cover
Contact Name
Masduki
Contact Email
lppi@ums.ac.id
Phone
+62856-4096-0975
Journal Mail Official
lppi@ums.ac.id
Editorial Address
Magister Ilmu Hukum Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta Jln. A. Yani, Pabelan, Kartasura, Surakarta - 57162
Location
Kota surakarta,
Jawa tengah
INDONESIA
Jurnal Jurisprudence
ISSN : 18295045     EISSN : 25495615     DOI : -
Core Subject : Social,
Jurnal Jurisprudence is an academic journal published twice a year by the Magister Law Program of Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 74 Documents
Judicial Reasoning on Rehabilitation Orders for Offenders of Drug Abuse: a Ratio Decidendi Analysis of Indonesian Court Decisions Intan Munirah; Rizky Aulia Fitri; Khairil Akbar; Naqia Annisa Faradiz; Clarizze Yvoine Mirielle; Angga Aldilla Gussman
Jurnal Jurisprudence Vol. 16, No. 1, June 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.23917/jurisprudence.v16i1.15452

Abstract

Purpose of the Study: This study aims to analyze the judicial reasoning (ratio decidendi) of District Court Decision No. 92/Pid.Sus/2021/PN Bna and District Court Decision No. 16/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Sgi in ordering rehabilitation for offenders of drug abuse within the Indonesian criminal justice system, with a particular focus on how judges reconstruct legal facts and interpret rehabilitative norms under the double track sentencing framework.  Methodology: This research employs a normative juridical method with statutory, conceptual, and case approaches. The statutory approach examines relevant provisions, the conceptual approach analyzes the double track sentencing system, and the case approach focuses on District Court Decision No. 92/Pid.Sus/2021/PN Bna and District Court Decision No. 16/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Sgi. Legal materials were collected through library research and analyzed qualitatively using prescriptive and jurisprudential analyses. Results: The study finds that divergent sentencing outcomes in drug abuse cases are not caused by normative deficiencies, but by differences in judicial reasoning. Judges adopting a formalistic and retributive interpretation tend to marginalize assessment results and prioritize imprisonment, whereas judges employing a purposive and teleological approach integrate assessment findings as substantive legal facts and prioritize rehabilitation. This inconsistency demonstrates that the application of rehabilitation depends heavily on judicial interpretation rather than statutory mandate. Applications of this study: This research provides a jurisprudential foundation for judges, legal practitioners, and policymakers in strengthening consistency in sentencing practices for drug abuse cases, particularly in evaluating assessment results and applying rehabilitation within the double track system. Novelty/ Orginalty of this study: This study contributes originality by offering a jurisprudential analysis of ratio decidendi in rehabilitation-related verdicts, namely District Court Decision No. 92/Pid.Sus/2021/PN Bna and District Court Decision No. 16/Pid.Sus/2023/PN Sgi, demonstrating that inconsistencies in rehabilitation orders arise from judicial interpretative paradigms rather than legal norm ambiguity. It also proposes the need for coherent judicial reasoning standards in drug abuse sentencing. Keywords: Judicial Reasoning; Ratio Decidendi; Rehabilitation Orders; Drug Abuse; Indonesian Courts.
Constitutional Implications of Elections after Constitutional Court Decision : a Comparison of Indonesia and Malaysia Anang Dony Irawan; Levina Yustitianingtyas; Syivana Nabila; Anissa Putri Amelia; Mualimin Mochammad Sahid
Jurnal Jurisprudence Vol. 16, No. 1, June 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.23917/jurisprudence.v16i1.16174

Abstract

Purpose of the Study: This study analyzes the ratio decidendi of Constitutional Court Decision No. 135/PUU-XXII/2024, its constitutional implications for separating Indonesian elections, and compares the design with Malaysia's multi-level electoral system. Methodology: This research employs normative legal research using statutory, conceptual, jurisprudential, and comparative approaches. Primary legal materials include the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, relevant election laws, Constitutional Court decisions, and the Federal Constitution of Malaysia. Secondary materials consist of legal doctrines, scholarly journals, and comparative constitutional law literature, which are analyzed qualitatively through descriptive and comparative methods. Results: The Court's decision shifts Indonesia's electoral architecture by separating national and regional elections to enhance substantive democracy. However, it raises constitutional challenges regarding legal certainty, transitional governance, and judicial norm formation. The comparison with Malaysia reveals that while both jurisdictions separate subnational elections, Malaysia's practice derives from a federal framework, whereas Indonesia remains a unitary state. Applications of this Study: The findings provide normative guidance for harmonizing electoral legislation and designing an adaptive post-decision electoral governance framework. Novelty/Originality of this study: This study offers a comparative constitutional analysis integrating Decision 135/PUU-XXII/2024 with Malaysia’s system to model post-decision electoral governance reconstruction in Indonesia.  Keywords: Constitutional Implication; Elections; Constitutional Court Decision
A On the Crime of Illegal Fishing: A Comparison of Court Decisions in Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines Muhammad Amin Hanafi; Arief Budiono; Hasan Madilis; Gamar Muhdar; Saslina Kamaruddin; Joel Rey Ugsang Acob
Jurnal Jurisprudence Vol. 16, No. 1, June 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.23917/jurisprudence.v16i1.16589

