Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Jurnal Akta

Analysis of Adjudicative Authority in Regional Election Disputes: A Case Study of the Cianjur Regency Regional Election Dispute Based on Law Number 10 of 2016 and Its Amendments on the Election of Governors, Regents, and Mayors Sinaga, Dahman; Nuraeni, Yeni; Sihombing, Lasmin Alfies
JURNAL AKTA Vol 12, No 4 (2025): December 2025
Publisher : Program Magister (S2) Kenotariatan, Fakultas Hukum, Universitas Islam Sultan Agung

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30659/akta.v12i4.51409

Abstract

The administration of regional head elections (Pilkada), as a manifestation of popular sovereignty, requires a dispute resolution mechanism that ensures justice and legal certainty. However, Law No. 10 of 2016 distributes dispute resolution authority among several institutions, which in practice creates the potential for jurisdictional conflicts. This study examines the problem of overlapping authority between the General Courts in handling electoral criminal offenses and the Constitutional Court in resolving disputes over Pilkada results. The objective of this research is to analyze juridically the source of the conflict of authority and its impact on legal certainty, with a case study of the Cianjur Regency Pilkada. The findings indicate that the fragmented attribution of authority under Law No. 10 of 2016 does not provide a synchronization mechanism between criminal judgments that have obtained permanent legal force (inkracht) and decisions on election result disputes (PHPU) that are final and binding. This condition produces a dualism of contradictory legal truths between the District Court and the Constitutional Court. Consequently, it leads to legal uncertainty and the potential delegitimization of Pilkada results. This study recommends the establishment of a specialized Pilkada court to comprehensively integrate all dispute resolution regimes.
Co-Authors Agustin, Elsa Rizqina Ahmad, Fika Fauziah Alfiatun Najah, Mia Amanda, Yunita Aminuyati Aqwal, Syifa Masyhuril Azahra, Davina Aurora Azarah, Intan Azzahra, Radiva Samsa Bintang, Tiara Kusuma Dani, Melihan Deanira Chantika Denisa, Najwa Putri Diana Sari Dorahman, Boy Ekasatya Aldila Afriansyah Elis Herlina Endry Boeriswati Fahtoni, Arbillah Fartdilah, Kurnia Firdausi Nuzula Fitriani , Imelda Harmadi, Ashur Henigusnia, Henigusnia Herawati, Ita IDA HODIYAH Iqbal, Faizul Khoiriyah, Meilin Manisa Komsiah, Fitri Ani Kuntum, X'cha Sekar Kurniawan, Eka Yulyawan Lianingsih, Dian Arsy Lubis, Rahma Dani Magdalena, Ina Makbullah, Shiva Mardiyanto, Muhammad Sodiq Maulana, Zusfarlian Maulidyaputri, Rizka Mellymayanti, Hani Mia Rasmiaty Nasution, Faizal Amir Nasution, Faizal Amir P Neneng Hasanah Nirmala, Dewi Noor Said, Fachri Nur Latifah, Nur Nur Maulida, Luthfia Nurfadhillah, Septi Nurfadhillah, Septy Nurhaeni Nursaleha, Ervina Purba, Elvrida Triana BR Puspita Sari, Ardita Putri Dwi Mariana Rahayu, Musfiroh Andi Rahmatika, Nurlia Rani Dewi Kurniawati Rosnaningsih, Asih Safrudin , Barry Saleh, Hairul Septianih, Nabilah Septiyani, Alina Shidqi, Muhammad Sholeha, Shelma Aulia Sihombing, L. Alfies Sinaga, Dahman Sugiharti Binastuti Suhaibah, Euis SULASTRI Sunaryo Sunaryo Sutihat, Ihat Suwadji, Yuniarti Tri Syfa, Delia Unaenah, Een Wahyuni, Siska Wardhani, Tunggadewi Ratu Warsito Warsito Wulandari, Christiana Yoranda, Dea Oktaviani Yuliastuti, Ari Yuwono, Rachmat Yuyut Prayuti Zulela Ms Zuraidah