cover
Contact Name
Moh Ilham A Hamudy
Contact Email
bestuurskunde@kemendagri.go.id
Phone
+6221-3459556
Journal Mail Official
bestuurskunde@kemendagri.go.id
Editorial Address
Kementerian Dalam Negeri Republik Indonesia Jalan Medan Merdeka Utara No. 7 Jakarta Pusat 10110 DKI Jakarta Indonesia
Location
Kota adm. jakarta pusat,
Dki jakarta
INDONESIA
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies
ISSN : 27976351     EISSN : 27975576     DOI : https://doi.org/10.53013/bestuurskunde
Core Subject : Economy, Social,
Bestuurskunde is a journal that provides scientific information resources aimed at researchers, research institutions, government agencies, and stakeholders. The journal publishes original research manuscripts, review articles, studies, and case studies that focus on governmental studies.
Articles 71 Documents
Public Service Transformation Based on Local Leadership: A Study in Palleko Village Syarif Idris; Rahma Pramudya Nawang Sari; Ibnu Azka; Fathur Baldan Haramain
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 5 No 2 (2025): Reflection on Political Governance and Optimization of Village Governance
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.5.2.119-131

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the transformation of public services in Palleko Village, Polombangkeng Utara District, Takalar Regency, and the strategies implemented by the Village Head to improve service quality. Effective and efficient public services are very important to meet the needs of the community but are often hampered by various problems such as a complicated bureaucratic system, limited resources, and low community participation. This study uses a qualitative method with a descriptive approach, where data is collected through observation, interviews, and documentation. The results of this study indicate that the Palleko Village Head implements several service transformation strategies, such as improving facilities, providing fair and professional services, and transparency through clear service flow information. Supporting factors in this transformation include the availability of infrastructure, friendly and responsive attitudes from staff, and good relations between the government and the community. However, the main challenges in this transformation process are the professionalism of staff, which still needs to be improved, and the low public awareness of the importance of their role in supporting public services. The transformation of public services in Palleko Village shows that with the right strategy, service quality can be improved so that it is more responsive to community needs and supports inclusive development.
Menyeimbangkan Kebebasan Berserikat dan Ketertiban Umum: Evaluasi Kebijakan Penataan Ormas di Indonesia Al-Adly Darniyus
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 1 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.1.1-16

Abstract

The issue of restricting the operational space of mass organizations (ormas) has recently become a significant concern in Indonesia’s democratic discourse. The tension between the need to maintain public order and the obligation to uphold freedom of association has become increasingly evident, particularly amid the rise of coercive administrative policies. This article aims to comprehensively evaluate policies governing mass organizations in Indonesia by examining three purposively selected evaluative dimensions: policy effectiveness, responsiveness to civil society, and their impact on the social order. The study employs a qualitative-descriptive approach through a literature review, analyzing legal documents, institutional reports, and relevant academic literature. The document review focuses on policy dynamics, particularly following the enactment of Law No. 16 of 2017. The analytical method applied is thematic and evaluative document analysis. The findings indicate that policies on mass organizations in Indonesia remain partial and are predominantly characterized by an administrative-repressive approach. In terms of effectiveness, the policies emphasize formal legality rather than the substantive strengthening of organizational capacity. Their responsiveness is also limited due to the lack of public participation in both policy formulation and evaluation processes. From the perspective of social impact, these policies have the potential to constrain civic space and exacerbate social polarization. This study recommends the reformulation of mass organization policies based on the principles of due process, meaningful participation, and the strengthening of constitutional rights protection. Furthermore, insights from international practices—such as the model of militant democracy in Germany and the challenges observed in India—are presented to enrich the discourse on developing more democratic and accountable policy frameworks in Indonesia.
A MENILAI ULANG KEWENANGAN PEMERINTAH DALAM MENGATUR ORMAS BERBASIS ANGGOTA Wiranata Nababan; Elsa Gustini Vinsensia Situmorang
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.2.101-114

