In social commerce, particularly among small and medium-sized handicraft enterprises (SMEs), personalized recommender systems (RS) are crucial for enhancing store and product discovery. Conventional content-based filtering (CBF) often overemphasizes accuracy, leading to over-specialization and limiting exposure to novel or diverse items, an issue in the handicraft sector where uniqueness is valued. This study proposes a serendipitous recommendation approach using a Genetic Algorithm (GA) with adaptive selection strategies, Roulette Wheel Selection (RWS), Tournament Selection (TnS), and Rank-Based Selection (RBS), to balance relevance and unexpectedness. Handicraft store attributes, such as product types, materials, and services, are encoded in a 19-bit chromosome and evaluated via a hybrid fitness function. Tested on real data from West Sumatra SMEs, the model is assessed using Precision, Recall, Novelty, and Serendipity metrics. Results show that the GA-based adaptive selection approach outperforms baseline CBF in producing more diverse and surprising recommendations, fostering exploratory shopping experiences and supporting the discovery of unique local products in social commerce ecosystems.