cover
Contact Name
-
Contact Email
-
Phone
-
Journal Mail Official
-
Editorial Address
-
Location
Kota depok,
Jawa barat
INDONESIA
Policy & Governance Review
ISSN : -     EISSN : -     DOI : -
This journal encompasses issues and practices in policy analysis, public management, public policy and administration. PGR provides high quality study outcomes and new thoughts for academic practitioners, researchers, scientists and consultants to discuss about social science theories and concepts to significant political, economic and social issues and to the ways in which public policies are made.
Arjuna Subject : -
Articles 189 Documents
Automated Decision-Making and the Transformation of Bureaucratic Discretion:A Cross-Sector Systematic Review of Empirical Evidence Adissa Nayla Putri; Alvi Syahrina
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 2 (2026): May
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i2.1391

Abstract

Automated decision-making (ADM) is becoming a significant feature of contempo- rary public administration, with major implications for how bureaucratic decisions are made and discretion exercised. Existing scholarship has mostly examined ADM within single sectors, leaving a limited cross-sector understanding of how discretion shifts across policy domains. This article addresses this gap by analyzing how empir- ical studies describe changes in bureaucratic discretion after ADM implementation across sectors. Using a systematic literature review of 21 empirical studies published between 2020 and 2025, this study discovers and examines five sectors: social wel- fare and public health, labor market governance, administrative systems, policing, and judicial decision-making. The findings show that ADM does not transform dis- cretion uniformly but reconfigures it according to the sectoral decision structures. Three analytical dimensions were identified: level of automation, level of shift, and type of shift. Highly standardized sectors, such as labor market governance, show stronger automation and a greater curtailment of discretion. The social welfare, ad- ministrative, and judicial sectors retain stronger human involvement because of their contextual complexity, accountability, and reviewability. Policing shows the strongest continuity of discretion owing to situational judgment and professional autonomy. Overall, this study contributes to ADM scholarship by offering a cross-sector perspec- tive on bureaucratic discretion and suggesting that public organizations tailor ADM design and implementation to sector-specific decision logics to preserve accountabili-ty and meaningful human judgment.
Democracy Governance and Human Security in Nigeria: A Need for Recap Yemi Daniel Ogundare; Yushau Sulaiman Abubakar Alfakoro
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 2 (2026): May
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i2.1369

Abstract

The relationship between democracy and human security is often assumed to be mutually reinforcing, with democratic governance expected to promote citizens’ welfare, political freedom, and socioeconomic well-being. However, the Nigerian experience presents a significant puzzle: despite more than two decades of uninterrupted democratic rule since 1999, the country continues to experience persistent poverty, insecurity, unemployment, food insecurity, weak healthcare systems, and a decline in public trust in governance. This study investigates why democratic governance has not translated into meaningful human security outcomes in Nigeria, despite the institutional presence of democratic structures and processes. This study is anchored in Human Security Theory and adopts a qualitative case study approach. Data were obtained from semi-structured interviews, focus group discussions, and relevant secondary sources, including policy documents, journal articles, government reports and other scholarly materials. The data were analyzed thematically. The findings reveal that the relationship between democracy and human security in Nigeria is mediated by weak institutional capacity, poor governance quality, policy discontinuity, elite-driven political behavior, and inadequate implementation of development programmes. While democratic administrations have introduced various policies aimed at improving citizens’ welfare, these initiatives have produced limited results owing to governance failures and institutional weaknesses that undermine the effective delivery of public goods and services. The study argues that democracy is a necessary but insufficient condition for human security, as the benefits of democratic governance can only be realized when supported by effective institutions, accountability, policy consistency, and citizen-oriented governance practices. This study contributes to the democracy-human security debate by demonstrating that the persistence of human security challenges in Nigeria is not primarily a consequence of democracy itself, but of the weak institutional mechanisms through which democratic governance is implemented. The study recommends strengthening governance institutions, improving accountability mechanisms, ensuring policy continuity, and adopting a comprehensive human security framework that simultaneously addresses freedom from fear and want.
E-Government, Governance Quality, and Control of Corruption in ECOWAS: A Governance-System Perspective Kerkulah P Nyeleker; Achmad Nurmandi; Chinyabuuma Bengibabuya Esther; Ruth Kunda; Herman Lawelai
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 2 (2026): May
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i2.1374

