Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Range : Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika

Moderating Effects of Educational Level and Mathematical Competence on the Effectiveness of Cognitive Conflict Strategy: A Meta-Analysis Onesimus Laia, Harun; Martadiputra, Bambang Avip Priatna; Candraningsih, Yosy; Marjud, Fujiama
RANGE: Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika Vol. 7 No. 1 (2025): Range Juli 2025
Publisher : Pendidikan Matematika UNIMOR

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.32938/jpm.v7i1.9531

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the effectiveness of the cognitive conflict strategy in mathematics learning and to examine whether educational level and mathematical competence act as moderators in this strategy. A meta-analysis approach was conducted on 41 effect sizes. Data were analyzed using a random-effects model, with effect sizes calculated using Hedges' g. The data analysis was performed using the Comprehensive Meta-Analysis (CMA) software to ensure the accuracy of effect size calculations, heterogeneity tests, and moderator analyses. The results show that the cognitive conflict strategy has a significant effect (g = 1.047; p < 0.05). Additionally, mathematical competence was found to be a significant moderator (p < 0.05), with the highest effect sizes observed in conceptual understanding (g = 1.712) and critical thinking (g = 1.355). However, the educational level did not serve as a significant moderator (p = 0.092), indicating that the cognitive conflict strategy is beneficial across various educational levels. This study concludes that the cognitive conflict strategy is effective in enhancing mathematics learning, especially in conceptual understanding and critical thinking. Its novelty lies in identifying mathematical competence, not educational level, as a significant moderator. This implies that implementation should be adjusted based on the targeted competence. Future research may explore other potential moderators, including learner traits, instructional design, and technology use, to refine its application.
Co-Authors Agustyani, Anggit Reviana Dewi Ahbi Mahdianing Rum AHMAD LUTFI Ahmad Lutfi Ahmad Mukhibin, Ahmad Al Jupri Alberta Parinters Makur Arwan Zhagi Asih, Endang Cahya Mulyaning Astri Wahyuni Bambang Cahyono Candraningsih, Yosy Dadang Juandi Darhim Darhim Dejarlo, Jenisus O. Dendy Maulana Gusmawan Dewi Rahmatin Diory Pribadi Sinaga Sinaga Dwi Agusantia Eka Rosdianwinata Elah Nurlaelah Esterlina Esterlina Eva Dwi Minarti Faizah, Siti Finola Marta Putri Fitriani Agustia Freddy Prasetyo Gusni Satriawati, Gusni Hidayat, Abas Husty Serviana Husain Ilham Muhammad Imelda Verina Irmasari - Isnawan, Muhamad Galang Jarnawi Afgani Dahlan Kusnandi Kusnandi Kusnandi Kusnandi, Kusnandi Kusumah, Yaya S Marchy, Febrinna Marjud, Fujiama Martina Mery Yohanna Limbong Meicindy Jeny Klorina Muhaimin, Lukman Hakim N. Nurjanah Naila Ratu Dianti Nanang Priatna Nar Herrhyanto Naser, Abdurrahman Do. Muhamad Nurjanah, Nurjanah Onesimus Laia, Harun Pahmi, Samsul Pauzan, Muh Primadiana, Anneke Putri, Maria Rosari Sulistyo Rachmi Dwiyati Rahmatudin, Jajang Ratni Purwasih, Ratni Ratu Sarah Fauziah Iskandar Rini Marwati Riyan Hidayat Rodríguez-Nieto, Camilo Andrés Rr Kuntie Sulistyowaty Rusyid, Husnul Khatimah Sartika, Nenden Suciyati Sri Asnawati, Sri Sudirman Sudirman Sudirman Sudirman Suhendra Suhendra Suparman Suparman Suparman Suparman Suparman Suparman Suparman Suparman, Suparman Sutihat Sutihat Tatang Herman, Tatang Tresna Nur’aviandini Tri Nopriana Tri Nopriana, Tri Turmudi Wahyudin Wahyudin Yaya S. Kesumah Yaya S. Kusumah Yaya S. Kusumah Yaya Sukjaya Kusumah Yumiati Zafrullah, Zafrullah