Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : ULJLS

Differences in Restorative Justice in Indonesia, New Zealand and Saudi Arabia Viewed from Comparative Criminal Law Manurung, Fajar Rudi; Gunanto, Marcus Priyo; Mohammad Ekaputra; Marlina; Wessy Trisna
Ultimate Journal of Legal Studies Vol. 2 No. 1 (2024): Develompment of Legal Science
Publisher : Talenta Publisher

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.32734/uljls.v2i1.16665

Abstract

Resolving criminal cases through the judiciary is considered successful if law enforcers are able to bring the perpetrators to justice and receive punishment. In certain cases, the public hopes that there will be no need for prosecution because the crime committed is not commensurate with the sentence imposed. Provisions about Restorative Justice in Indonesia, the civil law legal system is not yet clearly regulated in the law. New Zealand is a country Common Law who successfully implemented it Restorative Justice at the Correctional Institution. Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia is an Islamic country that most consistently applies Islamic criminal law which has a concept Restorative Justice. The aim of the research is to compare the concept of restorative justice between Indonesia, New Zealand and Saudi Arabia. Through these three different legal systems, which legal system is restorative justice most appropriate to apply? in Indonesia Restorative Justice guided by the internal provisions of the Police, Prosecutor's Office and Courts, which have not yet been stated in New Zealand Law Restorative Justice under the Parole Law of 2002, Saudi Arabia Restorative Justice relies on transcendental rules, namely the Qur’an and Hadits as well as the judge's discretion. The fact that it is applied in different countries is not certain that it will be useful if applied in one's own country or another country. Restorative justice must be in accordance with the social, economic and political conditions of a country.
Co-Authors Abdul Rauf Adi Chandra Alvi Syahrin Alvi Syahrin Andrio Bukit Astri Khairisa Ayu Anisa Brunner, Emil Dahlia Kesuma Dewi Damanik, Vania Andari Dwina Elfika Putri Edi Yunara Edi Yunara Ediwarman Ediwarman, Ediwarman Edy Ikhsan Elwi Danil Ester Ronatiur Sitourus Fadli Imam Syahputra Harahap Fahmi Jalil Farhan Zulfahmi Frans B.S. Siagian Gunanto, Marcus Priyo Gurusinga, Irayata Br. Idris, Siti Hafsyah Indah Widyarantika Zebua Irianto Irianto Jamaluddin Mahasari Jelly Leviza Kumaedi Liza erwina Luthvia Meidina Madalaine, Madalaine Madiasa Ablisar Madiasa Ablisar Madiasa Ablisar Madiasa Ablisar Mahmud Mulyadi MAHMUL SIREGAR Mahmul Siregar Manurung, Andri Rico Manurung, Fajar Rudi Mark Sihombing, Esthon Marlina Marlina Marlina Marlina, Marlina Mohd Din Muhammad Adlan Nasution Muhammad Hamdan Muhammad Hamdan Munthe, Irfansyah Nasser, Gamal Abdul Nasution, Akmal Handi Ansari Nasution, Aulia Arif Nurhalija, Nadia Pandiangan, Rodo Venesia H. Pardede, Rendra Yoki Pohan, Husein Pusdiana, Made Sadika Ramboo Loly Sinurat Rina Melati Sitompul Rinaldi Rinaldi Ritonga, Fani Holidayani Rosmalinda, Rosmalinda Rumahorbo, Alberth Mangasi Saputri, Rizki Nanda Sebayang, Ekinia Karolin Siahaan, Alvin Adianto Silalahi, Saut Maruli Tua Simada, Arthur Siregar, Mangantar Anugrah Sri Delyanti Suhaidi Suhaidi Sukarja, Detania Sunarmi Sunarmi Sunarmi Sunarmi, Sunarmi Sutiarnoto Sutiarnoto Syafruddin Kalo Syahputra, Rezky Syawal Saputra Siregar Tanjung, Wiranti Tarigan, Vita Cita Emia Thahir, Irfan Farid Trisna, Wessy Tumanggor, Paian Utari Maharany Barus Wessy Trisna Yessi Grenia Batu Bara