cover
Contact Name
Nur Putri Hidayah
Contact Email
ilrej@umm.ac.id
Phone
-
Journal Mail Official
ilrej@umm.ac.id
Editorial Address
Jalan Raya Tlogomas 246 Malang
Location
Kota malang,
Jawa timur
INDONESIA
Indonesia Law Reform Journal (ILREJ)
ISSN : 27769259     EISSN : 27769674     DOI : 10.22219
Core Subject : Social,
Scope of scientific articles published in this journal deals with various topics in the multidisciplinary field of study of Law from around the world, in particular issues related to: 1. Jurisprudence 2. Legal theory 3. Laws in modern countries 4. Comparative law 5. Constitutional law 6. Law and environment 7. Customary law 8. International law 9. Legal institutions 10. Islamic law 11. other legal topics
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 124 Documents
Interweaving Law in Diversity: An Integrated Model of Islamic, Criminal, and Customary Law as a Solution to Kawin Tangkap in Sumba Muhammad Luthfi; Nu'man Aunuh
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i2.45164

Abstract

This research examines the urgency of resolving kawin tangkap (piti maranggangu) as a legal conflict in Sumba, which sparks disagreement among Islamic, criminal, and customary law in Indonesia. This research departs from the paradox between recognition within a local tradition and the guarantee of the protection of women’s rights. The practice of such marriage, which is locally deemed acceptable, contravenes Article 10 of the Sexual Violence Crime Law, Article 446 of the Penal Code, and the principle of ridha in Article 6 of the Marriage Law in conjunction with Article 16 of the Compilation of Islamic Law. This research develops the conceptual framework and operational mechanism of an integrated law that resolves conflicts without overlooking the protection of women’s rights. Using a normative research method, supported by statutory and conceptual approaches as well as prescriptive analysis, this research offers a trigonal model of integration that pivots on three axes: 1) the conditional customary legitimacy based on maqashid syariah; 2) formal Sharia verification by the Religious Affairs Office; and 3) responsive state guarantee under the Sexual Violence Crime Law and the Penal Code. This research also indicates that the integration of law can take place by establishing hifzh al-nafs (protection of life) and hifzh al-'irdh (protection of dignity) as ethical principles, and by designing a tiered mechanism that combines customary mediation, restorative processes, and law enforcement as the ultimum remedium. Grounded in human rights and gender theory, the model introduces strict 'red-line criteria' and grants absolute veto power to the victim or legal counsel to prevent secondary victimization during mediation. The recommendations of this research manifest in an integrative-progressive approach to address kawin tangkap without undermining customary values, transforming religious principles and state rules to create a real solution for the plural Sumba community.
Reforming Hate Speech Criminalization in Indonesia: A Harm-Based Framework for Protecting Freedom of Expression Rahmad Rafid; Moh. Ali; Suyatno Ladiqi; Riski Febria Nurita
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 3 (2026): November 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i3.45478

Abstract

This paper examines the need to reform hate speech criminalization in Indonesia and proposes a harm-based legal framework to ensure legal certainty and safeguard the constitutional right to freedom of expression. Using normative legal research, this study analyzes relevant statutory provisions, legal doctrines, and constitutional principles governing hate speech and freedom of expression in Indonesia. The analysis reveals that the current regulatory framework remains fragmented and lacks a clear and operational definition of hate speech, creating broad interpretive discretion and a risk of overcriminalization. These weaknesses may blur the distinction between harmful hate speech and legitimate criticism, political expression, and dissent, thereby contributing to a chilling effect on freedom of expression. In response, this article proposes a harm-based framework that assesses criminal liability through contextual harm, mens rea, the likelihood and severity of harm, and the principles of legality, necessity, and proportionality. The proposed framework seeks to establish clearer boundaries for criminal intervention while preventing the excessive restriction of constitutionally protected expression. The article argues that reforming hate speech criminalization requires not only clearer statutory definitions but also a more constrained and context-sensitive approach to enforcement consistent with democratic values and constitutional guarantees of freedom of expression.
The Harmonisation of the Electronic-Based Government System Rules Between Central and Regional Governments in the Digital Era Nilam Agustryanti; Ilyas Ilyas; Iksan Iksan; Taufik Firmanto
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i2.45678

Abstract

Bureaucratic reform in Indonesia is a national strategic agenda that responds to the poor performance of state apparatus, complicated service procedures, and low government accountability. Amidst the pressures of the digital era, this agenda is increasingly complex because it must meet the demands of technological transformation while facing regulatory issues that are not fully adaptive. This study analyses the dynamics of bureaucratic reform in Indonesia and the challenges of its implementation; examines the state of government regulations and obstacles to their adaptation amid changes in the bureaucratic system; andassesses the implications of digital transformation for governance and the applicable regulatory framework. This study employs a normative legal research method with conceptual and legislative approaches. The legal materials analysed include laws and regulations on public services, information disclosure, information technology, and electronic-based government systems, as well as relevant academic literature. This study reveals three main findings. First, bureaucratic reform at the regional levelremains hampered by the strong legacy of bureaucratic culture, low civil servant competence, and a gap between central policies and on-the-ground service delivery. Second, government regulations suffer fromregulatory obesity, with a conflict between Marine Affairs Law and Regional Government Law. This has created ambiguity over how the central government, relevant ministries, and regional governments manage fisheries resources and marine territories. Consequently, fishers and business operators face confusion regarding permits for specific marine areas, while law enforcement activities at sea frequently overlap. Overlapping central and regional regulations and weak harmonisation mechanisms therefore create legal uncertainty. Third, digital transformation has been proven to increase efficiency and transparency in public services, but its success requires an adaptive regulatory framework, equitable digital infrastructure, and adequate civil servant competence. This study concludes that bureaucratic reform, stronger regulation, and digital transformation are inseparable prerequisites for effective and accountable governance. As a recommendation, the government should strengthen regulatory harmonisation, expand digital infrastructure equitably to remote areas, improve civil servants’ digital competence through a consistent merit system, and encourage a shift in bureaucratic work culture from a procedural orientation to a result and public service orientation.  
The Open Texture of Criminal Law Norms: Interpreting the Minor Nature of Offences Rocmad Dwi Riwayanto; Rahim Bin Lasupu
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

This paper examines the questionable phrase “Minor  nature of the offence” in Indonesia’s Criminal Code. This phrase should be distinguished from the term “Minor  offence” (bagatel), which refers to a specific type of petty crime. In contrast, “Minor  nature of the offence” is a standard that lets judges grant a judicial pardon (rechterlijk pardon) despite someone being found guilty. While this flexible language gives judges more freedom, it can also lead to inconsistent decisions and unpredictable law enforcement. The paper uses normative legal research and both statutory and conceptual approaches to review legal sources and develop well-defined evaluation criteria. The results show that the current wording is vague, rendering decisions more subjective and thereby increasing the tension between justice and legal certainty (rechtszekerheid). To solve this, the study proposes a two-part framework that includes objective factors like minimal harm, no violence, and low financial loss, as well as subjective factors such as intent, personal background, and actions after offence. The paper suggests that the Supreme Court issue formal sentencing guidelines through a Supreme Court Regulation or Circular Letter to guarantee more consistent judicial decisions. Judges and law enforcement should also use teleological interpretation to balance flexibility with clear legal standards.

Page 13 of 13 | Total Record : 124