cover
Contact Name
Nur Putri Hidayah
Contact Email
ilrej@umm.ac.id
Phone
-
Journal Mail Official
ilrej@umm.ac.id
Editorial Address
Jalan Raya Tlogomas 246 Malang
Location
Kota malang,
Jawa timur
INDONESIA
Indonesia Law Reform Journal (ILREJ)
ISSN : 27769259     EISSN : 27769674     DOI : 10.22219
Core Subject : Social,
Scope of scientific articles published in this journal deals with various topics in the multidisciplinary field of study of Law from around the world, in particular issues related to: 1. Jurisprudence 2. Legal theory 3. Laws in modern countries 4. Comparative law 5. Constitutional law 6. Law and environment 7. Customary law 8. International law 9. Legal institutions 10. Islamic law 11. other legal topics
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 124 Documents
Constitutional Preview in Lawmaking Based on the Principle of Social Justice: Utopia or a Normative Necessity? Sheila Kusuma Wardani Amnesti; Tunggul Anshari Setia Negara
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): March 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i1.43943

Abstract

The increasing number of judicial review petitions submitted to the Constitutional Court indicates recurring constitutional disputes arising from enacted legislation, reflecting structural weaknesses in Indonesia’s lawmaking process. These weaknesses include inadequate constitutional scrutiny during legislative drafting, inconsistencies between statutory provisions and constitutional principles, and insufficient incorporation of social justice values in legislative products. The Fifth Principle of Pancasila affirms that social justice for all Indonesians must serve as a fundamental orientation of public policy, including the legislative process. However, ex post constitutional control through judicial review remains corrective and reactive, addressing constitutional deficiencies only after laws have been enacted and have generated legal uncertainty or adverse social consequences. This article examines the urgency of implementing constitutional preview as an ex ante constitutional oversight mechanism that enables the harmonisation of Pancasila values and the norms of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia during the legislative drafting stage. This study employs a normative legal research method using statutory and comparative approaches, supported by Theory of Development Law, which conceptualises law as an instrument of social reform and development. The findings demonstrate that constitutional previewpotentially produces legislation that is more constitutionally compliant, socially responsive, and aligned with the principle of social justice, as constitutional concerns can be identified and addressed prior to enactment. In addition to reducing the frequency of constitutional disputes that lead to judicial review petitions before the Constitutional Court, constitutional preview can strengthen democratic legitimacy, normative effectiveness, and public trust in legislative outcomes. Therefore, constitutional preview constitutes an urgent mechanism for improving Indonesia’s legislative system and advancing socially just law grounded in the nation’s constitutional values.
Legal Protection Against The Impact of Geothermal Management on Communities: A Comparative Study in Kenya, Philippines and Indonesia Astrin Bernita Rahma; Ahmad Suryono
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): March 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i1.44194

Abstract

This study compares the regulatory frameworks in the Philippines, Indonesia, and Kenya to find out how they deal with the issue of legal protection for populations impacted by geothermal energy management. To protect community rights during geothermal energy development, this study primarily aims to determine the conceptualisation, regulation, and implementation of public consultation. The methodological references and respectable academic literature support the use of a qualitative legal research strategy with a regulatory analysis and comparative study technique to ensure the accuracy of the analysis. While there is a very extensive legislative framework in place in Indonesia, the results demonstrate that public consultation is still not consistently carried out, particularly with regard to openness, community participation, and checks and balances. In the Philippines and Kenya, accountability is greater, involvement methods are more inclusive, and procedural requirements are clearer. This research adds to the existing body of knowledge by identifying regulatory gaps in geothermal governance in Indonesia and providing examples of how other nations have strengthened public consultation duties through practices. This research identifies several regulatory and implementation gaps in Indonesia’s geothermal governance, particularly regarding transparency, accountability, and the effectiveness of public consultation mechanisms. Based on the comparative findings from Kenya and the Philippines, this study recommends strengthening Indonesia’s legal framework by implementing clearer procedural standards for public consultation, mandatory publication of consultation outcomes, enforceable government responses to public input, and the establishment of participatory monitoring mechanisms. These reforms are necessary to ensure meaningful community participation and provide stronger legal protection for communities affected by geothermal energy development.
Territorial Jurisdiction and Flag State Authority: The Acquittal of Criminal Acts on a Chinese Flagged Vessel during Innocent Passage in Indonesian Waters Aby Maulana; Dwi Putri Cahyawati; Putra Jovi
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): March 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i1.44443