Abstract

Corruption remains a persistent challenge to governance and sustainable development across Africa. This study examines the relationship between e-government develop- ment, governance quality, and control of corruption in the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) member states. It investigates whether digital reforms can substitute for weak institutions in strengthening control of corruption or wheth- er their effectiveness depends on governance quality. A quantitative cross-sectional design was employed using secondary data from the United Nations E-Government Development Index and the Worldwide Governance Indicators for the twelve active ECOWAS countries. Descriptive statistics, Pearson correlation, and multiple regression analysis were conducted using SPSS version 17.0. The findings reveal that both e-gov- ernment development and governance quality are positively associated with control of corruption, with governance quality exhibiting the stronger institutional relationship. The results further indicate that e-government development and governance quality function as complementary components of a broader governance system rather than as competing determinants. The study advances a governance-system perspective by demonstrating that the anti-corruption potential of e-government is conditioned by governance quality. Digital reforms therefore complement, rather than substitute for, strong governance institutions in strengthening corruption control, with implications for governance reform across ECOWAS and comparable contexts.
From Form to Function: Isomorphic Mimicry, Planned Development Endeavors, and Implementation Outcomes in Nepal’s Federal Periodic Planning Baburam Bhul
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 2 (2026): May
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i2.1375

Abstract

Despite nearly seven decades of periodic development planning experience, imple- mentation gaps remain pervasive and hinder the attainment of the planned devel- opment outcomes. While the literature has established that actual outcomes have differed significantly from the targets specified in development plans, the institution- al processes underpinning this chronic implementation problem have been studied less systematically. This study examines Nepal’s periodic planning regime, from the First Five-Year Plan (1956–1961) to the Fifteenth Periodic Plan (2019/20–2023/24), through the interpretive frame of isomorphic mimicry. Relying on a qualitative lon- gitudinal design, this study uses documentary analysis and process tracing to investi- gate changes in planning institutions, governance reform efforts, and implementation outcomes over time. This study operationalizes the concept of isomorphic mimicry through four observable indicators: the adoption of internationally propagated plan- ning models, an increase in the number of formal planning institutions, the presence of persistent plan-performance gaps, and repeated institutional reforms without cor- responding improvements in implementation capabilities. The findings show that as Nepal’s periodic plans became more integrated into global development objectives, literacy, poverty, human development, and income per capita improved. However, implementation capability trailed substantially behind the plan’s aspirations through- out. The study emphasizes the argument for planning-related isomorphism and demonstrates that improving institutional skills is an essential condition for trans- forming planning objectives into meaningful development outcomes.
What Drives Governance Reversal and How Does it Reshape State–Society Relations in Indonesia Mujibur Rahman Khairul Muluk; Sajida Sajida
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 3 (2026): September
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i3.1395

Abstract

This study investigates governance reversal as a failure-driven institutional reconfig- uration, through which decentralized, networked, or collaborative arrangements are re-centralized under state authority. This study combines a systematic literature re- view with a document-based qualitative analysis of three Indonesian policy domains: halal certification reform, the Makan Bergizi Gratis (MBG) program, and military involvement in food governance through territorial development battalions. This article formalizes a failure-reversal framework by mapping the sequence of failure, political interpretation, and institutional reconfiguration onto four analytical dimen- sions: institutional change, authority shift, policy justification, and governance mode. The framework also identifies two possible outcome pathways: corrective capacity, where state reassertion improves coordination and implementation, and pathological centralization, where reassertion intensifies executive dominance, symbolic institu- tionalism, and accountability deficits. The Indonesian cases are treated as purposively selected, maximum-variation illustrative cases rather than as a basis for an uncon- ditional empirical generalization. Therefore, governance reversal is proposed as an analytically transferable but scope-conditioned concept for studying how governance failures reshape state-society relations.
Gender Mainstreaming in Infrastructure Development : A Case Study of the Klaten– Prambanan Toll Road Project Sri Mulyani; Matheus Gratiano Mali; Reza Noormansyah; Tri Yuningsih
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 3 (2026): September
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i3.1303

Abstract

Infrastructure is often associated with the concept of development and seldom with the concept of social justice such as gender equality. This study seeks to analyze gen- der inequality in the construction of the Klaten-Prambanan toll road by presenting the experience stories of the affected women. In theory‚ this study adds to the few empirical studies on gender mainstreaming in infrastructure development in Indone- sia‚ and in practice‚ adds to the body of knowledge on making development planning more gender-just in Indonesia. This qualitative case study is based on in-depth inter- views‚ limited observation‚ document analysis‚ and thematic analysis. Some of the ad- verse impacts‚ including increased domestic work due to environmental degradation‚ loss of informal economic opportunities‚ lack of access to project-related jobs‚ and ex- clusion from project planning and decision making‚ are disproportionately borne by women. The aspirations of women seem to be channeled through male intermediaries instead of being directly solicited and responded to in a systematic manner. How- ever‚ gender mainstreaming suffers at project level and the paper concludes there are real policy gaps between gender equality norms and practice in infrastructure development. By focusing specifically on women’s experience‚ this study furthers a growing literature that recognizes that gender-responsive infrastructure is a necessary condition for achieving gender equality and also for sustainable development‚ and it highlights the importance of prioritizing women-centered participation and equita- ble‚ gender-sensitive remuneration in research.
The Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility on the Achievement of Sustainable Development in East Java: Community-Perception Evidence from Three Clusters of Industrial Intensity Asti Amelia Novita; Durratun Nashihah; Suhartono Winoto
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 3 (2026): September
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i3.1423

