cover
Contact Name
Auliya Ghazna Nizami
Contact Email
auliyanizami@uinsa.ac.id
Phone
+6281915490279
Journal Mail Official
jurnalkomparatif@uinsa.ac.id
Editorial Address
Jl. Ahmad Yani No.117, Jemur Wonosari, Kec. Wonocolo, Surabaya, Jawa Timur 60237
Location
Kota surabaya,
Jawa timur
INDONESIA
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam
ISSN : -     EISSN : 30261643     DOI : https://doi.org/10.15642/komparatif.v3i2
The Komparatif furnishes an international and regional scholarly forum for research on Comparative Mazahib, Law, and Islamic Thought. Taking an expansive view of the subject, the journal brings together all disciplinary perspectives. It publishes peer-reviewed articles on the historical, cultural, social, philosophical, political, anthropological, literary, artistic and other aspects of Comparative Mazahib, Law, and Islamic Thought in all times and places.
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 60 Documents
Marital Status after Apostasy: A Socio-Legal Analysis of Fiqh and the Compilation of Islamic Law in Kayu Kebek Village, Pasuruan Luthfillah, Sulthon Nahar
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 1 (2025): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i1.2585

Abstract

Apostasy after marriage raises complex questions concerning the continuity and legal status of the marital relationship. Classical Islamic jurisprudence generally recognizes religious conversion by one spouse as a basis for marital separation, although the four Sunni schools differ regarding its timing and legal consequences. Indonesian Islamic family law presents a different configuration. The Compilation of Islamic Law (Kompilasi Hukum Islam/KHI) addresses apostasy in Article 75(a) within the framework of marriage annulment, and in Article 116(h) as a ground for divorce when religious conversion results in household disharmony. This study examines how marital status is understood when one spouse returns to a previous religion after marriage and how this situation is situated between classical fiqh and the KHI. Employing a qualitative socio-legal case study, the research combines doctrinal analysis with interviews with three couples in Kayu Kebek Village, Tutur District, Pasuruan Regency. The findings indicate that all three couples maintained their marriages despite one spouse's religious conversion and did not perceive it as causing serious household disharmony. This finding reveals a tension between classical fiqh doctrines concerning marital separation and the procedural and contextual construction of marital dissolution under the KHI. The study argues that, within the Indonesian legal framework, the formal marital status of such couples cannot be inferred solely from apostasy; rather, it must be distinguished from its substantive legal consequences, the statutory grounds for divorce, and the judicial process by which marital status is formally determined.
Social Assistance and Electoral Bribery: A Comparative Analysis of Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah’s Islamic Legal Reasoning Nada, Nihalun; Sunan Umam, Zulfi; Musta'an Najikh, Ahmad
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 1 (2025): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i1.2597

Abstract

The distribution of social assistance for electoral purposes raises important questions concerning the boundaries between legitimate social welfare provision, electoral malpractice, and risywah (bribery) in Islamic law. This study examines how Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) and Muhammadiyah address the use of material assistance to influence electoral preferences and compares the legal reasoning underlying their respective positions. Employing a normative legal research design and library-based document analysis, the study examines relevant electoral regulations, Islamic legal sources, and published statements attributed to NU and Muhammadiyah scholars and institutions. The analysis focuses on the purpose of the distribution, the relationship between assistance and electoral influence, and the legal grounds used to assess the practice. The available materials indicate a shared rejection of electoral bribery and the instrumental use of assistance to influence voters. However, the institutional status of the statements and the specific legal reasoning attributed to each organization require careful differentiation. The central analytical issue is therefore not whether all assistance distributed during an election period is prohibited, but under what circumstances such assistance may be classified as risywah or electoral malpractice. This distinction is important for developing a more precise Islamic legal assessment of social assistance in electoral contexts.
From Reproductive Duty to Reproductive Agency: Reconstructing Women's Reproductive Rights through Musdah Mulia's Islamic Thought Aziz, Muhammad Hilmi
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 1 (2025): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i1.2656