Abstract

This study explores the application of the territoriality principle to criminal conduct committed aboard a foreign vessel and critically examines the legal reasoning behind the acquittal rendered in Verdict No. 823/Pid.B/2020/PN.Btm concerning allegations of violence aboard the Chinese-flagged fishing vessel Lu Huang Yuan Yu 118. The research pursues two principal objectives. First, it investigates the interaction between Indonesia's territorial criminal jurisdiction, China's jurisdiction as the flag State, and the legal regime governing innocent passage under the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Second, it evaluates the legal consequences of the acquittal and considers appropriate mechanisms for maintaining criminal accountability where Indonesian courts lack jurisdiction. This research adopts a normative juridical methodology supported by statutory, conceptual, comparative, and case-study approaches. The analysis draws upon Indonesian criminal legislation, the provisions of UNCLOS 1982, relevant Chinese criminal law, the Indonesia-China extradition framework, and the judicial considerations contained in Verdict No. 823/Pid.B/2020/PN.Btm. The findings demonstrate that the alleged assault occurred before the vessel entered Indonesia's territorial sea and therefore outside the territorial jurisdiction of Indonesian criminal law. Furthermore, the vessel's subsequent transit through Indonesian waters qualified as innocent passage under UNCLOS, thereby limiting the jurisdictional competence of Indonesian authorities. In the absence of a sufficient territorial connection, primary criminal jurisdiction remained with the flag State, restricting Indonesia's authority to initiate criminal prosecution. The analysis further emphasizes that the jurisdictional limitations imposed on Indonesia should not be interpreted as creating impunity for the alleged offenders. Rather, responsibility for criminal enforcement should be exercised by the State possessing the strongest jurisdictional basis, namely the flag State. Accordingly, the acquittal reflects a legally sound application of the principle of territorial jurisdiction under Indonesian criminal law. Nevertheless, the broader pursuit of justice required effective international legal cooperation to ensure that criminal accountability was not interrupted by jurisdictional constraints. The study therefore recommends strengthening the practical implementation of extradition, mutual legal assistance, and, where appropriate, the transfer of criminal proceedings through close coordination among law enforcement agencies, prosecutors, courts, diplomatic authorities, and maritime as well as migrant-worker protection institutions. Such collaborative mechanisms are essential to prevent jurisdictional gaps and to preserve effective criminal accountability in transnational maritime cases.
The Enforcement of Global Statutory Framework Against Child Soldiering: The Realities and Challenges Nwanneka Flora Ehirim; Ugochukwu Godspower Ehirim; Winifred Omawumi Okome
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): March 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i1.44670

Abstract

This paper examines the realities and challenges confronting the enforcement of the global statutory framework prohibiting the recruitment and use of children in armed conflict. Despite a robust body of treaties, charters, and domestic statutes, child-soldiering continues to escalate amid intensifying hostilities and the activities of non-state armed groups. Adopting a doctrinal research approach, the study analyses primary sources treaties, case law, and national legislation alongside secondary scholarly materials, employing comparative discourse and content analysis to examine the interaction of the relevant legal systems. The findings reveal several enforcement obstacles: the absence of a single binding definition of a ‘Child-soldier’; the lack of a universal minimum age, with instruments oscillating between under-15 and under-18 thresholds; the want of consensus on the minimum age of criminal responsibility; the unresolved question of prosecuting children for war crimes; the absence of a dedicated legal regime for children in armed conflict; the neglect of the gender dimension affecting the girl-child; and inadequate peacekeeper training and disarmament, demobilisation and reintegration (DDR) obligations. The analysis shows that fragmentation across international humanitarian law, international human rights law, international criminal law, and labour law weakens enforcement, while persuasive soft-law instruments such as the Cape Town Principles and the Machel Report bridge definitional gaps yet lack binding force. The paper recommends making the under-18 definition binding across all frameworks, adopting a uniform minimum age of criminal responsibility, standardising military recruitment procedures, strengthening gender-specific protections and DDR policies, and establishing an international human rights court with dedicated jurisdiction to enforce children’s rights.
Fiscal Privilege in Politics: Examining the Exemption of Advertisement Tax from the Perspective of Justice Baharuddin Riqiey; Ahmad Rizal Roby Ananta
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

This paper aims to examine the exclusion of advertisements for political activities from advertisement tax objects under Law No. 1 of 2022 and to assess whether this exemption is consistent with the principle of tax justice. This study employs normative legal research using statutory and conceptual approaches by examining the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, Law No. 1 of 2022, its Academic Draft, and relevant principles of tax justice. The research finds that the exemption lacks a clearly stated philosophical and sociological foundation in the Academic Draft. The law also provides no clear limitations regarding the types of advertisements, eligible parties, purposes, or periods covered by the exemption. These findings indicate that the exemption creates unequal treatment between parties conducting political activities and other taxpayers who remain liable for advertisement tax. The absence of clear limitations may also encourage misuse of the exemption and reduce potential regional revenue, making it more difficult for local governments to achieve their advertisement tax targets. From the perspective of justice, a tax exemption must be based on reasonable, transparent, and measurable criteria so that it does not unfairly shift the tax burden to other taxpayers. Therefore, Law No. 1 of 2022 should be amended to clearly define the scope of the exemption. The exemption should be limited to officially registered campaign advertisements displayed during the legally designated campaign period. Clear verification, registration, reporting, and supervision procedures should also be established to ensure legal certainty, accountability, and fair treatment among taxpayers.  
Between Experience and Exploitation: Reframing Apprentices' Right to Fair Compensation Resti Wijayanti; Sofyan Arief; Yohana Puspitasari Wardoyo
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): March 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i1.44831

