institutional reforms, ASEAN’s standing regarding refugee governance will remain compromised.
Externalized Borders, Internalized Control: The Politics of Detention in Indonesia-Australia Migration Governance Mohammad Nashiir; Atin Prabandari
Sospol Vol. 12 No. 2 (2026): July-December
Publisher : Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/jurnalsospol.v13i1.45117

Abstract

This journal article analyzes the internalization of Australian border controls within Indonesia's immigration detention governance. The primary research focus is the active agency of domestic authorities, which has been largely overlooked in existing literature. Utilizing a qualitative method with a case study of Rudenim Tanjungpinang, a facility occupying a crucial migration corridor between both nations, this study uncovers the strategies of local actors exploiting external funding for national interests. The conceptual framework integrates border externalization, strategic non-regulation, and migrant rentierism to dissect data from journals, books, policy documents, and official reports. Findings demonstrate that through regulatory ambiguity, Indonesian officials successfully assert territorial sovereignty while extracting political and financial benefits from Australia. Consequently, Rudenim Tanjungpinang operates as a hybrid control apparatus, shifting external containment into domestic management. Beyond these mutual state benefits, asylum seekers endure the tragic consequence of being trapped in prolonged limbo. This inquiry underscores that transit states are proactive strategic agents within the global political economy of migration. Due to specific facility data limitations, the depth of analysis is carefully situated within broader national and bilateral migration patterns.
Beyond the Western Gaze: Islamic Humanitarianism and the Decolonization of Global Aid Atin Prabandari
QIJIS (Qudus International Journal of Islamic Studies) Vol 14, No 1 (2026)
Publisher : IAIN Kudus

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21043/qijis.v14i1.32221

Abstract

This  study  examines  the  extent  to  which  Islamic  humanitarianism  can counterbalance  Western-dominated  norms  and  structures  of  global  aid. Combining  decolonial  theory  with  norm  localization,  it  develops  the  concept  of localized  universalism  to  explain  how  Islamic  humanitarian  actors  articulate independently  grounded  universal  ethical  commitments  while  selectively engaging  with  international  humanitarian  standards.  The  study  employs  a qualitative  document  and  literature  review  of  scholarly  works  published primarily  between  2000  and  2025,  including  literature,  organizational  reports, zakat  statistics,  regulations,  and  fatwas  on  Islamic  humanitarian  actors  in Indonesia  and  beyond.  It  also  includes  illustrative  cases  involving Muhammadiyah,  Nahdlatul  Ulama,  Islamic  Relief  Worldwide,  Dompet Dhuafa, BAZNAS, mosque-based philanthropy, and the UNHCR Refugee Zakat Fund. The findings  reveal  three  interrelated  patterns.  First,  Islamic  actors  re-ground humanitarian values in Islamic traditions, such as humanity, solidarity, and non- discrimination,  in  Islamic ethical  and  jurisprudential  traditions,  exemplified  by Muhammadiyah’s  al-Ma’un theology  and  Fikih  Kebencanaan.  Second,  Islamic social finance—including zakat, infaq, sadaqah, and waqf— provides substantial and  recurrent  humanitarian  resources,  although  these  remain  predominantly domestically  oriented  and  under-realized  relative  to  their  estimated  potential. Third, authority rarely shifts to Muslim communities; legitimacy is conferred by certifiers,  UNHCR,  and  the  Indonesian  state.  The  article  terms  this  pattern “localized  universalism”:  epistemically  rich  but  structurally  limited decolonization.  These  findings  contribute  to  debates  on  decolonizing humanitarianism  by  shifting  attention  from  the  localization  of  aid  delivery toward  the  deeper  question  of  who  possesses  the  authority  to  define humanitarian universality.
Indonesia’s Foreign Policy on Palestine and the Rohingya: Affective Solidarity and Strategic Ambivalence Atin Prabandari; Arief Bakhtiar Darmawan
Global Strategis Vol. 20 No. 1 (2026): Global Strategis
Publisher : Department of International Relations, Faculty of Social and Political Science, Universitas Airlangga

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.20473/jgs.20.1.2026.71-94

Abstract

Indonesia’s foreign policy has long carried a language of solidarity, especially toward oppressed Muslim communities such as the Palestinians and the Rohingya. While existing scholarship tends to explain Indonesia’s foreign policy through normative, religious, or strategic orientations, it has largely neglected the role of emotions in shaping foreign policy orientation. The article employs a post-positivist analytical lens—Affective Foreign Policy Analysis—to examine Indonesia's emotions in two case studies: the Palestinian Case and the Rohingya Crisis. The emotions considered are solidarity, compassion, pride, and ambivalence. In the Palestinian case, Indonesia has consistently taken a firm stance, drawing on its own parallelism and the emotional resonance of Islamic solidarity. In contrast, Indonesia has displayed a more ambivalent stand over the Rohingya crisis: strong affective mobilization at the societal level and yet restrained and selective humanitarianism at the state level, limited by sovereignty concerns and Indonesia’s non-signatory status to the 1951 Refugee Convention. Through comparative case studies analysis, the article argues that emotions sustain Indonesia’s foreign policy discourse while exposing gaps between solidarity and strategy within institutional constraints. The article concludes that understanding Global South foreign policy requires taking the role of emotions seriously as central mediators between ideals and interests. Keywords: Indonesia’s foreign policy, Palestine, Rohingya, Affective solidarity, Strategic ambivalence. Kajian yang ada kerap merasionalisasi kebijakan luar negeri Indonesia dengan komitmen normatif, identitas agama, atau kepentingan strategis pragmatisnya, pembahasan terhadap peran emosi dalam membatasi pilihan nasional masih terlalu minim. Artikel ini menggunakan lensa analitis pasca-positivis—analisis kebijakan luar negeri afektif—untuk membaca emosi dalam tanggapan Indonesia terhadap dua studi kasus, yaitu Palestina dan krisis Rohingya. Ada perbedaan sikap yang ditunjukkan Indonesia dalam kasus Palestina, lantaran adanya emosi yang bersifat paralel dan menggetarkan solidaritas Islam. Sebaliknya, Indonesia cenderung ambivalen terhadap krisis Rohingya. Melalui analisis komparatif, artikel ini berasumsi bahwa emosi dapat menjadi pendorong kuat bagi narasi kebijakan luar negeri Indonesia, sekaligus mengungkap kesenjangan antara solidaritas dan strategi dalam batasan kelembagaan. Artikel ini menyimpulkan bahwa dalam memahami kebijakan luar negeri Selatan-Selatan, diperlukan tanggapan serius terhadap emosi sebagai mediator utama antara cita-cita dan kepentingan. Kata-kata Kunci: Kebijakan luar negeri Indonesia, Palestina, Rohingya, Solidaritas afektif, Ambivalensi strategis.