Abstract

Women's reproductive rights remain contested within Islamic family law, particularly where reproductive decisions intersect with marital obligations, bodily autonomy, and the preservation of lineage. This article examines Musdah Mulia's Islamic thought to investigate how her discourse reconstructs women's reproductive rights from a duty-centered conception of reproduction toward a model of reproductive agency. Employing qualitative conceptual analysis, the study examines Musdah Mulia's writings, recorded lectures, podcasts, and publicly available discussions on sexuality, marriage, reproductive health, pregnancy, and women's rights. The analysis identifies seven recurrent rights in her discourse: sexual agency, the right to refuse sexual intercourse, reproductive timing, fertility decision-making, marital choice, access to reproductive healthcare, and access to reproductive information. These rights are subsequently organized into three dimensions of reproductive agency: bodily autonomy, reproductive decision-making, and enabling conditions. The study argues that Musdah's contribution lies not merely in asserting women's reproductive rights but in repositioning women as moral and legal agents within Islamic family relations. Through a maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah reading, this reconstruction can be related particularly to the protection of life, lineage, dignity, and reason. At the same time, reproductive agency generates normative tensions with conventional understandings of marital sexual obligations and ḥifẓ al-nasl. Rather than resolving these tensions through a simple claim of compatibility, the article demonstrates how Musdah's thought opens a space for reconstructing Islamic family law around reciprocity, bodily integrity, gender justice, and responsible reproductive decision-making.
Fatwa on the Marriage of a Person Who Has a Deviation of Sexual Orientation in Islamweb.net from the Perspective of Maqāṣid al-Sharī'ah Aisyah, Nabilah Rohadatul; Tussa’banniya, Nabila; Abida, Rossana Farah; Musyafa’ah, Nur Lailatul
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 1 (2025): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i1.2657

Abstract

Nowadays, more and more people have a deviant sexual orientation. The laws of their marriage, both same-sex and of different sexes, have caused legal debate among clerics, including on websites. This study aims to examine the fatwa of islamweb.net scholars on marriage for someone who has a deviant sexual orientation. This research is a normative legal research with a conceptual approach. Primary data is collected through the fatwa of islamweb.net clerics, while secondary data comes from books and scientific articles. The collected data was analyzed descriptively with the theory of Maqāṣid al-sharī'ah. The results of the study show that islamweb.net clerics view homosexuality as a form of deviance that needs to be cured through spiritual and medical approaches, with heterosexual marriage as "sharia therapy". This marriage is recommended if there are no biological disorders that hinder the relationship between husband and wife. This fatwa reflects the purpose of the shari'a in preserving religion (ḥifẓ al-dīn), honor (ḥifẓ al-'ird), and heredity (ḥifẓ al-nasl), but on the other hand, it has social implications for the LGBT community, which is still positioned as a deviant group. A more inclusive and equitable approach to maqāṣid is needed to bridge the gap between religious norms and human rights principles.
Concentration, Productivity, and Thematic Flow: A Comparative Bibliometric Reading of Maqāsid Sharī’ah Scholarship Using Bradford's, Lotka's, and Three-Field Plot Models Ghazna Nizami, Auliya; Prima Pratista, Farida; Maulana, Alfin; Zustika, Anisa Fadilah; Rusyda, Arjun Kamal
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 1 (2025): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i1.2773

Abstract

Maqāsid Sharī’ah (the higher objectives of Islamic law) has grown into a prolific and increasingly interdisciplinary field, yet little is known about the structural patterns underlying its scholarly production. This study offers a comparative bibliometric reading of Maqāsid Sharī’ah literature by applying three analytically distinct models, Bradford’s Law, Lotka’s Law, and the Three-Field Plot, each capturing a different dimension of the field’s architecture: source concentration, author productivity, and thematic knowledge flow. Using 413 documents indexed in Scopus (2020–2026) and analyzed with Biblioshiny/bibliometrix and VOSviewer, the study finds that the field is governed by a small core of 14 journals (Zone 2 = 36, Zone 3 = 124 sources; Bradford multiplier k = 3.01, R² = 0.9806), indicating strong concentration around a handful of Indonesian Islamic-law outlets. Author productivity follows a steeper-than-classical power distribution (Lotka’s Beta = 4.49, R² = 0.9939; KS test against the theoretical Beta = 2 not rejected, p = 0.329), pointing to a fragmented community with no dominant “star” authors. The Three-Field Plot further reveals that this fragmented, source-concentrated scholarship nonetheless converges on a shared theoretical root, most prominently Auda's (2008) systems approach to Maqasid al-Shariah, before branching into two distinct application streams: Islamic economics/finance and human rights/legal discourse. Read together, the three models show a field that is structurally concentrated and authorially fragmented, yet thematically coherent. The study provides a methodological template for triangulating complementary bibliometric laws and offers an evidence-based map of the emerging research frontiers in Maqāsid Sharī'ah.
Comparative Study of Husband’s Iddah Policy in Indonesia: Imam al-Ghazali’s Maslahah and Jeremy Bentham’s Utilitarianism Perspective 'Aisyi, Marshalina Rahadatul; Ulya, Zakiyatul; Hidayat, Muhammad Rifqi
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 2 (2025): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i2.2797

