cover
Contact Name
Achmad Faiz
Contact Email
Jhr74201@gmail.com
Phone
+628577662255
Journal Mail Official
achmadfaiz8@gmail.com
Editorial Address
Fakultas Hukum Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang. JL. Mayjend. Sutoyo No. 2 Sukarasa, Kota Tangerang, 15111, Banten, Indonesia
Location
Kota tangerang,
Banten
INDONESIA
JHR (Jurnal Hukum Replik)
ISSN : 23379251     EISSN : 25979094     DOI : 10.31000
Core Subject : Social,
The aim Jurnal Hukum Replik is venue for academicians, researchers, and practitioners for publishing their original research articles or review articles. The scope of the articles published in this journal deals with a broad range of topics in the fields of constitutional law, criminal law, civic law, administrative law, agrrian law, medical law and interconnection study with Legal Studies in accordance with the principle of novelty
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 166 Documents
From Legal Certainty to Procedural Justice: Reconstructing The Philosophy of Indonesian Procedural Law Deny Guntara; Muhamad Abas
Jurnal Hukum Replik Vol 14 No 02 (2026): Jurnal Hukum Replik
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31000/5j9y1n24

Abstract

Procedural law plays a crucial role in ensuring that law enforcement is not only conducted in an orderly and legally certain manner but also operates fairly for all parties involved. Indonesian procedural law has long demonstrated a strong orientation toward legal certainty, reflected in its emphasis on jurisdiction, procedural requirements, limitation periods, evidentiary rules, legal remedies, and the finality of judicial decisions. Such certainty remains indispensable; however, compliance with procedural rules does not necessarily correspond to fairness in the legal process. This study aims to analyze the dominance of the legal certainty paradigm in the construction of Indonesian procedural law and to reconstruct its underlying philosophy toward a stronger orientation to procedural justice. The study employs a normative-doctrinal legal research method using statutory, philosophical, conceptual, case, and comparative approaches. The analysis examines developments in Indonesian criminal and civil procedural law, relevant judicial decisions, Gustav Radbruch’s conception of legal certainty, justice, and utility, Tom R. Tyler’s theory of procedural justice, and the concept of justice as fairness. The findings demonstrate that legal certainty remains an essential foundation for limiting the exercise of power and preserving procedural order, but it is insufficient unless accompanied by a meaningful opportunity to be heard, neutrality of decision-makers, a balanced position between the parties, and access to effective remedies. The novelty of this study lies in the construction of a procedural justice-oriented model of procedural law, built upon four elements: procedural clarity, meaningful participation, procedural impartiality, and effective remedy. This reconstruction positions legal certainty not as the ultimate objective of procedural law, but as a foundation for a judicial process that is more just, participatory, impartial, and effective.  Keywords legal certainty; procedural justice; procedural law; procedural fairness; legal philosophy; effective remedy
Inequality Between Parties In The Industrial Relations Court: Reconstructing Equality of Arms Between Workers and Employers Muhamad Abas; Deny Guntara
Jurnal Hukum Replik Vol 14 No 02 (2026): Jurnal Hukum Replik
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31000/zb85qj65

Abstract

Inequality between workers and employers in the settlement of industrial relations disputes stems not only from disparities in economic power but may also arise from procedural rules that formally treat both parties equally while overlooking their differing practical capacities to access judicial forums, manage procedural time constraints, navigate procedural stages, and produce evidence. This study aims to examine the forms of procedural inequality between workers and employers before the Industrial Relations Court and to reconstruct the principle of equality of arms as a normative basis for reforming the procedural law governing industrial relations dispute resolution in Indonesia. This study employs a normative-doctrinal legal research method using statutory, case, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The analysis focuses on Law No. 2 of 2004 and several Constitutional Court decisions issued in 2025–2026 concerning relative jurisdiction, time limits for filing claims, and mediation procedures. The findings demonstrate that formal equality does not necessarily result in genuine procedural equality. Procedural inequality manifests in four principal dimensions: access to judicial forums, procedural time arrangements, procedural stages, and evidentiary processes. Accordingly, the principle of equality of arms should not be confined to evidentiary matters but should serve as a comprehensive framework for designing the procedural law of the Industrial Relations Court. The novelty of this study lies in the concept of substantive equality of arms, comprising access equality, temporal equality, procedural equality, and evidentiary equality. This framework is intended to ensure that workers and employers are afforded a reasonable and effective opportunity to assert and defend their rights without placing either party at a substantial procedural disadvantage. Reform of Industrial Relations Court procedure should therefore move beyond formal equality toward substantive procedural equality while preserving legal certainty, judicial impartiality, and a fair balance between the interests of the parties. Keywords Industrial Relations Court; equality of arms; procedural justice; workers; employers; access to justice
From the Annulment of Administrative Decisions to the Restoration of Plaintiffs’ Rights in Indonesian Administrative Court Judgments Tri Cahya Indra Permana
Jurnal Hukum Replik Vol 14 No 1 (2026): Jurnal Hukum Replik
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31000/ekpr4c18