Abstract

Purpose of the paper, briefly stating the problem or issue being solved. Methods, stating the methods used to solve the problem. Research results, summarising the findings of the research. Analysis, describes the results of the author's analysis of the results of the research that the author conducted. Recommendations, explain the implementable suggestions based on the results of the research and analysis conducted by the author. The purpose of this study is to analyze the allowance regulations in Minister of Manpower Regulation No. 6 of 2020 and provide recommendations regarding allowance regulations in accordance with the principle of fairness. The issues examined in this paper are how allowances are regulated in Minister of Manpower Regulation No. 6/2020 and how the provision of allowances should be regulated in Minister ofManpower Regulation No. 6/2020. The research method used is normative juridical with a legislative approach through primary and secondary legal materials, and the method of analyzing legal materials uses qualitative methods. The results of the study show that pocket money is regulated in Minister of Manpower Regulation No. 6 of 2020 based on an internship agreement agreed upon by both parties. The amount of pocket money can be based on the district or city minimum wage (UMK) based on the operational costs incurred by participants during the internship, and small companies that are unable to pay in accordance with the district minimum wage can provide non-financial compensation while still considering the pocket money component. The recommendation provided in this study is that there needs to be a revision of Minister of Manpower Regulation No. 6/2020, which regulates the minimum allowance standard and details the monitoring mechanism, monitoring procedures, and reporting procedures in the event of a violation of the norm.
Ecological Agrarian Reform and Customary Land Conflicts in the Climate Crisis: A Comparative Legal Study of Indonesia, Kenya, and South Africa Safrin Salam; Nurhijah; Muhammad Ramadan Kiro; Nuragifah; Izu Cynthia Chukwufumnanya
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

This article explores ecological agrarian reform as a normative legal framework for responding to such conflicts by bringing together the principles of agrarian justice, environmental protection, and the rights of indigenous peoples. The study adopts a normative legal research methodology, drawing on statutory, comparative, case-based, and conceptual approaches. Indonesia is examined alongside selected African jurisdictions namely Kenya, South Africa, Nigeria, and Tanzania with particular attention to the regulation of customary land tenure, communal land governance, and mechanisms for community participation. The legal analysis considers, among other materials, Article 18B clause (2) and Article 28H of the 1945 Constitution of Indonesia, Constitutional Court Decision No. 35/PUU-X/2012 on customary forests, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), Kenya’s Constitution of 2010 and Community Land Act 2016, and significant indigenous land rights cases, including the Endorois and Ogiek cases. The analysis demonstrates that customary land disputes are shaped by several interconnected factors, including competing claims over land, extractive development activities, inadequate institutional recognition of customary tenure, and insufficient opportunities for meaningful community participation. The comparison further shows that, although Indonesia constitutionally recognizes the rights of indigenous peoples, the implementation of those rights remains dependent on fragmented administrative and legal procedures. By contrast, Kenya and South Africa have established more explicit institutional arrangements for the governance of communal land. Against this background, the study advances ecological agrarian reform as a normative framework that incorporates the recognition of customary territories, ecological restoration, meaningful Free, Prior, and Informed Consent and the reassessment of environmentally destructive concessions. Such an approach could strengthen the legal basis for advancing agrarian justice, environmental protection, and climate resilience, while its effectiveness in practice remains subject to further empirical investigation. Ecological agrarian reform may serve as a comprehensive approach for reorienting land governance toward rights-based and sustainable development.
Regulatory and Governance Models for Sub-District Mediation Institutions in Community-Based Dispute Resolution Wahyudi Kurniawan; Cholidah Cholidah; Muhammad Wahdini; Mohd Norhusairi Mat Hussin
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