Abstract

The existence of the iddah policy for husbands has caused much debate because the validity of the iddah adopted by the majority of scholars is only for women. This study aims to analyze the iddah policy for husbands in the Circular of the Director General of Islamic Community Guidance, Number P-005/DJ.III/HK/007/10/2021 using Imam al-Ghazali's maslahah theory and Jeremy Bentham's utilitarianism theory. This study is library research with a qualitative approach, using documentation as a data collection technique and descriptive analysis as a data analysis technique. The study concluded that the policy of iddah for husbands in the Circular of the Director General of Islamic Community Guidance, Number P-005/DJ.III/HK/007/10/2021 is in accordance with Al-Ghazali's maslahah because it has fulfilled 5 (five) elements of maqashid al-shari’ah, namely: hifdz ad-din (maintenance of religion), hifdz an-nafs (maintenance of the soul), hifdz al-aql (maintenance of reason), and hifdz an-nasl (maintenance or offspring), hifdz al-mal (maintenance of property) and is in accordance with Jeremy Bentham's utilitarianism theory because it has fulfilled seven core elements of happiness, namely: intensity of pleasure, duration of pleasure, certainty of happiness, closeness to achieving pleasure, fecundity, purity, and extent. By fulfilling the five elements of maqashid al-shari’ah and seven core indicators of happiness, it can be concluded that this policy is appropriate to implement because it contains benefits and happiness.
Interpreting the East Java Indonesian Ulema Council Fatwa on “Sound Horeg”: Bayānī, ‘Irfānī, and Burhānī Perspectives Amien, Ach Badri; Alfanny, M. Sa’ad; Al Af Ghoni, Achmad Sholakhuddin; Aniq, Ahmad Fathan
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 2 (2025): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i2.2879

Abstract

The phenomenon of “sound horeg” audio systems with bass pressure reaching 95–135 dB has caused social, health, and environmental problems in various regions of East Java. Responding to this condition, the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) of East Java issued Fatwa Number 1 of 2025, which stipulates that the use of “sound horeg” with excessive intensity and accompanied by practices that lead to harm is declared harām (forbidden), while reasonable use for positive activities is permitted. This study aims to explain the normative basis of the fatwa through the epistemological perspective of Muḥammad ‘Ābid al-Jābirī, covering three models of reasoning: bayānī, ‘irfānī, and burhānī. Data were collected through a literature review of official fatwa documents, fiqh literature, al-Jābirī’s works, and scientific articles on the “sound horeg” phenomenon. The analysis was carried out using a qualitative-analytical approach, namely, reading the fatwa as both a legal text and a social phenomenon to examine how the three models of reasoning operate. The study's findings demonstrate that the MUI combines the legitimacy of sharia texts (bayānī), ethical-spiritual considerations of society (ʿirfānī), and empirical evidence regarding the dangers of noise and social damage (burhānī). Thus, this fatwa is not merely normative but also constitutes a comprehensive epistemological response to changes in modern entertainment culture.
Patriarchal Structures in Islamic Law and Indonesian Positive Law: A Comparative Legal Analysis from a Gender Justice Perspective Ramadhan, Rahmat Gilang; Hibatullah, Mohammad Rafii'; Farichudzaki, W.K.; Aji, Rajali H.
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 2 (2025): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i2.3126

