Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Lentera Hukum

Pseudo-judicial Review for the Dispute over the Result of the Regional Head Election in Indonesia Indra, Mexsasai; Saragih, Geofani Milthree; Handoko, Tito
Lentera Hukum Vol 10 No 1 (2023): Human Rights in Indonesia and Beyond
Publisher : University of Jember

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.19184/ejlh.v10i1.36685

Abstract

In Indonesia, the Constitutional Court has the power to decide the dispute over the result of the national election, including that of the regional head election. In practice, the Constitutional Court exercises power with the so-called pseudo-judicial review for the result of the regional election dispute. This study aims to analyse the rationale of the Constitutional Court to implement a pseudo-judicial review over the regional head election result, given the judicial activism that also is limited to checks and balances. It also links the theoretical basis for rule-breaking and judicial activism by the Constitutional Court, the transition of the Constitutional Court's power in deciding regional election disputes from temporary to permanent, as well as further analysis of why the Constitutional Court needs to file a lawsuit for review. This study used legal research that examined legal principles and regulations with a theoretical approach analysed qualitatively. The results of this study indicate that pseudo-judicial review affirms the legal breakthrough beyond ordinary decisions as this was made on the ground of the public interest. While the Constitutional Court is essential in maintaining and overseeing democracy in Indonesia, the rationale of the Constitutional Court under the public interest is justified as it is constitutionally correct that has led to judicial activism. A pseudo-judicial review is for substantial justice and can influence time efficiency.Keywords: Constitutional Court, Judicial Review, Local Election Disputes.
Co-Authors ", Antika Abdul Majid Siregar Abdul Mirad Abdul Munir Mulkan Abdul Sadad Abdurrahman, Rezi Achmad Fajri Febrian ADLIN, ADLIN Adnan, Fachri Agus Sutikno Aguswan Aisyah Nurterra Alyf Valencia Erel Amelia, Dinda Anania Rahmah Angga Pramana Angga Pramana Anisa Permata Rahma Apriani, Lilis Ardi Putra ARDIANSYAH ARDIANSYAH Arum Rovarti Ningsih Aulia Junita Auradian Marta Azani Safira Azhar, Muhammad Belli Nasution Besri Nasrul Chandra Gunawan Dadang Mashur Dahlan Tampubolon Dwi Visti Rurianti Eko Priyo Purnomo Eko Wahyudi Elin Safitri Era Refani Erdianto Erdianto Effendi erman muchtar Fabiyanto, Erlan Fadhiilatun Nisa Fadhiilatun Nisaa Firman Andika FRINI KARINA ANDINI Halimah Tussakdiah Harapan Tua R. F. S Harsanto Mursyid Hasanuddin Hasanuddin Hasanuddin Hidayati, Mega Hijri Aprianto Irawati Irwin Mirza Umami Ishak Ishak Ismandianto Jeany Ristia Jendrius Jendrius Johan Frengky King Sing Lubis, Nursiani M. Rafi M.Y.Tiyas Tinov, M.Y.Tiyas Mahmud Hibatul Wafi Manalu, Nengsih Mayarni Mayarni Mexsasai Indra Meyzi Heriyanto Mimin Sundari Nasution Mohammad Yohamzy Tiyas Tinov Monalisa Muchid Muchid Muhammad Ilham Taufiqurrahman Munadi Munadi Novita, Irma Nur Hasnah Nurul Fatma Ogi Rifansyah, Ogi Putri Azzahara Rachman, Gieat Fathur Rafi, M Rahmad Zaki Rahmadini Payla Juarsa Rahmanto, Fajar Rahmat, Al Fauzi Rahmi Khairiyah ME Ramlan Darmansyah Ringgo Eldapi Yozani Risky Arya Putri Rizqy Ridho Prakasa S Syofian Saipudin Ikhwan Saragih, Geofani Milthree Sarmina Purba Sinaga, Putra Rikki Hilarius Suharni " Sujianto Sujianto Sundari, Dicky Syafri Harto Sylvina Rusadi Syofian Syofian Syofian, . Tika Mutia Tinov, M.Y Tiyas Tinov, MY Tiyas Tiyas Tinov Triana Wulandari, Triana Utama, Rezaldi Prastya Vinsensius, Chairul Vivin Jenika Putri Wati, Nurhafiza Welly Wirman Wicaksono, Luluk Reza Widia Astuti Yelly Zamaya Yelmira Zalfiatri Yunandra Zahwa Juwita Zebua, Ben Hansel Notatema Zubaidah, Evi Zulfa Harirah MS