Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : SIGn Jurnal Hukum

Evidentiary Strength of Land Ownership Certificates: An Analysis of Judicial Considerations in Supreme Court Decision Number 3762 K/Pdt/2022 Ardiansyah, Aldi; Akbar, Muhammad Gary Gagarin; Abas, Muhamad
SIGn Jurnal Hukum Vol 7 No 1: April - September 2025
Publisher : CV. Social Politic Genius (SIGn)

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.37276/sjh.v7i1.463

Abstract

The Land Ownership Certificate, as a manifestation of formal legal certainty, often clashes with substantive justice, particularly when its acquisition process is based on an unlawful act. This fundamental problem is central to Supreme Court Decision Number 3762 K/Pdt/2022. The decision contrasts a claim based on hereditary rights and physical possession with ownership based on a certificate originating from a juridically flawed transaction. This research aims to critically evaluate the appropriateness of the Supreme Court’s considerations in that decision. Using a normative juridical method enriched by critical discourse analysis and John Rawls’s theory of justice, this study deconstructs the paradigmatic dialectic between the judex factie and the judex juris. The analysis reveals that the decisions of the judex factie (District Court and High Court) tended to adopt a progressive approach by prioritizing material truth. In contrast, the Supreme Court applied a rigid legal positivism paradigm, protecting the certificate’s formal validity without conducting a substantial validity test of its acquisition process. It is concluded that while doctrinally justifiable, the Supreme Court’s decision is fundamentally unjust. It sacrifices the rights of the heir as the most vulnerable or least advantaged party and implicitly legitimizes the outcome of an illegality. This decision sets a dangerous precedent that reduces legal certainty to mere procedural formality and negates the law’s objective of achieving substantive justice in agrarian disputes.
Co-Authors Aditia, Fani Agus Antoni, Mochamad Akbar, Gary Gagarin Akbar, Muhamad Gary Gagarin Akbar, Muhammad Gary Gagarin Akup, Apriliyanto Juwan Sukmana Amalia, Sitti Fadilah Amaliya, Lia Andri Susanto Andriani, Nina Anggraeni, Kiki Arafat, Zarisnov Ardiansyah, Aldi Ardiansyah, Ata Arisa Wongchai Asnanda, Anggraeni Asyahadi, Farhan Asyhadi, Farhan Ayomi, Andreas C. Bintang S, Andi Muhamad Bintang, Muhamad Budi Prayogo, Sutras Chicka Aircheny Dede Nurhayatie Devi Arviani Arinta Dewi Putri Wibowo, Sabrina Dini Nurfalah Farhan Asyhadi Fatonah Fatonah Fauzan, Ade Ahmad Fauzi, Muhamad Jiia Febrian, M. Ibnu Gagarin Akbar, M. Gary Gary Gagarin Akbar, Muhamad Gary Gagarin Akbar, Muhammad Gugun Gunawan, Gugun Guntara, Deny Haetami, Vikri Hambali, Muslim Hariawan, Hariawan Hasanah, Hilyatun Hasrinda, Hasrinda Hendri Gunawan Hidayat, Anwar Hilman Alfiansah Himim, Aldora Ananda Putra I Ketut Suardika Ichsan Maulana Indah Nurhayati Irawan, Angki Irawan, Surya Irwanto, Danang Iswandi, Erik Ivan Hanafi Ixal, Da'i Safuad Kaimuddin, Sitti Mikarna Koswara, Wahyu Kurnia, Didiek Lestari, Widya Annisa Pudji LIA AMALIA Lubis, Adyan Machestian, Hario Bismo Maharani, Dennisya Maharani, Syahwa Mahmudi, Afrizal Makhron, Fiki Muzaki Malau, Masnida Marhan, Citra Marpaung, Dorkas Mehue, Bruce Meidah, Nuryanah Tirostiah Mohamad ArdinSuwandi Muhammad Latif Mustika, Mela Mutiara Dewi, Chalidya Ningrum, Wulan Cahya Nopianti, Wike Nor Khasanah, Jana Siti Nugraha Putra, Muhamad Nugroho, Gynastiar Nur Elita, Raden Lita Nurbaliza, Violita Nurdin Nurdin Nurhidayah, Desyifa Pebriyani, Pebriyani Pratama, Raka Indra Prilly Larasati, Dwiana Purwana, Dalih Putra, Reza Alamsyah Putri, Ina Malia R, La Ode Rafiuddin Rahmalia, Indah Rahmatiar , Yuniar Rahmatiar, Niar Rahmatiar, Yuniar Ramadani, Trisna Rana Dewi Siauta, Putri Rizal Aripin Robillah, Robillah Rosdiana Dewi, Elvira Rudin, Suci Ramadhani Sadjat, Rizki Safitri, Diana Alpiani Sahab, Nurlin Sampurna Banyuaji, Sampurna Sanjaya , Suyono Sanjaya, Suyono Santoso, Imam Budi Saprudin Saripudin, Asep Sartika Dewi Septian, Fazrian Setiawan, Ade Yunas Shidqi Mubarok, Muhammad Sibri, Lili Sidabutar, Octaviana Sihotang, Alex Antonius Sitorus, Leonardo Sopian, Singgih Sopyan Sopyan Sri Wahyuni Sudjadi, Agung Sukarta, Dimas Tatang Wiro Sukmawati Sukmawati Suroso, Zulfiansyah Yusuf Suryadi, Ismutiah Susanti, Depi Sutrisno, Sutrisno Syahida, Nadia Taofik Rohman, Paisal Targana, Tatang Toha, Imam Sofii Tri Setiady, Tri Triana Dewi, Liza Viyanda, Karina Wakono, Nur Widasari, Widasari Wilianita, Ani Yulianita, Donna Yulianti, Yuli Yuniar Rahmatiar Yunior Sanu, Primawan Zaenury, Ahmad Goza Zahra Alfianti, Kartika Zahra Maharani Hilman, Hanna