Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 2 Documents
Search
Journal : Constitutional Review

Judicial Preview on the Bill on International Treaty Ratification Sidharta, Noor; Sudarsono, Sudarsono; Nurjaya, I Nyoman; Sugiri, Bambang
Constitutional Review Vol 3, No 1 (2017)
Publisher : The Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | Full PDF (317.075 KB) | DOI: 10.31078/consrev312

Abstract

This research is aimed to find and introduce a new idea on the state administration, which has implications on the international treaty ratification procedure followed by Indonesia and additional authorizations of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia. The judicial preview in this research is an international treaty examination procedure by the Constitutional Court before an international treaty is transformed into a law, i.e. such international treaty is a Bill. The judicial preview shall have different terms in each country, such as Review ex ante, abstract review, judicial review. This procedure is applied when an international treaty has not been validated as a country’s national law. The benefits of a judicial preview shall be a solution to connect an ambiguity between the state administrative law and international law. The judicial preview is also the inter-state institutions real check and balance on the international treaty. Out of benchmarking results of four countries following the monism doctrine, i.e. Russia, Germany, France, and Italty and two countries following the dualism doctrine, i.e. Hungary and Ecuador, several additional authorizations of the Constitutional Court shall be summarized, i.e. via the Amendment of 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia and/or regulations via laws. If both manners are not possible, the Constitutional Court may apply the judicial preview as a state administrative practice. An international treaty draft, which has passed through the judicial preview, may not be submitted to the Constitutional Court to be performed a judicial review, unless 5 (five) year-period has passed since the bill is enacted as a law.
Relation between the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia and the Legislators according to the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia Laksono, Fajar; Sudarsono, Sudarsono; Hidayat, Arief; Safaat, Muchammad Ali
Constitutional Review Vol 3, No 2 (2017)
Publisher : The Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | Full PDF (310.5 KB) | DOI: 10.31078/consrev321

