Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 26 Documents
Search

Hierarki Pengetahuan Gaib dalam Pemikiran Ibn Khaldun: Analisis Epistemologis atas Wahyu, Kasyf, dan Perdukunan Afidah Wahyuni; Abdul Hakim Wahid; Rahmat Hidayatullah
Paradigma: Jurnal Kalam dan Filsafat Vol. 7 No. 2 (2025): Paradigma: Jurnal Kalam dan Filsafat
Publisher : Faculty of Ushuluddin Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15408/paradigma.v7i2.46904

Abstract

This article examines the hierarchy of unseen knowledge in Ibn Khaldun’s thought by focusing on prophetic revelation, Sufi kashf, and divination. It employs library research and conceptual analysis, using the Muqaddimah as its primary source and scholarly works on Ibn Khaldun’s epistemology as secondary materials. The study demonstrates that Ibn Khaldun does not assign an equal epistemological status to all forms of knowledge concerning the unseen. Their differences are determined by the quality of the soul, source of knowledge, mode of reception, validity, and moral orientation of the recipient. Revelation occupies the highest level because it derives from the natural preparedness of the prophetic soul and divine assistance. Kashf is attained through spiritual discipline and is considered valid only when grounded in moral and religious rectitude. Divination occupies the lowest level because it relies on psychic ability, imagination, celestial objects, or demonic forces. These categories therefore constitute both an epistemological and a moral hierarchy.
Kualitas Kitab Al-Shahihain Abdul Hakim Wahid
Ushuluna: Jurnal Ilmu Ushuluddin Vol. 3 No. 2 (2017)
Publisher : Faculty of Ushuluddin UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15408/ushuluna.v3i2.15195

Abstract

Artikel ini menjelaskan tentang dampak tadlis dalam sahih Bukhari dan Muslim terhadap kedudukan kedua Kitab tersebut sebagai asahhu al-kutub ba’da al-Qur’an. Kitab Sahihain merupakan dua kitab induk dalam hadis yang paling autentik karena syarat dan selektifitas imam Bukhari dan imam Muslim dalam mengumpulkan hadis yang terdapat di dalamnya. Metode yang digunakan dalam artikel ini adalah analisis deskriptif dengan menganalisa dan mendeskripsikan riwayatriwayat yang mengandung tadlis dan melihat implikasi riwayat tersebut terhadap kedudukan kitab sahihain. Meskipun ditemukannya sejumlah hadis yang bermasalah di dalam sahih Bukhari dan Muslim, ternyata persoalan ini tidak berdampak pada penurunan kedudukan dua kitab ini sebagai kitab hadis yang paling autentik.
Testing the Consistency of G.H.A. Juynboll’s Determination of Common Link Narrators: An Analysis of the Encyclopedia of Canonical Hadith Silfiani Silfiani; Abdul Hakim Wahid; Ummi Kalsum
Al Irsyad: Jurnal Studi Islam Vol. 5 No. 1 (2026): Al Irsyad: Jurnal Studi Islam
Publisher : STAI Publisistik Thawalib Jakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.54150/alirsyad.v5i1.1057

Abstract

Inconsistency in Juynboll’s classification of Common Link and Seeming Common Link narrators compared to his theory and classical evaluations. This study aims to examine the consistency of Juynboll’s identification of Common Link and Seeming Common Link narrators in his work. This study uses a qualitative library research approach with descriptive-analytical methods, analyzing isn?d reconstruction from the Encyclopedia of Canonical Hadith and supporting literature on rij?l al-?ad?th and jar? wa ta?d?l. The findings reveal that Juynboll’s application of the common link theory in the Encyclopedia of Canonical Hadith is not entirely consistent. Among the seven narrators examined, four narrators correspond to his classification of Common Link (CL) and Seeming Common Link (SCL) based on reconstructed isn?d transmission patterns. However, three narrators do not align with his criteria due to differences in transmission structures and their positions within sanad networks. Furthermore, several narrators classified by Juynboll as fabricators of hadith are considered trustworthy (thiqah) by classical scholars of jar? wa ta?d?l. These results indicate methodological inconsistencies and significant divergence between Orientalist approaches and classical Islamic hadith scholarship. Conclusion: Juynboll’s common link theory demonstrates inconsistencies in application, requiring reassessment through classical and isn?d-based analytical perspectives. This study contributes to critical hadith scholarship by evaluating Orientalist methodology and strengthening sanad-based analytical approaches in Islamic studies.
A New Paradigm of Common Link Theory in Contemporary Hadith Studies Abdul Hakim Wahid; Harun Rasyid
Millati: Journal of Islamic Studies and Humanities Vol. 9 No. 1 (2024): MILLATI
Publisher : Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Salatiga