Abstract

Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is commonly assessed through corporate dis- closures, whereas the perspectives of people living around company operations re- main less visible. This study investigates whether residents’ perceptions of CSR are associated with perceived sustainable development in three East Java localities that represent contrasting industrial contexts. A cross-sectional survey produced 1,154 usable responses from resident’s familiar with local CSR programmes in Gresik Re- gency (n = 412), Malang City (n = 353), and Bojonegoro Regency (n = 389). Cova- riance-based structural equation modelling was combined with measurement-invari- ance tests and multigroup comparisons. Perceived CSR was positively associated with perceived sustainable development in each locality (p < 0.001). The association was weaker in Gresik than in Malang City and Bojonegoro, while the latter two did not differ significantly. Thus, the principal comparative finding distinguishes the high-in- dustry locality from the other two territorial settings rather than demonstrating a pro- gressive low-to-medium-to-high industrial-intensity gradient. Dimensional weights also varied across settings. The social dimension generally carried lower weights, but differences between loadings were not formally tested. These patterns are compati- ble with stakeholder and legitimacy perspectives, although the proposed explanatory mechanisms were not examined directly. Policy interpretation should therefore rely on context-sensitive assessment, community participation, and direct outcome indi- cators rather than treating factor loadings or R² as measures of programme perfor- mance or causal impact.
Administrative Justice in Public-Sector Automated Decision-Making Governance: A Systematic Review Setiawan Setiawan; Hernimawati Hernimawati; Trio Saputra
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 3 (2026): September
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i3.1400

Abstract

Public authorities are increasingly embracing automated decision making (ADM). The literature on legal mandates, organizational practice, and citizen results is mixed. This systematic review assesses the conceptualization of accountability, transparency, supervision by humans, and administrative justice in public sector ADM by scholarship and how protections are operationalized. The search in Scopus (PRISMA method) resulted in 122 entries and 56 qualifying full-text papers. The archive is dominated by doctrinal and socio-legal research (28/56) and European contexts (31/56). Conceptual and case studies are many but empirical qualitative [7] and quantitative [5] are limited. The gap between ideals and implementation is stark: literature describes more than safeguards for review, correction, and repair ADM governance ideals. Three conflicts are clearly emerging: formal accountability versus diffused responsibility, formal transparency versus useable cures, and formal oversight by humans versus intervention capacity. A four-layer diagnostic methodology is proposed: system traceability, administrative capability, institutional responsibility, and citizen-facing remedies. Cross-layer dependency matters: safeguards cannot work without complementary records, authority, review capability, or accessible remedies.
The Paradox of Electric Vehicle Policy in Indonesia A Systems Perspective Analysis Andreo Wahyudi Atmoko; Asputia Damayanti; Teoh Ai Ping
Policy & Governance Review Vol 10 No 3 (2026): September
Publisher : Indonesian Association for Public Administration

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30589/pgr.v10i3.1436

Abstract

As part of its plan to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, Indonesia has very supportive policies for electric vehicle (EV) users. This study investigates whether the technology that replaces internal combustion engines with electric vehicles (EVs) is sufficient to achieve the desired system emission levels for the mobility and energy subsystems. This study integrates academic literature, official statistics, policy documents, stake- holder documentary evidence, and causal loop diagrams (CLD) and system archetype modeling. This model is built at the national policy level and only incorporates ur- ban mechanisms below the national level that are relevant, without considering this context as a representation of Indonesia as a whole. In fact, the following analysis found the presence of a balancing mechanism, meaning that while electric vehicle subsidies can drive technology substitution and emission reduction, they can also re- veal reinforcing feedback on the growth of private vehicles, congestion, mode choice, sustainability of conventional vehicles, road development, and the condition of the electricity industry, which can mitigate the effects of electric vehicle subsidies. The following research can determine a structure consistent with the “Fixes That Fail” archetype and provide input to recalibrate subsidies for public transportation as a strategic leverage point to achieve more sustainable emission reductions and support Indonesia’s long-term goal of achieving Net Zero Emissions.