Abstract

The annulment of an unlawful administrative decision does not always restore the rights of a successful plaintiff. In Indonesian administrative justice, the consequences of an administrative decision may continue even after the decision has been declared invalid, creating a gap between formal judicial victory and substantive legal protection. This study examines how judgments of the State Administrative Court can move beyond annulment toward the effective restoration of plaintiffs’ rights. The research employs qualitative legal research combining doctrinal analysis, systematic case-law analysis, and a comparative functional approach. Primary legal materials include legislation, judicial decisions, Supreme Court regulations and guidelines, and official judicial reports up to 2024, while secondary materials consist of relevant scholarly literature on administrative remedies and effective judicial protection. The study finds that the effectiveness of administrative court judgments depends on three interconnected dimensions: remedial adequacy, remedial enforceability, and effective restoration. Annulment alone may be insufficient where the unlawful administrative act has already produced legal, economic, professional, or other factual consequences. The study also distinguishes between execution failure, which occurs when an adequate judgment is not implemented, and remedial failure, which arises when the judgment itself does not provide sufficient relief. The main contribution of this study is the development of a rights-restoration framework that shifts Indonesian administrative procedural law from an annulment-centred approach toward a model of effective judicial protection. Keywords administrative justice; State Administrative Court; judicial remedies; rights restoration; effective judicial protection
Legal Consequences of Debtor Default under a Leasing Agreement Based on Court Decision No. 69/Pdt.G.S/2022 Janis Makarimah; Yuniar Rahmatiar; Muhamad Abas
Jurnal Hukum Replik Vol 13 No 1 (2025): JURNAL HUKUM REPLIK
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31000/jamb4d65

Abstract

Default refers to the failure of a party to perform its contractual obligations in accordance with the terms agreed upon in a contract between a creditor and a debtor. Under Indonesian law, default is regulated under Article 1238 of the Indonesian Civil Code, which provides the legal basis for determining a debtor’s failure to perform contractual obligations. This study examines the legal consequences of default in leasing agreements and the judicial considerations applied in deciding leasing disputes, particularly in Court Decision No. 69/Pdt.G.S/2022/PN.Kwg. The study aims to analyze the legal consequences arising from default in leasing agreements and to examine the legal reasoning adopted by the judge in the aforementioned decision. This research employs a qualitative method using a normative juridical approach. The findings indicate that the legal consequences of default are governed by Article 1243 of the Indonesian Civil Code, which provides legal certainty by requiring the debtor to compensate the creditor for losses resulting from the breach of contractual obligations. Furthermore, the judge’s reasoning in Court Decision No. 69/Pdt.G.S/2022/PN.Kwg was legally justified, as the debtor was proven to have failed to fulfill its obligations as stipulated under Article 1238 of the Indonesian Civil Code. Keywords Default, Agreement, Leasing, Fiduciary Security.
LEGAL ANALYSIS OF INHERITANCE DISPUTE SETTLEMENT FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF CIVIL LAW AND CHINESE CUSTOMARY LAW (Study of Decision No. 54/Pdt.G/2020/PN.Mdn Jo Decision No. 22/Pdt/2021/PT MDN Decision Jo No.3539 K/Pdt/2022) Yolanda Br Sitanggang; Rungtung Sitepu; Rosnidar Sembiring
Jurnal Hukum Replik Vol 13 No 1 (2025): JURNAL HUKUM REPLIK
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31000/jhr.v13i1.13944

Abstract

This research analyzes the resolution of inheritance distribution disputes from the perspective of civil law and Chinese customary law through a case study of Decision No. 54/Pdt.G/2020/PN.Mdn Jo Decision No. 22/Pdt/2021/PT MDN Decision Jo No.3539 K/Pdt/2022. Using normative legal research methods, this study examines the position and rights of heirs between men and women according to the Indonesian Civil Code (KUHPerdata), which is egalitarian with equal distribution as regulated in Article 852, while Chinese customary law gives men a higher position due to their responsibility towards ancestors. The inheritance dispute in this case was resolved through litigation in court because family deliberation did not reach an agreement. The panel of judges decided on equal inheritance distribution (1/3 for each heir) based on the provisions of Article 852 of the Civil Code, ignoring Chinese customary traditions that give a larger portion to male children. This research shows that although the Chinese community can use civil inheritance law, in practice there are still conflicts between customary norms and the applicable positive law
A Critical Examination of the Electronic Evidence Mechanism in Indonesian Procedural Law Amalul Arifin Slamet
Jurnal Hukum Replik Vol 13 No 1 (2025): JURNAL HUKUM REPLIK
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Tangerang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.31000/jhr.v13i1.14827

Abstract

The digital era has profoundly transformed the Indonesian judicial system, particularly in the realm of evidentiary law. The emergence of electronic evidence such as digital documents, online communications, and electronic transactions has enriched the evidentiary framework while simultaneously presenting significant challenges concerning authenticity, integrity, and admissibility. Although the Electronic Information and Transactions Law formally recognizes electronic evidence, inconsistencies arise due to its disharmony with procedural codes such as the Criminal Procedure Code, Het Herziene Indonesisch Reglement (HIR), and Rechtsreglement Buitengewesten (RBg), which remain oriented toward conventional forms of proof. This normative-comparative legal study employs statute, case, and comparative approaches, analyzing Indonesian regulations, judicial decisions, and international standards including the UNCITRAL Model Law, the EU e-Evidence Regulation, and practices in the United States and Singapore. The findings reveal that Indonesia’s regulatory framework remains fragmented, lacking uniform technical standards, forensic capacity, and judicial readiness to effectively assess electronic evidence. Comparative analysis demonstrates that advanced jurisdictions have developed integrated mechanisms such as electronic discovery (U.S.), technology courts (Singapore), and trust service regulations (EU), which ensure greater certainty and reliability. The study argues for comprehensive reform through harmonization of procedural laws, establishment of clear forensic and authentication standards, enhancement of judicial and law enforcement capacity, and adoption of best practices in line with global developments. Strengthening the electronic evidence mechanism is crucial to safeguard legal certainty, fairness, and due process in Indonesia’s judicial system.Keywords: Electronic Evidence, Indonesian Procedural Law, Digital Forensics, Fair Trial, Legal Reform