Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Lex Scientia Law Review

Enhancing Fair Use in Protecting Appropriated Artworks: A Comparative Analysis of Safeguarding Indonesian Copyright Law Nadya Aurelia, Caitlynn; Tanaya, Velliana; Sugianto, Fajar; Yamamoto, Atsuko
Lex Scientia Law Review Vol. 9 No. 1 (2025): May, 2025: Law, Technology, and Globalization: Challenges and Innovations in th
Publisher : Universitas Negeri Semarang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15294/lslr.v9i1.20570

Abstract

Appropriated artwork refers to the practice of using pre-existing objects or images into new works of art with little or no significant changes to the original form. This trend developed into the Pop Art movement, where one of the characteristic features was the use of images from mass media, as seen in the works of Andy Warhol, including the transformation of Campbell's soup cans into iconic works of art. Although widely appreciated, this work has drawn criticism regarding copyright infringement, raising the question: where do one artist's rights draw on another? To what extent is the appropriation of copyright protected works considered legal without violating the rights of the original creator? The research results show that the two legal systems differ significantly in the aspects of exclusive rights, moral rights, protected works, exceptions, and duration of protection. The challenge in understanding fair use lies in determining the boundaries between the rights of one artist and another. The fair use doctrine assesses four main factors: the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the original work, the proportion of the work used, and the impact on the market. Courts in the US often favor fair use if elements of transformation are identified, measuring the extent to which the appropriated work carries elements of originality or new creativity. Indonesia could consider adopting the fair use doctrine by adapting the concept through ministerial regulations or other implementing regulations.
Co-Authors Abraham Jiavello Rumampuk Akila Kieyenatama Kristanto Aldryan Perez Elisa Paka Angeline, Felicia Audrea Dindya Djohan Baretta, Nicole Cassey Regina Salamintargo Catherine Susantio Catrina Yuka Chen, Natasya Edgina Christabella, Sheren Desuardi, Shabrina Aurellia Nafisah Dian Parluhutan Dicky Winata Dicky Winata, Dicky Djohan, Audrea Dindya Dwi Nugraha Dwi Putra Nugraha Elena Philomena Lee Elisa Paka, Aldryan Perez Elizabeth Prima Ratrisari elsa, elsa Emmanuel Stutanto, Theodore Francisco Fajar Sugianto Felicia Angeline Gisella Helga Xaviera Gunadi, Chaterine Grace Gunawan, Anneke Catlynne Gunawan, Lauren Angel Gymnastiar, Rigan Haganta Orvin Ginting Harimurti Adi Nugroho Hasianatama, Tri Indrakusuma, Jason Jason Matthew Anthony Jemimah Puteri Rajagukguk Jessica Angeline Zai Jessica Vincentia Marpaung Jessy Yohanes Jordan Baros Indraputra Silalahi Jordan Baros Indraputra Silalahi Joseph Radya Pandu Nararya Kristanto, Akila Kieyenatama Kwu, Paulina Shelly Lee, Elena Philomena Lo, Adeline Marpaung, Jessica Vincentia Matthew Benedictus Manuputty Mirelle Elicia Perera Nadya Aurelia, Caitlynn Nathanael, Sheren Christabella Nugraha, Dewi Nugraha, Dwi Nugroho, Harimurti Adi P. Karo, Rizky Pratama Paulina Shelly Kwu Paulina Shelly Kwu Perera, Mirelle Elicia Putri, Intan Indriani Putri, Veronica Salim, Hartono Agus Shabrina Aurellia Nafisah Desuardi Sheren Christabella Nathanael Silalahi, Jordan Baros Indraputra Silalahi, Thomas Rifera Indraputra Singgih, Marvino Nathanael Steven Ignatius Chandra Subiran, Danishel Thomas Rifera Indraputra Silalahi Thomas Rifera Indraputra Silalahi Veronica Enjelina Manalu Veronica Putri Xaviera, Gisella Helga Yamamoto, Atsuko Yap, Celine Alexia Yohanes, Jessy Yuka, Catrina