Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search
Journal : Pandecta

Asymmetrical Arbitration Clauses: A Comparative Study of International and Indonesian Arbitration Law Lingkanaya, Jovanka; Adolf, Huala; Amalia, Prita
Pandecta Research Law Journal Vol 16, No 1 (2021): June
Publisher : Universitas Negeri Semarang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15294/pandecta.v16i1.29522

Abstract

This article presents a study of the validity of asymmetrical arbitration clauses, a clause that combines arbitration and a choice of court option, in international commercial contracts. These clauses designate a method of dispute settlement that gives a more favorable position for one of the parties to a contract, hence, creating a debate on its validity on an international level. Despite the convenience the trend has brought in business, this form of arbitration clause has been called into doubt by courts in numerous jurisdictions. Unfortunately, Indonesia itself has yet to have a firm legal standing on this matter as asymmetrical arbitration clauses are not explicitly regulated by the Indonesian arbitration law. This research is conducted by exploring the relation between theories and practices concerning asymmetrical arbitration clauses through analyzing case law and provisions of international arbitration law and the Indonesian arbitration law, and are also analyzed through principles of international and Indonesian contract law. This article aims to provide an analysis regarding the legal effects of having asymmetrical arbitration clauses in commercial contracts and commercial arbitration. Lastly, this study offers a method of interpretation towards such clauses that favors their validity under both international arbitration law and Indonesian arbitration law.
Asymmetrical Arbitration Clauses: A Comparative Study of International and Indonesian Arbitration Law Jovanka Lingkanaya; Huala Adolf; Prita Amalia
Pandecta Research Law Journal Vol 16, No 1 (2021): June
Publisher : Universitas Negeri Semarang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15294/pandecta.v16i1.29522

Abstract

This article presents a study of the validity of asymmetrical arbitration clauses, a clause that combines arbitration and a choice of court option, in international commercial contracts. These clauses designate a method of dispute settlement that gives a more favorable position for one of the parties to a contract, hence, creating a debate on its validity on an international level. Despite the convenience the trend has brought in business, this form of arbitration clause has been called into doubt by courts in numerous jurisdictions. Unfortunately, Indonesia itself has yet to have a firm legal standing on this matter as asymmetrical arbitration clauses are not explicitly regulated by the Indonesian arbitration law. This research is conducted by exploring the relation between theories and practices concerning asymmetrical arbitration clauses through analyzing case law and provisions of international arbitration law and the Indonesian arbitration law, and are also analyzed through principles of international and Indonesian contract law. This article aims to provide an analysis regarding the legal effects of having asymmetrical arbitration clauses in commercial contracts and commercial arbitration. Lastly, this study offers a method of interpretation towards such clauses that favors their validity under both international arbitration law and Indonesian arbitration law.
Co-Authors AA Agustia Sinta Dewi Adi Nurzaman Adiza, Salza Fadila Afifah Zakiyatul Aulia Ahmad Farhan Baihaqqi Akbar, Amrul An An Chandrawulan An An Chandrawulan An An Chandrawulan Anhar Fauzan Priyono Anindita, Sashia Diandra Anindya Saraswati Ardiwinata Astuti, Violi Maulidya Charlieans Ning Aziz, Wahyu Rizkika Belaputri, Addyana Chandrawulan, An-An, Prof. Damos Dumoli Agusman Dandrivanto Budhijanto Danrivanto Budhijanto Dewanto, Jagad Putra Dewi Kania Sugiharti Dwi Linna Suswardany Erlien Erlien Aunina Linggar Aji Fachran, Syahreza Faradina, Tazky Aulia Fatimah Ibtisam Fery Irawan Garry Gumelar Pratama Hanan Aliya Putri Hayati, Aisyah Nur Helitha Novianty Muchtar Helitha Novianty Muchtar Huala Adolf Ida Bagus Mahawira Nawagani Inzaghi, Rafly Nauval IRAWAN, FERY Isis Ikhwansyah Isis Ikhwansyah Jessica Leonard Jonathan Matthew Jovanka Lingkanaya Kanris, Jesslyn Karami, Ahmad Adib Kurdi Kurdi Labib Wajdi, Muhammad Laksono, Wahyu Agung Leonard, Jessica Lingkanaya, Jovanka Makmun, M. Lazuardy Thariq Maulanisa, Hasna Fitri Nurzaman, Adi Nurzaman, R. Adi Owen, Patrick Pamungkas, Eksa Pamungkas, Eksa Pandu Rizky Putra Pratama Pupung Faisal Puput Mardiani Purba, Tesalonika Putri Pinuram Rambe Purnama Trisnamansyah Putri, Hanan Aliya Putri, Resha Roshana Qolby, Fatihatul Ramadhan, Ana Noviana Sashia Diandra Anindita Sinta Dewi Sinta Dewi Rosadi Suhendra, Hartono Syukri Syukri Taufik Rachmat Nugraha Velani Prastika Diyanto Velicia Theoartha Manalu Velly, Nicholas Vida Azaria Wahyu Agung Laksono Wangsit Restu Adi Guritno Wardhana, Yuki Mahardhito Adhitya Wawan Hermawan Wawan Hermawan Yogi Suprayogi Yogi Suprayogi Sugandi Yudi Azis