Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search
Journal : RechtIdee

The Influence Of Differences In Judges' Opinions On Legal Certainty In Deciding A Case Claudia, Jean; Firmansyah, Hery
RechtIdee Vol 20, No 1 (2025): JUNE
Publisher : Trunojoyo Madura University

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21107/ri.v20i1.30285

Abstract

This study examines the influence of differences of opinion among judges on legal certainty in court decisions. In judicial practice, differences of opinion between judges often arise and have the potential to affect consistency and legal certainty, which are one of the main pillars of the legal system. The research method used is qualitative with a juridical-normative approach, utilizing analysis of relevant laws and legal literature. The results of the study indicate that differences of opinion among judges can cause legal uncertainty if not managed properly, thus impacting the credibility of the judicial institution and public trust in the judge's decision. Therefore, it is important to develop clear mechanisms and standards for handling differences of opinion among judges to maintain legal certainty in the judicial system. 
Legal Review of The Criminal Act of Murder of Women By Intimate Partners Based on The Provisions of The Act on PKDRT Chrishans, Raffael Moreno; Firmansyah, Hery
RechtIdee Vol 20, No 1 (2025): JUNE
Publisher : Trunojoyo Madura University

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21107/ri.v20i1.30566

Abstract

The phenomenon of domestic violence that results in the death of women by intimate partners shows a gap in the legal protection that should be provided by the state. This study examines how Law Number 23 of 2004 concerning the Elimination of Domestic Violence (UU PKDRT) regulates and qualifies murder in domestic relations, and the extent of its effectiveness in implementation. The issues discussed include aspects of normative regulation and the application of law in the field. The methodology applied is normative legal research, using a legislative approach and a case approach. Data sources were obtained through literature studies from laws and regulations, court decisions, and relevant academic opinions, and analyzed qualitatively. The findings show that although the Law on PKDRT contains legal provisions regarding serious physical violence, including that which causes death, its implementation has not been optimal. The low understanding of law enforcement officers, the influence of patriarchal culture, and the lack of protection for victims are the main obstacles. Therefore, integration between the Criminal Code and the Law on PKDRT is needed, as well as increasing the competence of law enforcement officers so that victim protection becomes more effective and just.
Co-Authors Adeline, Laurencia Ahmad Muzacky Aisyah Cahyani, Putri Amelia Abdullah Zimah Aprianes, Cesilia Audy, Viola Cendranita, Ivannia Cesilia Aprianes Charenitha, Aurellia Chrishans, Raffael Moreno Cintya, Sindhi Claudia, Jean Deryl Leeland Dianti, Anisa Rahma Edgar, Calvin Egieta Christy Tarigan Evangeline Amanta Chrisya Evelyn Natasha, Evelyn Fahmi Saputra, Ewaprilyandi Febiola, Stefany Florencia Fevernova, Fiona George Daniel Pangaribuan Gunawan, Angelene Vivian Halim, Hartaty Harefa, Dany Hendra Jaya Harshita, Harshita Hasna, Nada Putri Henlindra, Roland Nofenick Gunther Hugo Feris Tri Susanto Hum, M. Indri Elena Suni Ivanca, Eveline Jean Ranice Siregar, Alynne Khoiroh, Aimmatul Kholim, Fellicia Angelica Kuistono, Caesar Andre Liberty, Gavriel Lim, Hamielly Cortez Madani, Irfan Syauqi Mandala, Azi Fachri Marbun, Jessica Marshanda, Talitha Mathiew Mahulette, Andrew Reinhard Matthew Mikha Sebastian Matondang Michelle, Grace Bernadette Mikael Rondo, Pieter Agustinus Mutiara Adival, Julisya Nadhir, Khibran Natashya, Natashya Naufal Wala, Gevan Ngadio, Gabriel Nugroho, Dryan Oemar, Erwin Natosmal Oktavina, Margaretha Andini Patty, Thalia Rizq Aurora Putra, Surya Dharma Putra, Verdy Cahyana Putri, Lisentia Putri, Nessya Monica Larasati Riyanto Prameswara, Dwi Sabrina, Najwa Maulida Sahrul, Farhan Ananda Sandini, Jessica Sanjaya, Bintang Theo Sealtiel, Marselly Siahaan, Shinta Aulia Sukur, Partermutios Susilo Putra Sun Lisyah, Lisyah Susanto, Hugo Feris Tri Tata Wijayanta Timothy Benaya, Marsahala Trinovada, Andrew Valedra Sitorus, Juan Vanessa Vanessa Walla, Mikhael Melvren Widagdo, Chanandika Dafri