Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : JHCLS

Artificial Intelligence and Quality of Composition Verdicts in Indonesia: Lessons from New Zealand Hidayah, Nur Putri; Wicaksono, Galih Wasis; Aditya, Christian Sri Kusuma; Munarko, Yuda
Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System Vol. 4 No. 1 (2024): Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System
Publisher : Lembaga Contrarius Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.53955/jhcls.v4i1.175

Abstract

The quality of the decision is not only related to the judge's considerations but also its suitability to the composition of the decision so that the resulting decision is not easily overturned at the level of legal action and increases public confidence in the judicial institution. This research aims to analyze the quality of judges' decisions in Indonesia in terms of the composition of the decision texts that have been made. This research uses normative legal research methods, a statutory approach, and a comparative approach. The study results show that decisions are not based on the structure of decisions determined by the Supreme Court. One of the reasons is the minimal use of AI, even though AI can help judges identify which parts of the decision structure are not yet in the decision prepared by the judge and improve them so that it is hoped that it will produce uniformity and decisions that are certain and not easily overturned. Indonesia needs to learn from New Zealand guidelines for using AI at the court and tribunal level. Judges can apply AI, some related to summarizing information and administration.
Co-Authors Adi Bagus Setiawan Agus Eko Minarno Ahmad Faiz, Ahmad Ahmad Salam Rahim Al asqalani, Sheila Fitria Al Sakinata, Annisa' Al-Fatih, Solahudin Al-rizki, Muhammad Andi Aldiensyah Aldy Satria Gumilar Alfian Dwi Khoirul Annas Alfira Rizky Alimuddin Hasan Al Kabir Amiludin, Amiludin Aminudin Aminudin, Aminudin Andesti, Kiki Andjani Chaerun Nisha Andreawan Andreawana, Andreawana Anisa Dewi Anggraeni Arcelia, Allysa Sonia Aria Maulana Eka Mahendra arrafiq, ubay hakim Aulyah, Khairunnisa Azzahra, Kiara Basuki, Setio Bella Dwi Mardiana Budiono Budiono Budiono Budiono Chandranegara, Didih Rizki Cholidah, - Christian Sri Kusuma Aditya Christian Sri Kusuma Aditya Christian Sri kusuma Aditya, Christian Sri kusuma Dati Nafa Alfiana Didih Rizki Chandranegara Edo Ardhiansyah Eko Budi Cahyono Erwin Budi Setiawan Evi Dwi Wahyuni Fakhrul Nasrulloh Fath Dzulkifli Febri Ayu Fitriani Feny Aries Tanti Ferdiansyah, Danny Gilang Ramadhan Gita Indah Marthasari Hakim, Muhammad Nafi Maula Hardianto Wibowo Hari Windu Asrini Harmanto, Dani Hermansyah Adi Saputra Hilman Abi Sarwan Heryawan I'anatut Thoifah Ianatut Thoifah Intana Sari, Tiara Iqbal Fairus Zamani Kharisma Muzaki Ghufron Lathifah, Fildzah Maskur Maskur Muafika, Siti Nurmala Lailatul Muhammad Andi Al-Rizki Muhammad Farhansyah Muhammad Riadi Muhammad Risky Pratama Hermawan Muhammad Rojib Saiful Nisrina Arintia Maghfiroh Nizarullah Himawan Noor Prasetyo, Said Nur Hayatin Nur Oktaviana, Ulfah Nur Putri Hidayah Nuryasin, Ilyas Perdana, Muhammad Ilham Rakha Pradana Susilo Putra Ricky Hendrawan Rizka Nurlizah Rizky, Alfira Rizky, Wahyu Saiful Amien Saiful Arif, Mukhammad Rojib Saleh, Abd Saleha, Meisya Maulidina Sari, Tiara Intana Syuyukh, Fakhrusy Ulfah Nur Oktaviana Wahyu Budi Utomo Wildan Suharso Yuda Munarko Yufis Azhar Yunus, Nur Rohim Zakiyah Rakhmawati Zamah Sari