cover
Contact Name
Auliya Ghazna Nizami
Contact Email
auliyanizami@uinsa.ac.id
Phone
+6281915490279
Journal Mail Official
jurnalkomparatif@uinsa.ac.id
Editorial Address
Jl. Ahmad Yani No.117, Jemur Wonosari, Kec. Wonocolo, Surabaya, Jawa Timur 60237
Location
Kota surabaya,
Jawa timur
INDONESIA
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam
ISSN : -     EISSN : 30261643     DOI : https://doi.org/10.15642/komparatif.v3i2
The Komparatif furnishes an international and regional scholarly forum for research on Comparative Mazahib, Law, and Islamic Thought. Taking an expansive view of the subject, the journal brings together all disciplinary perspectives. It publishes peer-reviewed articles on the historical, cultural, social, philosophical, political, anthropological, literary, artistic and other aspects of Comparative Mazahib, Law, and Islamic Thought in all times and places.
Arjuna Subject : Ilmu Sosial - Hukum
Articles 60 Documents
KIP-K Scholarship Eligibility for Economically Established Students: Perspectives of Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama Figures Qomariyah, Nurul; Putri, Eka Desiana; Aziz, Muhammad Irfan; Musafa'ah, Suqiyah
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i1.3171

Abstract

The Indonesia Smart College Card Scholarship (KIP-K) is an assistance program organized by the government with the aim of easing the burden of education costs for students from underprivileged families. However, in practice, many underprivileged students receive KIP-K scholarships. This study examines in depth the comparative analysis of the views of NU and Muhammadiyah figures regarding the provision of KIP scholarships to underprivileged students. This type of research is a normative-empirical law with a descriptive-comparative approach. Data was obtained through literature studies and in-depth interviews with figures from Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama. The data were analyzed comparatively. The results of the study show a difference in approach between Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) figures regarding the ethics of the utilization of scholarship, especially the KIP-K program. Muhammadiyah leaders tend to emphasize a normative, procedural approach grounded in maqāṣid al-syarī'ah, particularly the principles of ḥifẓ al-'aql (safeguarding reason) and ḥifẓ al-māl (safeguarding property). Meanwhile, NU figures highlight aspects of social ethics and pesantren values, such as honesty, trust, and social responsibility. The similarity between the two lies in the understanding that scholarship is a mandate that must be used honestly and on target, and that any deviation is a violation of Islamic law. Both Muhammadiyah and NU leaders view the act of receiving scholarships illegally as a form of deprivation of rights that are not justified by morality and Islamic law.
Pilgrimage to Sunan Ampel's Tomb from the Perspective of Kiai and Habib in Surabaya Ubaidillah, Romi; Izzati, Nailatur Rahmah; Anggraini, Yuni; Syafaq, Hammis
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

Sunan Ampel's tomb in Surabaya is one of the pilgrimage sites with important religious, historical, and social significance. Although tomb pilgrimage is generally accepted as a religious practice, its meaning can differ based on the pattern of religious understanding of the figure who guides the community. This study aims to analyze the meaning of the pilgrimage to Sunan Ampel's tomb based on the views of Kiai Badar Thomthomi and Habib Hasan bin Faruq Alkaff. This study uses an empirical legal method with a comparative approach. The main data was obtained through interviews with Kiai Badar Thomthomi and Habib Hasan bin Faruq Alkaff, while supporting data was obtained through literature and documentation studies. The results of the study show that both figures view pilgrimage as a means of getting closer to Allah, praying for the dead, remembering death, and strengthening faith. The difference lies in the pressure point of meaning. According to Kiai Badar Thomthomi, in pilgrimage, pilgrims must pray for the dead and not make a place to ask for the deceased. Meanwhile, Habib Hasan bin Faruq Alkaff put greater emphasis on the spiritual dimension, tawasul, wasilah, tabarruk, self-reflection, and the continuity of the archipelago's Islamic tradition. Nevertheless, both reject the belief that the wali has independent power beyond the will of Allah.
The Construction of Women's Law in Surah al-Nisā' According to al-Qurṭubī and Rashīd Riḍā Ajaj, Mohamed Ibrahim Abdul Aziz
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i1.3194

Abstract

This study discusses the construction of women's law in Surah al-Nisā' from the perspective of al-Qurṭubī and Rashīd Riḍā. This study aims to analyze the interpretation of the two mufasirs on women's legal verses and identify similarities and differences in the resulting legal construction. This study uses a qualitative method with the type of library research and the muqāran interpretation approach (comparative). The primary sources of research are al-Jāmi' li Aḥkām al-Qur'ān by al-Qurṭubī and Tafsīr al-Qur'ān al-Ḥakīm (Tafsīr al-Manār) by Rashīd Riḍā. The research data is focused on the verses of Surah al-Nisā' related to inheritance, dowry, polygamy, treatment of women, qiwāmah, and nusyūz. The results of the study show that the two mufasir have similarities in recognizing women as legal subjects who have the right to property, marriage, good treatment, and protection. The difference lies in the orientation of interpretation. Al-Qurṭubī emphasizes the juriscal-normative approach, while Rashīd Riḍā emphasizes a social-reformist approach that considers context, rationality, and benefit. These differences show that the construction of women's law is influenced by the interpretation methods and socio-intellectual context of each mufasir.
The Judicialization of Divorce in Islamic Family Law in Libya and Indonesia: A Maqāṣid Al-Sharī'ah Perspective Ali, Salih Awadh; Arif, Mohammad
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i1.3009