Abstract

Civil society organizations (CSOs) serve as vital pillars of democracy by providing a platform for public participation in monitoring state power. However, the regulation of CSOs is characterized by overlapping authority between the Ministry of Home Affairs (MoHA) and the Ministry of Law and Human Rights (MoLHR). This overlap creates legal uncertainty, weak oversight, and opportunities for abuse, including acts of intimidation and violence. This study aims to reassess the allocation of authority between these two ministries concerning the regulation and disbandment of CSOs and to analyze the balance between freedom of association and the government’s interest in maintaining public order in a democratic state. The study employed a qualitative approach based on a literature review, drawing on academic literature, regulations, media reports, and other relevant secondary sources, which were analyzed and validated through content analysis and source triangulation. The findings indicate that the division of authority between MoHA and MoLHR remains ambiguous, particularly regarding the oversight and membership-based CSOs. A redistribution of authority is therefore warranted: MoHA should oversee membership-based organizations,while MoLHR should oversee non-membership organizations, particularly foundations.Furthermore, the 2017 Government Regulation in Lieu of Law on Civil Society Organizations, which eliminated the requirement for prior judicial authorization for disbandment, reflects a shift from a more conciliatory to a more repressive approach that may undermine the rule of law and democratic principles. Therefore, the disbandment of CSOs must comply with due process of law and the principle of proportionality to ensure the protection of citizens’ constitutional rights.
Dynamics and Challenges of Civil Society Organizations in Indonesia Rachman Kosasih; Mohammad Rizky Luthfiah Aziz; Tomy Veryanto Bawulang
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 1 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.1.75-87

Abstract

Civil society organizations (CSOs) are key actors in democratic governance and social development in Indonesia. However, the rapid growth in the number of CSOs has not been supported by effective governance, regulation, and institutional development. This study analyzes the dynamics of CSOs in Indonesia from a public policy perspective, with a focus on regulatory frameworks, institutional arrangements, public perceptions, and the implications of CSO development policies. It employs a qualitative approach based on policy review, drawing on more than 200 documents, including laws and regulations, government reports, internal documents from the Directorate General of Politics and General Government, academic publications, and survey data from research institutions. The findings show that, despite their significant contributions to social services and public participation, CSOs face persistent challenges, including overlapping institutional mandates, weak oversight mechanisms, and ambivalent public perceptions. Comparative analysis suggests that effective CSO governance requires a balance between freedom of association, transparency, and institutional accountability. This study highlights the importance of a more integrated and evidence-based reformulation of community organization development policies, and positions the Directorate General of Politics and General Government (BSKDN) as a key actor in shaping national CSO policy. It also contributes an analytical framework for CSO governance that integrates regulatory, institutional, and public perception dimensions within the broader context of state–civil society relations in Indonesia.
Balancing Freedom and Order:: Civil Society Organization Governance, Policy Communication, and the Investment Climate in Indonesia Defrida Suzana Lukuaka; Desi Natalia Sihombing
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.2.129-143

Abstract

Civil Society Organization (CSO) governance in Indonesia stands at the intersection of protecting democratic freedoms and maintaining public order to foster a favorable investment climate. Although various regulations have been enacted, research on policy communication has paid insufficient attention to how government policy communication can reconcile these often conflicting imperatives. This qualitative study used policy document analysis and a critical literature review to identify communication channels and barriers affecting interactions among state authorities, civil society groups, and investors. The findings indicate that closed and inconsistent regulatory messaging may contribute to information dissonance, constraining civic space and creating legal uncertainty for business actors. Conversely, an integrated communication model may help bridge state control and public participation through bureaucratic transparency, coordinated policy implementation,  and interactive dialogue platforms. This study concludes that civil liberties and the investment climate can mutually reinforce each other when addressed through adaptive and inclusive policy communication. The findings offer theoretical contributions to public governance studies and practical recommendations for formulating balanced government communication strategies.
Community Organization Based on Local Wisdom in Fostering Harmony in Bali I Dewa Gede Darma Permana; Widya Ayu Candra
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 1 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.1.29-41

