Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

FROM APPRECIATION TO DISSATISFACTION: EXPLAINING VISITOR EVALUATIONS THROUGH ONLINE REVIEWS OF A CULTURAL AND RELIGIOUS HERITAGE DESTINATION Sri Maryanti; Febrian Humaidi Sukmana; Nila Rahayu
Multifinance Vol. 4 No. 2 (2026): Multifinance
Publisher : PT. Altin Riset Publishing

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.61397/mfc.v4i2.570

Abstract

Online reviews provide destination managers with unsolicited accounts of service encounters, place meanings, and perceived value. Yet aggregate ratings can conceal the mechanisms through which visitors move from appreciation to dissatisfaction, particularly at heritage destinations that combine sacred, historical, and recreational functions. This study examines visitor evaluations of Pura Agung (Taman) Narmada, Lombok, through 207 TripAdvisor reviews reported in the source manuscript. The study adopts an interpretive netnographic orientation and combines qualitative content analysis with inductive thematic analysis. The reported rating distribution comprises 35 five-star, 81 four-star, 75 three-star, 11 two-star, and five one-star reviews, with a reported mean rating of 3.6. Across rating groups, six interconnected dimensions structure visitor accounts: cultural, historical, and spiritual meaning; physical environment and aesthetics; supporting facilities and attractions; destination management and governance; social interaction and service; and emotional-evaluative responses. The synthesis indicates that heritage significance and landscape aesthetics function as core sources of appreciation, but they do not compensate consistently for weaknesses in maintenance, interpretation, service standardisation, pricing transparency, and the management of interactions. The article contributes to experience-oriented destination management by showing how intrinsic heritage value and operational delivery jointly shape online evaluations. For managers, the findings support an integrated approach that protects sacred meanings while improving cleanliness, interpretation, accessibility, service protocols, and the coherence of recreational facilities. The findings are interpretive and platform-specific; they should not be treated as representative estimates of all visitors.
Co-Authors Abdurrahman Abdurrahman Adika Paranata Adrianda Anwar Adrianda Anwar Akram Akram Akram, Akram Andika Noviawan, Lalu Animah Animah Anisa Savira Antoni Antoni Anwar, Adri Arista Pradnyani I Gusti Agung Arista Pradnyani, I G A Bambang Bambang Burhanudin Burhanudin Dewi Rakhmawati Dewi Rispawati Eny Widiaty Evrita Putri Azzahroh Evrita Putri Azzaroh Fatimah Azzahra Febrian Humaidi Sukmana Ferdaus, Nadia Nuril Genadi, Yeldy Dwi Hendri Saleh I GUSTI AGUNG ARISTA I Gusti Agung Arista Pradnyani I Gusti Agung Arista Pradnyani I Gusti Agung Arista Pradnyani, I Gusti Agung Arista I Gusti Agung Ayu Pramita Indraswari I Gusti Putu Widya Atmaja I GUSTI PUTU WIDYA ATMAJA I Ketut Tri Anansa I.G.A Arista Pradnyani I.G.A. Arista Pradnyani Iman Hidayatullah Ismayadi Armansyah Isti Fadah Iwan Kusuma Negara Jayawarsa, A.A. Ketut Khaerul Umam, Khaerul Kurniawan Syahputra, M. Lusi Shinta Nugraha Maria Dewi, Suprayanti Mohammad Yanwar Doraq MUAIDY YASIN, MUAIDY Muh Zaini Nadia Nuril Ferdaus Nanda Dwipratiwi Ladila Nazwa Farahdila Nazwa Farahdila Nur Fazillah Milawati Nur Fazillah Milawati Nur Fazillah Milawati Nur Fitriyah nurfazillah milawati Nursin Nursin Paradisa Sukma Putu Atim Purwaningrat Ramli Ramli Reny Wardiningsi Resty Yusnirmala Dewi Rini Adriani Auliana Rispawati, Dewi Rusdan Rusdan Sagir, Junaidi Sahirul Alim Sakhila, Yana Samsul Karmaen Septiani Larasati Siti Aisyah Hidayati Sri Maryanti Sri Maryanti Sri Maryanti Suhaemi Hilmi TONY WINATA Wardiningsih, Reny Widia Astuti Widia Astuti Yeldi Dwi Genadi Yeldy Dwi Genadi Yulia Fitri Rosydiati Yulia Fitri Rosydiati Zaenal Wafik, Ahmad Zamroni Alpian Muhtarom Zukrina Kholis