Community-based dispute resolution has long been practised informally by sub-district governments in Indonesia through deliberation and mediation facilitated by village heads, community leaders, and religious figures. Despite its significant role in maintaining social harmony, The practice remains institutionally weak due to the absence of a comprehensive legal framework, standardised governance, professional mediators, and operational procedures. Existing studies predominantly examine mediation, its effectiveness, or court-annexed mediation, while attention devoted to designing a regulatory and governance framework for community-based mediation institutions at the local government level remains limited. This study formulates a regulatory and institutional governance model for village/sub-district mediation institutions based on empirical findings from Malang City, Indonesia. Employing a socio-legal approach that integrates normative legal analysis with empirical research, this research collected data through statutory analysis, in-depth interviews with sub-district heads, observations, and document analysis. The findings reveal a three-dimensional regulatory loopholes in normative, institutional, and operational aspects, collectively hindering the institutionalisation of community mediation. To address these gaps, this study proposes an integrated regulatory and governance frameworkcomprising six interrelated components: regulatory philosophy, institutional arrangement, authority and jurisdiction, operational governance, accountability system and digital governance framework. Furthermore, the study develops a seven-stage operational governance modelencompassing institutional entry, case assessment, mediator appointment, community mediation process, settlement agreement, monitoring, and evaluation, supported by Integrated Community Mediation Information System aligned with Indonesia's Electronic-Based Government System. Theoretically, this study contributes to alternative dispute resolution literature by introducing the Three-Dimensional Regulatory Vacuum Theory and the Community-Based Mediation Governance Model, which integrate legal system theory, responsive law, institutional governance, collaborative governance and digital governance into a comprehensive framework for community dispute resolution. Practically, the proposed model offers an evidence-based blueprint for drafting local regulations and strengthening access to justice through institutionalised, accountable, and digitally enabled community mediation.
Reconstruction of the Causing Factors of the High Divorce Rate in Sambas in 2025 Asman
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

The high divorce rate in Sambas Regency in 2025 represents a complex socio-juridical phenomenon that requires a comprehensive study based on empirical data. Divorce is no longer understood as a mere individual event, but rather as a reflection of social, economic dynamics, and changing values ​​in society. This study aims to reconstruct the factors causing divorce through an integrative approach that combines legal, social, and religious perspectives based on data from the Sambas Religious Court. The method used is a socio-legal study with a qualitative approach, using primary data in the form of interviews and secondary data in the form of divorce case statistics in 2025. The results show that the dominant factors causing divorce include ongoing disputes and arguments, household economic pressures, infidelity, adultery and changes in social values ​​due to the influence of modernization and digitalization. These factors do not stand alone, but interact complexly to trigger household disintegration. The novelty of this study lies in the use of an integrative approach based on judicial data that allows for the identification of patterns of relationships between factors in a more systematic and contextual manner. The conclusion of this study formulates a conceptual model that states that divorce in Sambas in 2025 is the result of a multidimensional interaction between structural and cultural factors, with dysfunctional family communication predominating, exacerbated by economic pressures and transformations in social values. This model is expected to serve as a basis for formulating more effective preventive strategies and policy interventions to reduce the divorce rate.
Cybersecurity Risks and Legal Protection for Financial Investors in Indonesian and Malaysian Equity Crowdfunding Aris Yuni Pawestri; Amara Diva Abigail; Basuki Kurniawan; Fibran Ahmad Firdaus
Indonesia Law Reform Journal Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): July 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22219/ilrej.v6i2.45137

Abstract

This paper examines how cybersecurity risks are regulated within the ECF frameworks of these two countries and evaluates the effectiveness of the legal protections provided to financial investors. This study investigates the following central research question: how can a comparative legal framework be developed to strengthen the legal protection of financial investors against cybersecurity risks on Indonesian and Malaysian equity crowdfunding platforms? This study employs a normative legal research method, drawing on statutory, conceptual and comparative approaches. The legal materials examined include legislation, regulatory policies, cybersecurity governance frameworks and academic literature on equity crowdfunding and investor protection in Indonesia and Malaysia. The research reveals that both jurisdictions have established legal frameworks governing equity crowdfunding and digital financial services. However, cybersecurity governance, regulatory supervision, data protection standards and platform liability significantly differ. While Malaysia adopts a more integrated regulatory approach through centralised supervision and clearer cybersecurity requirements, Indonesia continues to experience regulatory fragmentation and overlapping institutional authority. The analysis shows that existing regulations in both countries primarily focus on financial compliance and market supervision, whereas legal protection against cybersecurity-related losses is minimal. Consequently, investors may face legal uncertainty when cyber incidents result in financial harm or unauthorised access to investment assets. Based on these findings, the study recommends developing a comparative legal framework that emphasises cyber resilience, stronger cybersecurity obligations for platform operators, enhanced investor rights, integrated regulatory supervision and clear liability mechanisms for cyber-related losses. Such reforms are expected to strengthen investor confidence, improve legal certainty and support the sustainable growth of equity crowdfunding ecosystems in Indonesia and Malaysia.

Page 12 of 13 | Total Record : 124