Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 32 Documents
Search

Judicial Legal Reasoning on Wife-Initiated Divorce (Cerai Gugat) and Its Social Determinants at the Surabaya Religious Court: A Parsonian AGIL Analysis Ramadlan, 'Adie Cahya; Panjalu, Gandhung Fajar; Hamzah, Saiful Ibnu
JURNAL AT-TURAS Vol 13, No 3 (2026): Islamic Law, Socio-Economic Empowerment, and Sustainable Development
Publisher : Universitas Nurul Jadid

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.33650/at-turas.v13i3.16757

Abstract

This research analyzes the social factors underlying the dominance of cerai gugat (wife-initiated divorce) at the Surabaya Religious Court, and the judges' legal considerations in adjudicating such cases, using Islamic legal sociology and Talcott Parsons' structural-functional theory (the AGIL scheme). This empirical legal research employs a qualitative approach. Primary data were purposively drawn from a semi-structured interview with a judge of the Surabaya Religious Court and analysis of two illustrative cerai gugat verdicts, selected for evidentiary richness rather than statistical representativeness; secondary data were sourced from statutory regulations and court reports. Data were analyzed through reduction, display, and conclusion drawing, with validity reinforced through source triangulation. Results show economic factors as the most dominant cause of cerai gugat in the cases examined, followed by domestic violence, infidelity, and loss of affective and communicative functions between spouses. Viewed through Parsons' AGIL scheme, the family's four basic functions show signs of concurrent strain in these cases, illustrating a loss of equilibrium in the family as a social system. These social facts are transformed into legal facts through the judges' legal reasoning: applicable norms serve as the major premise, and facts proven at trial as the minor premise, yielding the juridical qualification of broken marriage as ratio decidendi for granting the petition, alongside the ex officio imposition of iddah maintenance, mut'ah, and child support. The study contributes by tracing how family-system strain is qualified into the statutory grounds courts rely upon.
The Dialectics of Gender Justice within Patrilineal Systems: A Comparative Analysis of Inheritance Flexibility in Islamic Law and Balinese Hindu Adat Law in Indonesia Gandhung Fajar Panjalu; Ali Mufrodi; Sholihul Huda
SPECTRUM: Journal of Gender and Children Studies Vol 6 No 1 (2026): June
Publisher : The Center for Gender and Children Studies, the Institute for Research and Communing Service, State Islamic Institute of Manado (IAIN) Manado, Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30984/spectrum.v6i1.1867

Abstract

This study aims to analyze how both systems engage in dialectics to address the challenges of substantive gender justice and sociological issues, such as gender ratios and higher female life expectancy. Utilizing a normative legal research method with a comparative approach, this study examines legal flexibility instruments as solutions that do not abandon patrilineal principles. The results indicate that Islamic law in Indonesia takes a distributive path by optimizing grants (hibah) and mandates (wasiat) to balance women's economic rights. Meanwhile, Balinese Hindu customary law employs a transformation of juridical status through the institution of sentana rajeg and nyeburin marriage to establish women as primary heirs. The fundamental difference lies in the focus of flexibility: Islam modifies the distribution of property objects, whereas Balinese Hindu law re-engineers the status of the legal subject. This study concludes that such flexibility is a manifestation of ijtihad and local wisdom in achieving welfare (maslahah) without undermining the theological foundations of each legal system.