Abstract

Divorce is one of the important issues in Islamic family law regulated in state law, including in Libya and Indonesia. This study aims to analyze and compare the judicialization of divorce in Libyan and Indonesian family law. This study uses normative legal research methods with a comparative legal approach, a statutory approach, and a jurisprudence approach. The main source of research is the Libyan Law No. 10 of 1984 on marriage, divorce, and its legal consequences, as well as the Indonesian Marriage Law and the Compilation of Islamic Law. The results of the study show that both Libya and Indonesia place the courts as important institutions in the settlement of divorce, but establish different mechanisms. Libyan law provides ample room for judges to decide on divorce based on ḍarar (harm), absence of support, absence of a spouse, disability, īlā', ẓihār, and irreconcilable disputes. Indonesian law restricts divorce through court proceedings and requires the existence of legal grounds and peaceful efforts before the divorce is decided. The most fundamental difference lies in the position of divorces carried out out of court. Libyan law still regulates divorce based on talaq, but stipulates that its legal existence must be proven through the courts. Meanwhile, the Indonesian legal system institutionalizes divorce through the courts so that divorce obtains legal consequences after the judicial process.
The Islamic Ruling on Singing Arabic Songs at Religious Events: Perspectives of Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah Figures in Surabaya Rosyida, Salma; Fikan, Wafi Atqiya’; Hibatullah, Mohammad Rafii’; Husain, Muhammad Zakir
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): June
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i1.3170

Abstract

The development of religious art has given birth to the practice of using various Arabic songs, although the text sung is not always shalawat. This study examines the law on the use of Arabic songs at religious events from the perspectives of figures from Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah in Surabaya. This study uses empirical legal research methods with qualitative and comparative approaches. Primary data is obtained through interviews and observations, while secondary data is obtained through literature studies of books, journal articles, and relevant scientific works. The analysis is carried out descriptively and comparatively, examining the basis of legal considerations, the position of melody, the content of the lyrics, the purpose of use, and the ethical limitations of both perspectives. The results of the study showed that both informants allowed the use of Arabic songs, provided the lyrics did not contradict sharia, did not contain immoral elements, and were used for good purposes. The difference lies in the orientation of argumentation. Nahdlatul Ulama figures emphasized more on the cultural context, 'urf, maslahah, adab, and the function of cultural da'wah. Meanwhile, Muhammadiyah figures emphasized the substance of worship, the absence of sharia provisions regarding certain melodies, and caution so that artistic expressions are not sashrined as worship. These findings show that differences in the thinking styles of NU and Muhammadiyah figures do not always lead to legal differences, but can give rise to common points through different argumentation frameworks.
Judicial Independence in Sentencing: A Comparative Study Between the Indonesian Penal Code and Islamic Criminal Law Candra, Marli; Musyafaah, Nur Lailatul; Khalil, Shahidra Abdul
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i2.3179

Abstract

Judicial independence in sentencing constitutes a fundamental principle of the criminal justice system, aimed at ensuring the attainment of substantive justice and legal certainty. The enactment of the National Penal Code (KUHP Nasional) affords judges broader discretionary authority in determining the type and degree of punishment. Islamic criminal law, for its part, has long recognized the concept of judicial independence through the principles of istiqlāl al-qādī and ijtihād al qādī, particularly in taʿzīr cases. This study aims to analyze judicial independence in sentencing from the perspectives of the National Penal Code and Islamic criminal law. The study employs normative legal research. The legal materials consist of primary sources, including the National Penal Code and foundational sources of Islamic criminal law, as well as secondary sources, such as relevant legal literature and scholarly journals. The findings reveal that both the National Penal Code and Islamic criminal law recognize judicial independence as a pivotal principle in sentencing. The commonality lies in the acknowledgment of judicial discretion in the individualization of punishment. Nevertheless, fundamental differences exist regarding the sources of legitimacy, the scope of discretion, and the orientation of sentencing objectives.
Halal Self-Declare Certification Assistance at UIN Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang and Universitas Nahdlatul Ulama Sidoarjo from a Maqasid al-Shari'ah Perspective Ilmiyah, Zainatul; Junaidy, Abdul Basith; Hidayat, Muhammad Rifqi
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i2.3193