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.18326/millati.v9i1.544

Abstract

This article aims to explore the theory of common links in contemporary hadith research which was used differently from the beginning of its invention by Joseph Schacht and developed by Juynboll, who focuses only on discovering the originator or person in charge of the dissemination of a hadith. By using qualitative research with a historical approach, this article concludes that in the current context, the common link theory can be used to strengthen the authenticity of the prophet’s hadith because by using the source of the entire hadith book, a person with a common link status will be signed to a companion and even the prophet himself. Given the analysis that has been provided, it is clear that hadith scholars who are Muslim and non-Muslim have taken a keen interest in and debated Joseph Schacht's common link thesis, which Juynboll further expanded. Individual religious beliefs significantly influence the implementation and acceptance of the theory, resulting in differing degrees of support and criticism. There is no denying the common connection phenomena among isnad systems, even if many Muslim academics have widely rejected it. This research indicates that the common link theory can be used to support the veracity of particular hadiths, in contrast to some objections. Its potential utility in hadith validation is highlighted by the research, which finds cases in which the common link is attributed to the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and his associates.
Pluralisasi dan Peredaran Pengetahuan dalam Studi Hadis Barat dan Indonesia, 2010–2020 Abdul Hakim Wahid; Aep Saepulloh; Muh. Akbar Nasrulah
Refleksi: Jurnal Kajian Agama dan Filsafat Vol. 25 No. 1 (2026)
Publisher : Faculty of Ushuluddin Syarif Hidayatullah State Islamic University, Jakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15408/refleksi.v25.i1.50560

Abstract

This article compares selected works in Western Islamic Studies and Indonesian hadith scholarship published between 2010 and 2020 to examine changes in research objects, evidentiary practices, and knowledge circulation in contemporary hadith studies. Previous scholarship has largely framed their relationship through debates on hadith authenticity, often overlooking shifts in research objects and analytical procedures. Using a comparative literature-based approach, this study analyzes selected publications in terms of their research objects, sources, forms of evidence, and modes of inference. The findings show that both academic environments experienced a broadening of research objects and procedures. Within Islamic Studies, hadith research expanded beyond source criticism to include commentary traditions, manuscripts, transmission, authority, and reception. In Indonesia, similar developments are reflected in methodological debates, mappings of scholarship and publication trends, curriculum studies, and living hadith research. Differences in publication language, genre, and publishing channels indicate patterns of asymmetrical knowledge circulation, although the extent of such asymmetry is not measured in this study. The findings suggest that the relationship between the two environments is better understood as a process of intellectual exchange and adaptation rather than merely a response to debates over authenticity.
The Reorientation of Western Hadith Studies (2010–2020): Authenticity and Contextual Reconstruction Abdul Hakim Wahid; Aep Saepulloh; Bustamin; Syifa Mauliza
Al-Zahra : Journal for Islamic and Arabic Studies Vol. 23 No. 1 (2026): Al-Zahra: Journal for Islamic and Arabic Studies
Publisher : Fakultas Dirasat Islamiyah, Univitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15408/zr.v23i1.54353

Abstract

This article examines the changing orientation of Western hadith studies during the period 2010–2020. Although debates over hadith authenticity remain an important theme, the question of authenticity alone is no longer considered sufficient to explain how hadith authority is constructed, how commentary (sharḥ) traditions develop, and how reports are used in diverse intellectual contexts. This study aims to investigate the changing position of authenticity as a research problem and to analyze the relationship between source criticism and contextual reconstruction in contemporary hadith scholarship. The research employs a qualitative library-based approach using intellectual history and comparative analysis. The primary corpus consists of twenty-three purposively selected academic publications. Each work is examined through five analytical indicators: research object, research question, type of evidence, method of analysis, and scope of conclusions. The findings reveal four overlapping areas of inquiry: the evaluation of hadith dating methods, the relationship between hadith, law, and scholarly authority, manuscript and commentary studies, and reflections on the limits of historical inference. This classification is not intended to describe a universal developmental sequence for the entire field of Western hadith studies. Rather, it serves as an analytical framework for interpreting the selected corpus. The study demonstrates that authenticity has not disappeared from contemporary hadith scholarship. In some works, authenticity remains the primary objective of research, while in others it functions as a starting point for investigating the history of transmission, usage, and interpretation of hadith. Based on these findings, the article proposes a model of contextual reconstruction that connects research questions with the evidence employed and the limits of the claims that may be drawn from it. The proposed model offers a more balanced framework for assessing arguments across different methodological approaches without reducing methodological differences to conflicts of academic identity.