Abstract

Historical records have repeatedly revealed the empirical reality that Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) in Bali, which initially emerged as unifying platforms, have instead transformed into sources of conflict. The lack of deep-rooted local wisdom in Bali—which is inherently harmonious—has become one of the primary factors contributing to these issues. Given this situation, the researcher is interested in conducting a comprehensive study of CSO structures based on local wisdom in Bali. Analytically, this study aims to present the essence of Balinese local wisdom as an integral part of Balinese society, its implementation within the structure of Civil Society Organizations in Bali, and its implications in addressing the threat of conflict while serving as a means to strengthen harmony. Methodologically, this study employs a qualitative research approach based on a case study methodology. Research data were derived from observations and interviews as primary data, supplemented by literature reviews and documentation as secondary data. Using the Miles and Huberman analytical approach, the findings of this study indicate that the structure of Civil Society Organizations based on Balinese local wisdom generally aligns with five concepts: 1) Tri Hita Karana, 2) Menyama Braya, 3) Matulung, 4) Makasah, and 5) Ngrombo. The application of this community organization framework based on local wisdom has the potential to strengthen harmony in Bali, serving as a philosophical foundation for social movements, a bond of solidarity, a foundation for humanistic movements, a manifestation of love for Bali’s natural environment, and a catalyst for unity and social justice. The contribution of this research is intended to serve as an academic guideline for strengthening the governance of Civil Society Organizations based on local wisdom to foster harmony.
Sustainable Governance Strategies forCivil Society Organizations in Indonesia:: Navigating Institutional Challenges and Democratic Resilience Gandisa Pangestuti Kiswoyo; Adam Nurfaizi Rosyan; Resa Septia Nugroho
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.2.115-127

Abstract

Civil society organizations (CSOs) in Indonesia play an important role in strengthening social development and democratic processes; however, their governance continues to face a range of challenges that limit their effectiveness. This study aims to analyze CSO governance in Indonesia by examining both enabling and inhibiting factors, particularly those related to human resources, funding, and public legitimacy, and to formulate strategies for strengthening the role of CSOs. This study employed a qualitative method with a literature review approach, drawing on reports, academic articles, and policy documents. The findings indicate that CSOs contribute to various programs in the areas of social welfare, community empowerment, and democratic participation, yet they are often constrained by weak leadership capacity, limited organizational management, dependence on unstable funding sources, and declining public trust resulting from cases of abuse of authority. To address these challenges, this study draws on the collaborative governance framework of Ansell and Gash, which emphasizes strategies such as building trust, maintaining commitment, fostering shared understanding, engaging private actors, sharing resources, and strengthening societal legitimacy. The study concludes that effective CSO governance requires synergy between internal organizational reform and collaborative strategies involving the state, the private sector, and society more broadly, thereby enabling CSOs to maximize their role as partners in sustainable social development and democratic governance in Indonesia.
Reformasi Regulasi Pembubaran Ormas di Indonesia: Menyeimbangkan Ketertiban Umum dan Hak Berserikat: Balancing Public Order and the Right to Association Bimo Fajar Hantoro
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.2.89-100

