p-Index From 2021 - 2026
4.865
P-Index
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : New Language Dimensions

Profiling Student Teachers Tendencies on Peer Review Production Rahmawati, Eva
New Language Dimensions Vol. 1 No. 1 (2020): New Language Dimensions, June 2020
Publisher : English Department, Universitas Negeri Surabaya

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | Full PDF (190.206 KB) | DOI: 10.26740/nld.v1n1.p1-9

Abstract

ABSTRACT This is a report of a preliminary study focused on investigating student teachers tendencies of peer review production. The research is a basis for a more comprehensive research aiming to explain how the aforementioned tendencies affect the effectiveness of peer review. The data collected were in the form of students written commentaries taken from three expository and argumentative essay writing assignments. These data were collected from eight students, four high achievers and four low achievers. On the courses first meeting, an essay writing proficiency test was administered to determine researchs participants and dyads involved. To prepare students with peer review practice, a peer review tutorial and rubrics were also given on the first meeting of the course. Following this stage, students written commentaries were collected as data, which were then codified following the typology of written feedback by experts. Codification results were interpreted by comparing them to previous related research. In doing so, it was apparent that low achievers tend to produce commentaries on surface structure errors. As oppose to this, organization and content-focused commentaries were dominant in high achievers feedbacks. These findings are noteworthy, as they suggest a link between students proficiency level and their preferred commentary focus.Keywords: academic writing, peer review production, student teacher, commentary provision tendency.
Co-Authors . Rachmat achmad khairul Achmad Sumbaryadi, Achmad Ade Christian Ahmad Al Kaafi Ahmad Ishaq Akhiriyah, Suvi Akhmad Kasan Gupron, Akhmad Kasan Al Firdaus, M. Wildan Maulana Andi Agus Purnomo Andi Sanjaya Angger Wibowo Anton AYUNITA LELIANA Aziz Setyawan Hidayat, Aziz Setyawan Cahyo Pambudi Des Mulyati Desianty, Annisa Diana Dewi Sartika, Diana Dewi Doni Andriansyah Dwie Arifianto Ehon Abdulmanan Eka Kurniatun Hazanah Elly Mufida Elly Mufida, Elly Fachmi, Muhammad Fadillah Faizal Aziz Hidayatulloh Fathurrahman Dwi Ramtomo Fitria Fitria Habibah, Ridha Haikal Aserih Hani Harafani Hani Harafani, Hani Herlambang Brawijaya Hesti Nugraheni Hylenarti Hertiana Hylenarti Hertyana ira zulvia Irsyad Rafi Arsalan Irwansah Lubis Karo Karo, Alhazri khairul, achmad Lomotu , Syahrozi Maulana Farid Yunus Jahidin Mirianto, Agus Dina Mufida , Elly Muhammad, Alya Aulia Nur Muhopilah, Pipih Mulyati, Des Mulyawan, Yafiet Mustofa Mustofa Mustofa Mustofa Nafira Octaviani Amri Nanang Nuryadi Nandang Iriadi Nataza, Syali Oktavia Nugroho, Himmawan Adi Onivehu, Adams Ogirima Pambudi, Cahyo Pas Mahyu Akhirianto Pratama, Raka Putra Rahman, Taufikur Rahmawati, Eva Rahmawati Raka Putra Pratama Resmayanti, Mima Retno Wulan Dari Ria Ria Rohi, Saifurahman Romanda Annas Amrullah Sari, Tri Retna Sidik - Sidiq Sidiq Sidiq, Sidiq Sudirlan, Imelda Fransisca Sugeng Riyanto Syarif Hidayatulloh Toto Haryanto Tri Retnasari Waspodo, Waspodo Wibowo, Amiruddin Hadi Widjatmoko, Eko Nugroho Wiwiet Eva Savitri Yafiet Mulyawan Yudha Kamal Fauzan Yunita maudy Zainul Aminin