Abstract

Purpose of the study: This article aims to comparatively analyze how courts in Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines develop legal considerations as well as impose sanctions in cases of illegal fishing criminal acts, by emphasizing differences in the legal systems, criminal policy orientations, and their implications for the enforcement of maritime law. Methodology: This was normative legal research which employed the library research method. It employed the statute, case, and comparative approaches, focusing on the analysis of court decisions as the main legal sources without conducting research in the field. The data were obtained through literary studies on legal regulations, court decisions with permanent binding power, as well as relevant literature on criminal law and international maritime law. Result: Research results show that there are fundamental differences in the construction of judges’ legal considerations and the sanctioning patterns on illegal fishing, where the Indonesian justice system tends to emphasize the aspect of national interests and sovereignty. Meanwhile, the Malaysian court orients towards legal certainty and normative compliance through economic sanctions. Next, the court of the Philippines integrates the criminal law approach with the goal of coastal resource management and the protection of the people’s interests. Applications of this study: The function of this research lies in its contribution to providing a more comprehensive understanding of the practice of maritime criminal justice in the Southeast Asian territory, as well as a reference material for policymakers and law enforcement agencies in formulating a more effective and contextual strategy to overcome the crime of illegal fishing. Novelty/Originality of this study: This research’s novelty is its focus on analyzing and comparing the court decisions of different countries as the main instrument to read the orientation of maritime criminal law policies, which are so far more commonly analyzed from the normative and international cooperation aspects. Thus, it offers a new perspective on the role of courts in increasing the effectiveness of law enforcement in the fisheries sector. Keywords: maritime criminal law; illegal fishing; maritime sovereignty; court decisions; legal comparison
Reconstructing Judicial Reasoning in Sexual Violence Cases Against Children: a Comparative Study of Indonesian and European Court Decisions Ida Musofiana; Tomás Mateo Ramon
Jurnal Jurisprudence Vol. 16, No. 1, June 2026
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.23917/jurisprudence.v16i1.16820

Abstract

Purpose of the study: This study aims to examine and reconstruct judicial reasoning in selected Indonesian court decisions on sexual violence against children, particularly Supreme Court Decision No. 574 K/Pid.Sus/2018 and Supreme Court Decision No. 813 K/Pid.Sus/2019, through a comparative analysis with the European Court of Human Rights decisions in M.C. v. Bulgaria and E.S. v. Slovakia. The study evaluates how judges interpret evidence and assess victim credibility while considering power imbalances and psychological vulnerability, with the objective of developing a victim-oriented judicial reasoning model that strengthens substantive justice and child protection. Methodology: This research employs a normative legal method using case and comparative approaches. The study analyzes the ratio decidendi of selected Indonesian and European court decisions concerning sexual violence against children. Through qualitative legal analysis, the study examines how judicial reasoning is constructed in relation to evidentiary assessment, victim testimony, psychological vulnerability, power imbalance, and the principle of the best interests of the child. Results: The findings indicate that judicial reasoning in Indonesia remains predominantly formalistic, emphasizing procedural legality and rigid evidentiary standards. Such an approach often neglects the psychological vulnerability of child victims, the existence of unequal power relations, and the principle of the best interests of the child. In contrast, European courts demonstrate a more progressive reasoning model by incorporating victim-oriented and trauma-informed perspectives that prioritize substantive justice and human rights protection. Applications: This study provides practical guidance for judges and policymakers in reformulating judicial reasoning to enhance the protection of child victims in criminal proceedings. Novelty/Originality: This research offers a novel contribution by integrating comparative judicial reasoning with a victim-oriented framework, proposing a reconstructed model that combines child-sensitive principles, contextual analysis, and human rights-based approaches. Keywords: child protection; comparative law; judicial reasoning; sexual violence; victim-oriented justice