Abstract

This research aims to analyze and to describe the relation between the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia (CC) with the People Representatives’ Council and the President of the Republic of Indonesia as legislators by looking on implementation of CC’s decision through the legislation in the period 2004-2015. Using doctrinal research, it can be seen how the constitutional mandate in the CC’s decision are implemented by the legislator through the legislation. The results are: (a) legal opinions of the CC’s decision have a binding power; (b) a constitutional mandate in the legal opinion is intended as guidance for the legislators regarding what the 1945 Constitution requires; (c) directives to the legislator in the legal opinions should be implemented because it is the implementation of the principle of checks and balances according to the 1945 Constitution, (d) implementation of the CC’s decisions through legislation does not have standard mechanism and does not become the priority of legislation, and (e) relation between the CC with the legislators can not be categorized in black and white in cooperative or confrontative, but shows ups and downs between cooperative and confrontative relations. Cooperative relations are realized when the constitutional mandate is formulated strongly so it is implemented by the legislator as the formula. Relationships tend to be cooperative in the implementation of the constitutional mandate of the decision, but not a priority of legislation. Meanwhile, the confrontative relations is seen from the constitutional mandate of the CC decisions which are not implemented.
Co-Authors . MASWAR A.A. Gd. Tryadi Pradipta A.A. Ketut Agung Cahyawan W AA GN Anom Jambe AA. Devi Pradnyanita AAGN Anom Jambe AAGN Anom Jambe Achmad Fudholi AF. Ismiyanto, AF. Agung Endro Nugroho Agus Selamet Duniaji Agustinus Marjun Agustinus Yuswanto, Agustinus AI DARIAH Aksar, Prinob Al Ichlas Imran Al Ichlas Imran Albert Rufinus Ali Djamhuri Aminur Aminur Anak Agung Istri Sri Wiadnyani Andayani, Erda Dwi Anisa Intan Hartanti Anjar Hermadi Saputro Ariani Nisfin Kholifah Ariani Nisfin Kholifah Aulia Rahayu Ramadhani Satyaningtyas Sudrajat Bambang Admadi Harsojuwono Bambang Sugiri Budi Mulyaningsih Budiman Sudia Budiman Sudia, Budiman Christin Yunanto Chusni Ansori Clarry Sada Davita Putri, Ni Putu Amanda dewi novita Dewi, Ni Made Raditya Shinta Dina Puti Kartika Dwi Riyanti Dyah Mellawati, Dyah Eka Jana Walianingsih Emir Ramadhan, Emir Endang Susilawati Eni Rosnija Eny Rosnija, Eny Erick, Chrysostomus Erna P. Setyowati Eusabinus Bunau F. AGUS Fajar Laksono Febrian Rahma Putra Firnanda, Sari Gatot Sutapa Gusti Ayu Kadek Diah Puspawati Harmonis, Dinda Ria Hasibuan, Hoiruddin Husni Mubarok I D.P. Kartika Pratiwi I Dewa Made Sukrama I Gusti Ayu Ekawati I Gusti Ayu Kadek Puspawati I Gusti Ayu Lani Triani I GUSTI MADE SUBIKSA I Ketut Suter I Made Sugitha I Nengah Kencana I Nengah Kencana Putra I Nyoman Nurjaya I Putu Eka Putra Sentana I Putu Suparthana I Putu Willigis Benito Khatulistiwa I W.R. Widarta I Wayan Rai Widarta I Wayan Ryantama Swastika Braja I. Setiawan, I. I.W. Rai Widarta Ida Ayu Maria Christina Ida Ayu Putu Sri Widnyani Ida Ayu Surya Agustini Ida Bagus Wayan Gunam Indrati, Retno Iwa Sutardja, Iwa Iwan Setiawan Iwan Supardi J Sri Adiningsih Jeany Tio Larosta Jeremy Louis Adisurya Juliawati, Euis Kadek Danthiswara Gelgel KETUT BUDI SUSRUSA KOMANG AYU NOCIANITRI Kurniawati, Suma L.K Darusman L.T Indriyati Lewi Rensia Roulina Hutasoit Lini Fitri Lini Veriony, Lini Lucia Denok Wihartati Lucky Arisonna Roring Luh Putu Trisna Darmayanti Luh Putu Trisna Darmayanti, Luh Putu Luh Putu Wrasiati Lutfi Suhendra Luwandi Suhartono Luwandi, Luwandi M. Yogi Riyantama Isjoni Made Dwi Widyantari Mandayu, Yohana Yosiphanungkas Bahari Marlentera, Riris Marpaung, Uliana Sara Mauludiana, Poppy Iga Melania Veronika Samosir Melia Verdiana Meysi Andriani Mochammad Imron Awalludin Muchamad Ali Safaat Muhammad Fajar Sidiq Widodo Nanang Endriatno Nanang Endriatno Naniek Widyaningrum Natalie Indirasvari K. S. Nathania Pusparani Nur Ni Kadek Yuli Kesuma Ni Ketut Sri Agustini Ni Komang Ayu Nila Ratna Ni Komang Ayu Nila Ratna Ni Komang Sri Budihartini Ni Komang Trisna Rahayu Ni Luh Ari Yusasrini Ni Made Indri Hapsari Arihantana Ni Made Wartini Ni Made Yusa Ni Nyoman Desi Trisnadewi Ni Nyoman Puspawati Ni Putu Candra Utami Ni Putu Diah Cahyani Subamia Ni Putu Yuni Wulan Sari Ni Wayan Ayuk Yuliantari Ni Wayan Wisaniyasa Nico Kemit Noval Wahyu Adi Novia Hasanah Novriyanti Hutasoit Nur Wienda Permata Wulandari Nursiati, Nursiati Nyoman Citra Suryani NYOMAN SEMADI ANTARA Oktavianti, Siti Pande Ketut Diah Kencana Pande Made Agus S. Diputra Pangga, Wilfred Prayoga, Dewa Gede Eka Pudji Hastuti Pudji Hastuti Purba, Melini Pazyanita Purboyo, Bayu Aji Putu Eka Yudhayanti Putu Timur Ina R. SITUMORANG Rahmawati, Sumi Rahmi Safarina Fauziah, Rahmi Safarina Raisa, Metha Retno Indriati Ria Lidyawita, Ria Riani, Bela Rijal, Khairur Rubbana Sunardi Rut Elisabet Sianturi S. Arsyad S. Indarto, S. Saefudin Saefudin Samhuddin Samhuddin Sandhika Wahyu Adhinugraha Sasy Eka Putri Wahyuningtyas Sayi Hatiningsih Sembiring, Rinawati Sidharta, Noor Siti Sunarintyas Sri Wahyuni Stevani, Ana Sudibyo Martono Sugiri, Bambang SUPANDI SUBIHAM Suparmo Suparmo SUPIYANDI SABIHAM Suwasono, Sony Tito Azhari Saputro Viranci, Nofila Cici W.H SISWORO Wardah Wardah Winarno, Bambang Wulandari Setiadarma Yessica Kristanti Yohanes Setiyo Yossinta C.C. Kusuma YS Bintari, YS Yuliana, Yohanes Gatot Sutapa Yustina Andini Zenny Elfryani Purba