Abstract

The growth of the halal industry in Indonesia has encouraged an increase in the need for halal certification, especially for micro and small enterprises (MSEs) through the self-declare scheme. Universities play a strategic role in accelerating the halal certification process. This study aims to analyze the role of UIN Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang and Universitas Nahdlatul Ulama Sidoarjo (UNUSIDA) in implementing halal self-declaration certification and to assess its implementation from the perspective of maqāṣid al-sharī'ah. This study uses a qualitative approach, combining empirical legal research with normative-conceptual and comparative approaches. Primary data were obtained through interviews with Halal Center managers, while secondary data were obtained from documentation studies and related literature. The results of the study showed that the two universities played an active role in supporting halal certification by developing human resources, strengthening halal literacy, and building institutional networks. Comparatively, UIN Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang excels in institutional aspects and the number of certification achievements, while UNUSIDA excels in a community-based approach and cross-institutional collaboration. From the perspective of maqāṣid al-syarī'ah, the implementation of halal certification reflects efforts to protect religion, soul, intellect, property, and descendants.
The Position of the Wife in Household Debts Responsibility: An Analysis of Fiqh and the Civil Code Al-Azhari, Fajrul Falah; Amin, Faizal; Thaha, Muayyad
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i2.3293

Abstract

This study examines the position of wives in the responsibility of household debts through a comparison of the perspective of fiqh and the Civil Code. The research problem arises from differences between the two legal frameworks in determining responsibility for debts incurred to meet household needs. Previous research has examined the management of household debt, premarital debt, marital property, and financial responsibilities in marriage. Still, it has not specifically compared the position of wives in household debt responsibilities between fiqh and the Civil Code. This study employs normative legal methods, including legislative, conceptual, and comparative approaches. Primary legal materials include fiqh sources on debts (dayn), alimony (nafaqah), and the financial obligations of the husband and wife, as well as the Civil Code and relevant provisions of marriage law. The analysis was carried out qualitatively by comparing the legal basis and the imposition of debt liability in both frameworks. The results of the study show that fiqh recognizes the wife's personal responsibility for the debts she incurs. Still, under certain conditions, the context of household needs and the husband's maintenance obligations can affect the imposition of responsibility. In contrast, the Civil Code primarily determines responsibilities based on contractual relationships and on the parties who bind themselves to the agreement. These differences have implications for the wife's legal position and, under certain conditions, can cause a distributive imbalance. This research contributes to a more focused understanding of the construction of household debt responsibilities and the position of wives in fiqh and the Civil Code.
The Childfree Phenomenon in Marriage: A Comparative Study of Masdar Farid Mas’udi’s Perspective and Classical Fiqh Ahmad, Daryl Aufaa Dhorif; Wafi, Abdul
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i2.3349

Abstract

The phenomenon of childlessness in marriage has emerged as a significant contemporary issue in Islamic family law, particularly with regard to the purpose of marriage, reproductive rights, and the relationship between husband and wife. This study examines the phenomenon of childlessness through a comparative analysis of Masdar Farid Mas’udi’s progressive Islamic legal thought and classical fiqh. This study uses normative legal research with a conceptual and comparative approach, complemented by Islamic legal hermeneutics. The primary legal material consists of Mas’udi’s writings, while the secondary material includes books, scientific articles, and studies on Islamic family law and reproductive rights. The data are analyzed through descriptive-analytical and comparative methods. The study finds that Mas’udi’s thinking provides a contextual framework for understanding the marital relationship grounded in equality, shared responsibility, and deliberation. Compared to classical fiqh, which generally emphasizes procreation as one of the primary goals of marriage, Mas’udi’s approach provides greater room to consider individual circumstances and maṣlaḥah. Thus, a childless decision can be considered legally and ethically acceptable if it is based on mutual agreement, does not harm either spouse, and is consistent with the broader goals of Islamic law. This study contributes to contemporary Islamic family law discourse by showing how progressive Islamic legal thought can be involved in changing the practice of marriage without abandoning the basic principles of maqasid al-sharia.
Criminalization, Prevention, and Punishment in the Fight Against Administrative and Financial Corruption: A Comparative Study between Libyan Law and Islamic Jurisprudence Ezbeyda, Hamed Abdelsalam Mansour
Komparatif: Jurnal Perbandingan Hukum dan Pemikiran Islam Vol. 6 No. 2 (2026): December
Publisher : Department of Comparative Mazhab Comparative, Fakulty of Shariah and Law

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.15642/komparatif.v6i2.3415

Abstract

This study examines the prevention and control of administrative and financial corruption through a comparative analysis of Libyan law and Islamic jurisprudence in light of the objectives of Islamic law (maqāṣid al-sharī‘ah). This study aims to analyze the forms of corruption criminalized under Libyan law, examine the legal and institutional mechanisms established to prevent it, and assess the applicable sanctions, and then compare them with the relevant principles and rulings of Islamic jurisprudence. The study employs normative legal, analytical, and comparative approaches. The study finds that Libyan legislation has established a legal and institutional framework that addresses various forms of corruption, including bribery, embezzlement, unlawful appropriation of public funds, abuse of office, and illicit enrichment, as well as mechanisms for oversight, corruption detection, and asset recovery. Islamic jurisprudence likewise provides a comprehensive framework for addressing corruption by prohibiting bribery, betrayal of trust, unlawful appropriation of wealth, and abuse of authority, while allowing discretionary (ta‘zīr) sanctions based on the nature of the offense, the harm caused, and the public interest. The comparison demonstrates that both systems share fundamental objectives, particularly the protection of wealth, the realization of justice, the prevention of harm, and the protection of the public interest, although they differ in their sources, mechanisms of criminalization and punishment, and institutional procedures.