Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : The Digest: Journal of Jurisprudence and Legisprudence

The Judge’s Perspective on Material Unlawfulness in Cases of Illegal State House Control (Case of Decision Number 2002/Pid.B/2011/PN.Jkt.Pst) Rusdiana, Emmilia; Febrianti, Rena Arya; Putra, Dandi Akbar
The Digest: Journal of Jurisprudence and Legisprudence Vol 4 No 2 (2023): The Digest, December 2023
Publisher : Universitas Negeri Semarang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15294/digest.v4i2.75872

Abstract

This study explores the legal issues arising from housing and settlements, where individuals may assume defendant status when occupying a house without ownership, a status valid only with the owner's approval. The enactment of Law Number 1 of 2011, which revokes Law Number 4 of 1992, prompts judges to ponder its implications, especially in relation to Article 1 paragraph (2) of Law Number 1 of 1946 concerning the Indonesian Criminal Code (KUHP). The judge's decision, linked to the unlawfulness of the case, raises significant concerns. This paper seeks to underscore the inaccuracies in the judge’s interpretation of Criminal Code Article 1 paragraph (2) and the disregard for material law in the decision-making process. The research findings unveil a disparity in perspectives between Law Number 4 of 1992 and Law Number 1 of 2011 concerning case handling, leading to the conclusion that the case fails to satisfy the elements of Criminal Code Article 1 paragraph (2). The judge's misinterpretation is rooted in prioritizing the principle of legality (Article 1 paragraph 1) while overlooking the violation of material law. Importantly, this research contributes a nuanced understanding of the legal landscape, shedding light on the implications of housing laws and their intersection with criminal statutes.
Co-Authors ., Hifni Abdul Madjid ADHI WICAKSONO, SETYO Ahmad, Gelar Ali Aisy, Shinta Farah Rohadatul Aisyiah, Siti Nur AJI, ROJIL NUGROHO BAYU Aji, Wisnu Kuncoro AKBAR ROSYIDI, ACHMAD Al Akbar, Esa Setya AL HAFIEDZ, ADHEN Alfiassalam, Fawziah Nur Andreansyah, Gilang Chesar Anggraini, Crisdinata Refta ARI ADYATI, ANISA Arianto Nugroho, Arianto Arinto Nugroho Arizki, Faisal Farras Prima Armadonny, Rizky Arrifqi, Moh Fahmi ARUM PERTIWI, HELADIN ashola, dunga AWALANANDA, RIDHO AYU DINI, ALMIRA BAGAS AGUS N, CANDRA Bahari, Cornelia Indira Kusuma Bin Awang, Mohd Badrol Damayanti, Henny Puspita damayanti, reynisa ikko Delpiro, Ervindo Dewi Setyowati Edy Mulyono EKA PUTRA PRIYONO, FRYANSAH Fajriyah, Laila Himmatul Fazila, Arina Nur Febriant, Rena Arya Febrianti, Rena Arya Gantara, Rega Angga Gumelar, Adam HANANTO WIDODO Hardianti, Firda Yanis Hermawati, Rr. Lilis Hernanda, Dhicha Ayudiah IFTITAHUL AHSANI, TASYA Ilmansyah, Destra Ridho Risma Indah Bilqis, Vidya Afiyanti Irfa Ronaboyd IRFAN SAPUTRO, TINO Kurniawan, Devit Kusuma, Dinda Puteri Fathurachmah Layli, Azyzatul Maharani, Rizkiyah Putri Mahardhika, Vita Mahesa, Rifqi Noviendra Milda Istiqomah Mochtar, Helmi Nauval Muhammad Khoirul Huda Muhammad, Tio Aldino MUKARROMAH, LULUUL Muntari, Laedy Septi Nathalia, Dessy Ni'mah, Eka Maulan Nurul Hikmah Ocktavianti, Okky Oktaviani, Asfarina Pajuk, Adeline Angelina Pangestuti, Sisca PANJI SUGIARTO PUTRA, GUSTI Pasaribu, Kesna Elia PRABAWATI, TIARA DEWI Prasetio, Dicky Eko PUDJI ASTUTI PURNAMA SARI, MIRA Puspita, Audy Clara Putra, Dandi Akbar Putri, Senia Wandalillah Rachmania, Adinda Hilda Ramadhan, Rizki Wahyu Rindiarto, Ardhian Fadillah roszana, dina Said, Muhamad Helmi Md SARI, ELMA Sari, Nurnilam Sidauruk, Karsito Pardomuan Sonny Zulhuda SYAH PUTRA, AFFRIANTO Tinambunan, Hezron Sabar Rotua TRI YANINGRUM, SEPTI Tsania, Shofi Wilda ULVA DWI SEPTIYOWATI, LIDYA UROMAH, ANISA Wahono, Eldiva Firtsananda Arrafi Wahyudi, Bagus Dwi WAHYUDI, PONCO Widyowati, Wulandari WULANDARI, MILIA Yatunisa, Rizki Yekti, Fetty Faulina Yuardini, Fransiska Yuardini Yulia, Eva Yundari, Yundari Yuniantari, Djihan YUSANDHA, MERZADIO