Abstract

Indonesia has experienced a significant shift in legal politics regarding mass organization disbandment regulation. From a regulatory regime in which due process was strictly regulated to protect the right to association, to one in which due process guarantees are relaxed to allow the government to act quickly in the name of national security and public order. The purpose of this study is to analyze the current regulatory framework for the disbandment of mass organizations and to propose reforms to balance the government's interest in maintaining public order with the right to association. This research is normative in nature, employing statutory and conceptual approaches and secondary data gathered through a literature review. The findings of this study suggest that the Mass Organizations Law has several limitations and normative issues, including the removal of prior court authorization for disbandment decisions, the simplification of the administrative sanction imposition procedure, and the ambiguity surrounding the use of criminal offenses committed by mass organization members for the purpose of administrative sanction imposition. With the new low in the Constitutional Court's due process precedent, reforms may be made to reinstate the courts' role in the form of a speedy trial, by reinstating and calibrating temporal limitations on the imposition of sanctions, and by providing criteria for the use of criminal offenses as a basis for administrative sanctions. These reforms are necessary to ensure legal certainty and adequate due process, while also limiting and empowering the government in its efforts to maintain public order.
Between Empowerment and Co-optation:: The Role of Mass Organizations in Indonesia’s Democratic Consolidation Asrinaldi
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.2.161-174

Abstract

The political role of mass organizations (Ormas) in Indonesia has evolved significantly following the transition from the New Order to Reformasi democracy. This study examines how Ormas navigate their roles as interest groups and pressure groups and how these roles affect democratic consolidation. Using a qualitative approach, the study analyzes secondary data from 1998–2025, comprising academic publications, government documents, and national media reports. Data were examined through qualitative thematic analysis and interpretive cross-source comparison, with preliminary findings validated through an expert-focused group discussion. The findings show that Ormas do not function as fixed types of interest or pressure groups. Rather, they shift between interest representation and political pressure as different modes of political action, depending on political access, issue salience, perceived threats to organizational interests, and organizational survival. While these strategies can strengthen civic participation and democratic representation, state accommodation and co-optation may undermine organizational autonomy and transform Ormas into instruments of political mobilization. The study argues that democratic consequences therefore depend on the interaction between organizational autonomy and state–civil society relations. Strengthening the democratic role of Ormas requires transparent regulation, greater financial and organizational autonomy, and stronger civic and political education to enable them to function as independent channels of representation and counterbalances to political power.
The Reorientation Of Ormas Policy And Governance As A Forum For People's Political Participation: A. Legal Framework for the Management of Mass Organisations in Indonesia B. Mass Organisations as Representatives of Public Political Participation C. Reorientation of Policies Facilitating the Role of Mass Organisations Muhaimin; Novi Enjelina Putri
Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Restructuring Mass Organizations: Between Freedom of Association and Public Order
Publisher : Ministry of Home Affairs

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53013/bestuurskunde.6.2.145-159

Abstract

Freedom of association is a constitutional right guaranteed under Article 28 and Article 28E(3) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia. Nevertheless, the development of regulations governing community organizations (Ormas) in Indonesia has not followed a linear trajectory from repression toward democratization. This study examines changes in the regulatory regime governing Ormas based on three principal legal instruments: Law No. 8 of 1985, Law No. 17 of 2013, and Law No. 16 of 2017. The study employs a normative juridical method with a qualitative and historical-analytical approach. Unlike previous studies, which have generally adopted a descriptive-historical approach, this study analyzes the three legal regimes through the framework of manifest and latent functions. This framework demonstrates that the expansion of opportunities for Ormas participation following the Reform Era did not necessarily eliminate the coercive power of the state. Rather, the expansion of participation occurred alongside selective facilitation and practices of co-optation. The findings indicate that compliance with the principle of proportionality, which encompasses legality, legitimate aims, and the necessity and balancing of measures, varies across the three regulatory regimes. Law No. 8 of 1985 fails to satisfy the latter two elements. Law No. 17 of 2013 provides a stronger normative framework but faces weaknesses in its implementation. Meanwhile, Law No. 16 of 2017 represents a regression in terms of proportionality by eliminating judicial review mechanisms in the process of dissolving Ormas. Based on these findings, this study proposes four policy principles as a basis for restructuring Ormas regulation: legal certainty, restoration of fair legal process, strengthening the state’s supportive functions, and symmetrical accountability. These four principles are expected to provide a relevant framework for the Ministry of Home Affairs’ agenda for reforming Ormas regulation.