Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Jurnal Konstitusi

Metode Tafsir Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi dalam Pengujian Konstitusional Undang-Undang Cipta Kerja Dodi Haryono
Jurnal Konstitusi Vol. 18 No. 4 (2021)
Publisher : Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia, Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | Full PDF (117.673 KB) | DOI: 10.31078/jk1843

Abstract

The use of the constitutional interpretation method by the judges of the Indonesian Constitutional Court (MK-RI) in their decision’s consideration (ratio decidendi) determine the decisions quality, therefore it must be chosen appropriately. In the context of Indonesian rule of law, the use of constitutional interpretation method should be implemented holistically, integrative, and using a dynamic approach, that must be harmonized with the Pancasila. This article is aimed to explain and analyze the use of constitutional interpretation method in the Constitutional Court Decision Number 91/PUU-XVIII/2020 regarding the Formal Constitutional Review of Law Number 11 of 2020 concerning Job Creation, as well as its theoretical implications. This article also proposes a new approach for constitutional interpretation method which is expected to strengthen the normative legitimacy and justification of the MK-RI decisions in the future. The method of analyses used in this article is the legal normative analyses with a conceptual approach. Finally, this article concludes that the method of constitutional interpretation in the Constitutional Court Decision Number 91/PUU-XVIII/2020 is considered as eclecticism. Using the new approach, the decision has also fulfilled the principles of holistic, integrative and dynamic constitutional interpretation based on Pancasila. For this reason, the Constitutional Court Decision Number 91/PUU-XVIII/2020 deserves to be used as one of the Landmark Decisions at the Indonesian Constitutional Court. However, the eclecticism approach wich is used by Indonesian Constitutional Court to interpret the constitution still needs to be developed in order to increase the normative of legitimacy and justification of decisions quality. In addition, that approach must also be linked to Pancasila both as a rechtsidee and staatsfundamentalnorm of the Indonesian state.
Co-Authors ', Erdiansyah ', Ikhsan ABDUL GHAFUR Abdul Ghafur Aflina, Dia Aisyah Hatta Lianda Akmal, Zainul Alfianim ' Alsidik Syahputra Andreas, Parda Doni Andri Fandio Reza Andrikasmi, Sukamarriko Angga Sastiawan Lantri Anggi Jukrianto Arika Saddami Azoumy, Nur Ghufran Bahrul Ilmi Binsar Bersahabat Hutasoit Budi Prasetyo daris a raft ginting daris a raft ginting, daris a raft Dedy Saputra Dessy Artina Dewi, Murti Sari Didik Saputra Diennissa Putriyanda, Diennissa Dihan Elzani Dina Febri Yulita Dwi Liza Wati Emilda Firdaus Erdiansyah ' erdiansyah erdiansyah, erdiansyah Erlando, Topan Rezki Evi Deliana HZ FELLA DEFILLA Fitra, Ade Fadillah fitria ningsih Fitriyani, Nia Geofani Milthree Saragih gusliana H.B. Gusliana H.B., Gusliana Gusliana HB Handika, Yoga Harry Surya Putra Hazra, Filza Amalia Hengki Firmanda Hotman Maringin Ikhsan ' Ikhsan Ikhsan Ikhsan Ikhsan IskandarIskandarIskandar, Hafiz Jendri Heri Sumarta Julranda, Rizky Junaidi ' Junaidi Junaidi Junaidi Junaidi Ledy Diana LESTARI, FIKA Lubis, Baihaki M Alpian M JAMHURI M. Sadewa Rafie Aldiza M. SADMI AL QAYUM Maria Maya Lestari Maryati Bachtiar Merina Nurmiati Mexsasai Indra Muhammad A. Rauf muhammad andi susilawan muhammad andi susilawan, muhammad andi Muhammad Fathra Fahasta Muhammad Roif Alghani Mukhlis R Nababan, Eprin Erikson Nilam Hananti Nurahim Rasudin Nurliana Br Siregar Panggabean, Mey Sry Rejeki Pika Julianti Putra, Tamin Ripinra Rani Rinaldi Rauf, Muhammad A Rauf, Muhammad A. Reza Fachrurrahman Rialdo Putra Ridho, Havid Riduan Z Rinaldi, Rahmi Rizwanda, Wawan Rofika Shopia Ronny Andreas Rudi Heriyanto Sihombing safrudin - Separen, Separen Septiana Ulfah Silfania Nigellia SINURAT, ARGA SANDYA RAJA Sri Nabila Sultan Fadillah Effendi Taufik Hidayat Triandi Bimankalid Ulhaq, Kaafin Vitari, Jihan Aqila WAHYU ADHA RAHMANSYAH Wahyu Hidayat Wahyu Noprianto, Wahyu Widia Edorita Yan Agus Priadi Zainul Akmal Zuhdi Arman Zulfahmi ' Zulwisman, Zulwisman