Background: Evidence-based inventory decisions are essential for food processing SMEs, yet owner-managers often rely on intuition rather than systematic data analysis. This study examined the distinct associations of data literacy and analytical self-efficacy with evidence-based inventory decision practices. Methods: A cross-sectional survey involved 180 food processing SME owner-managers in Tulungagung Regency, Indonesia. Data literacy was assessed using an eight-item scenario-based test, while analytical self-efficacy and inventory decision practices were measured using five-item scales. Multiple linear regression with HC3 robust standard errors controlled for management experience and enterprise size. Results: Data literacy (B = 0.149, β = .37, p < .001) and analytical self-efficacy (B = 0.251, β = .24, p < .001) were independently and positively associated with evidence-based inventory practices, explaining an additional 20.9% of variance beyond control variables (ΔR² = .209). Their weak, nonsignificant correlation (r = .13, p = .076) indicated that analytical competence and confidence were empirically distinguishable. Conclusion: Data literacy and analytical self-efficacy represent distinct factors associated with evidence-based inventory decisions. Improving SME inventory management requires strengthening both practical data interpretation skills and confidence in applying analytical insights.