Abstract

This study critically examines the persistence of patriarchal bias in Indonesia’s legal system by comparing Islamic and positive law through a gender-justice lens. This research specifically identifies how patriarchal structures are embedded in family law norms, judicial reasoning, and institutional legal practices, particularly in matters of marriage, lineage, and gendered legal authority. Using a qualitative normative method with a comparative socio-legal approach, the study analyzes statutory regulations, classical and contemporary Islamic legal doctrines, and scholarly interpretations relevant to the Indonesian legal context. The findings reveal a fundamental divergence between the two systems: while positive law formally endorses gender equality, patriarchal bias persists at the level of legal interpretation and implementation, especially within judicial institutions; conversely, Islamic law, when interpreted textually, may reproduce gender hierarchy, yet offers a strong emancipatory potential when re-read through maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah and egalitarian legal reasoning. The study argues that patriarchal bias is not merely normative but institutional, and that meaningful legal reform requires not only doctrinal revision but also transformation of judicial reasoning and legal culture.
Marriage Prohibition Between Sepande and Banjarpoh Residents: Perspectives of Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah Almahdi, Tajuddin Nabil; Destiara, Sumi; Salsabila , Nisrina Ruliana; Nadhifah , Nurul Asiya; Yanda, Gatralina Sekar Harum Ael
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 2 (2025): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i2.3131

Abstract

The myth about the taboo of marriage between the residents of Sepande Village and Banjarpoh Hamlet in Sidoarjo is part of a local tradition that is believed to bring bad luck, disaster, and even death. Although the majority in the area are Muslims, this myth is still believed by some people to this day. This article examines the views of Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah village scholars on the myth of the prohibition of marriage between the residents of Sepande Village and Banjarpoh Hamlet. This type of research is empirical research using a sociological approach. The research data was obtained through interviews, observations and documentation. The data was analyzed comparatively to compare the opinions of the two scholars. The results of this study show that Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah scholars agree against the myth of the prohibition of marriage between the people of Sepande and Banjarpoh, because they do not have a strong legal basis in Islam. According to the scholars of Nahdlatul Ulama, the myth is included in the category of 'urf fasid, which means it cannot be used as an argument (hujjah), but under certain conditions it can still be used socially as a form of prevention against non-kufu’ marriage for the sake of benefit. Meanwhile, Muhammadiyah scholars strongly reject all forms of myths that lack a basis in the Qur'an and Hadith.
Development of the Dictionary of Sharia Economic Law as a Teaching Material: A Comparative Study between the Maqāṣid al-Sharī'ah Approach and the Qawā’id Fiqhiyyah Arifin, Moch. Zainul; Rohman, Moh. Faizur; Solikin, Agus; Mardiyanto, Ibnu; Ali, Mohammed Ramadhan Abraheem Alshaykh
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 5 No. 2 (2025): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v5i2.3178

Abstract

This research aims to develop a Dictionary of Sharia Economic Law Terms as supporting teaching material for understanding the term fiqh al-mu’amalah and to analyze its development from the perspective of maqāṣid al-sharī'ah and qawā’id fiqhiyyah. The research uses a qualitative approach and a research and development (R&D) design. The dictionary development process is carried out through the planning stages, identification of reference sources, preparation of lemmas, provision of term meanings, and evaluation through Focus Group Discussion (FGD) involving Arabic students and language experts. Data were collected through documentation studies, observations, and focus group discussions, then analyzed using qualitative descriptive methods and normative-conceptual analysis. The results of the study show that the developed Dictionary of Sharia Economic Law Terms is systematically compiled from classical and contemporary fiqh sources and contains fiqh al-muamalah terms relevant to students' learning needs. The results of the trial show that this dictionary is effective in helping students understand the term fiqh al-muamalah, especially in the Sharia Economic Law Book Study course. Analysis based on maqāṣid al-sharī'ah shows that the development of dictionaries is in line with the goal of preserving religion (ḥifẓ al-dīn) and preserving reason (ḥifẓ al-'aql), while analysis based on qawā’id fiqhiyyah shows relevance to the principles of al-mashaqqah tajlib al-taysīr and al-umūr bi maqāṣidihā. Thus, the development of this dictionary makes a practical and theoretical contribution to facilitating learning and improving the quality of understanding of terms in the field of Sharia Economic Law.