Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Jurnal Cakrawala Hukum

Granting a compulsory will to grandfather and grandmother based on Aristotle's distributive theory Kasuwi Saiban; Titi Rusydiyati Al Kaswy; Fadil SJ
Jurnal Cakrawala Hukum Vol 13, No 3 (2022): December 2022
Publisher : Faculty of Law, University of Merdeka Malang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.26905/idjch.v13i3.8855

Abstract

There is no legal basis for giving testament wajibah to a grandparent in Indonesia. However, the Religious Courts of Tarakan, in decision number: 610/Pdt.G/2014/PA.Trk. the judges gave testament wajibah portion of the inheritance to the grandparent because the heir’s mother blocked their position and the parenting role carried out by the grandparent since the mother left the heir, and her existence was unknown. The judge’s decision must consider the principles of legal certainty, benefits, and a sense of justice for the parties. Therefore, this research focuses on the judge’s legal reasoning in decision number: 610/Pdt.G/2014/PA.Trk. and how the judge’s decision is seen from the perspective of Aristotle’s distributive justice theory. This research is juridical-normative with cases and conceptual approaches. The results showed that the judge’s legal reasoning through the process of de heuristic and de legitimate, legal basis that judges used are the holy Qur’an, hadith, KHI, and Islamic law. The judges consider the role of grandparents during the heir to life. And giving testament wajibah to grandparents is considered fair based on Aristotle’s distributive justice theory because they have fulfilled the proportional principle requirements.How to cite item: Saiban, K., Al Kaswy, T., SJ, F. (2022). Granting a compulsory will to grandfather and grandmother based on Aristotle's distributive theory. Jurnal Cakrawala Hukum, 13(3), 272-280. DOI:https://doi.org/10.26905/idjch.v13i3.8855.
Co-Authors AA Sudharmawan, AA Abd Azis Tata Pangarsa Agung Wijayanto, Much Ahmad Izzuddin Ahmad Kholil Ahsani Taqwiem Alfi Syahri, Vanda Kamila Ali Mahmudi Ali Mahmudi Andi Poerwanto Soedjatmiko Anggun Imanto Anugerah, Ghifari Fajar Atik Abidah Az, M. Ghufron Badrud Tamam Budiyono Santoso Cut Amirah Fatinah Efriza Pahlevi Wulandari Evi Rohmatzzuhriyah Fadil SJ Fadilla Lailawaty Farhan, Muhammad Faiz Fatkhul Choiri, Mohamad Ğafurof, Rishat Ameer Hafidh, Hafidh Hidayat, Raya Hidayati, Manzilah Nuri Imamul Hakim Imamul Hakim Imanto, Anggun Jamrud Zaman Kartika Rose Rachmadi Khairani Mukdin Khoirul Musthofa Kholili Kholilulloh, Habib Khotbatul Laila Laili Mas’udah M. Luthfillah Habibi M. Taufiq Hidayat M. Yunus Abu Bakar Mas’udah, Laili Matnin MH Ainulyaqin Miftahul Khoir Misbahul Munir Misbahul Munir Misbahul Munir Misbahul Munir Misbahul Munir Moch. Mahsun Mohamad Fatkhul Choiri Mubin, Ufuqil Muchammad Fauzan Zenrif Mufarrihul Hazin Muhid Muhid Muhid, Muhid Muhtadi Ridwan Mujtaba, Wardah Mustofa Mustofa Nadia Ananda Putri Nafila, Radifa Isnain Naqiyyatussa’diyah, Naqiyyatussa’diyah Nik Saleh, Nik Salida Suhaila Noer Yasin Nu'man, Ali Nugroho, Rahmat Nurfadilah Nurfadilah Nurul Falach, Alifya putri, atina rokhmani Qomari, Nur R. Cecep Lukman Yasin R. Rusli Rahmat Vijay Bengal Ridwan, Muhtadi Rizkika Agustin Rostami , Soheila Rozendana, Fahed Zurrofin Sa'dun Akbar Saiful Bakhri Salsabila, Fajrina Dhia Soheila Rostami Solikhul Hidayat Sri Mulyani Sri Mulyani Sunarjo Sunarjo Suswanto Suswanto Suswanto Suswanto, Suswanto Syanaya Mela Abyta Syarif, Mas Abdullah Titi Rusydiyati Al Kaswy Triyo Supriyatno Tutik Hamidah Umi Salamah Umi Salamah Utien Kustianing Wahyudi Widodo Wardah Mujtaba Wika Yudha Shanty, Wika Yudha Yamin, Ashabul Yusran Yusran Zainur Rozikin Zaman, Jamrud Zenrif, Muchammad Fauzan