Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Satirical Cultural Criticism In Digital Podcasts Constitutes Legally Protected Expression: Kritik Budaya Satir Dalam Podcast Digital Merupakan Ekspresi Yang Dilindungi Hukum Wardani Aziz; Mochammad Tanzil Multazam
Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review Vol. 21 No. 3 (2026): Agustus
Publisher : Universitas Muhammadiyah Sidoarjo

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.21070/ijler.v21i3.1710

Abstract

General Background Media technology expansion has broadened opportunities for public discourse, frequently creating legal tension between constitutional rights and statutory restrictions regarding hate speech. Specific Background The Musuh Masyarakat audio broadcast titled "Indonesian Culture and Traditions Do Not Need to Be Preserved" sparked public controversy by employing irony and sarcasm to question state-enforced tradition preservation. Knowledge Gap Existing legal scholarship predominantly focuses on conventional social networks, leaving a scarcity of normative evaluations that test audio-on-demand comedy against updated national legislative frameworks. Aims This normative juridical study examines whether the controversial broadcast qualifies as lawful opinion or criminal hate speech under Indonesian positive law. Results Evaluating the transcript through Jürgen Habermas's deliberative democracy theory and statutory parameters reveals that the speakers target government socialization strategies and social phenomena rather than attacking specific group identities. Furthermore, the cumulative material elements of Article 28 paragraph (2) of Law Number 1 of 2024 and Article 243 paragraph (1) of Law Number 1 of 2023 are not fulfilled because the broadcast lacks intent to incite hostility, discrimination, or violence based on ethnicity, religion, race, or intergroup relations. Novelty This research establishes a structured five-variable normative matrix combining constitutional guarantees, electronic information regulations, criminal statutes, and communicative action theory to evaluate audio comedy. Implications The findings provide essential legal parameters for law enforcement and content creators to distinguish between legitimate public policy evaluation and unlawful hostility within democratic discourse. Highlights: Audio broadcasts evaluating government socialization policies and tradition preservation represent valid democratic discourse. Cumulative material elements of hate speech under Law Number 1 of 2024 and Law Number 1 of 2023 remain unfulfilled. Deliberative democracy parameters distinguish rational public policy debates from unlawful identity-based hostility. Keywords: Freedom Of Expression, Hate Speech, Normative Juridical, Deliberative Democracy, Audio Broadcast
Co-Authors Aan Eko Widiarto Agus Dwi Arifudin Ahmad Dzulfiqar Hibatullah Putra Aitama, Fadia Rozika Akhmad Anwar Dani Akhmad Anwar Dani Aldy Rialdy Atmadja Aldy Rialdy Atmadja Amelia Citra Sasasnti Andista Candra Yusro Anissa, Salsabila Apriliya Nursyabani Bachtyar Arif Zainudin Arini Desita Sari Asep Erlan Maulana Asep Erlan Maulana Ashila Xaviena Almira Molla Atikha Sidhi Cahyana Aulia Sarah Azizah Aviva, Srivit Bagaskara, Tegar Christianto Bagus Trispratama, Enrico Batari Mulya Bobur Sobirov Busro, B. Chairunnisa, Fahira Safa Cherin Ayudia Sari Citra Sonia Condro, Rudy Cut Novianti Rachmi, Cut Novianti Dasapta Erwin Irawan, Dasapta Erwin Dedhi Bima Samudra Dedi Rahman Nur Defny Holidin Deny Juanda Puradimaja Deva Putra Tegas Sakti Dilla Haniah Kurniawati Efendi , Nurul Eka Safitri, Annisa Eko Pramudya Laksana Eko Pramudya Laksana Emy Rosna Wati Emy Rosnawati Fahmi Shahab Fahrezi, Natario Okta Fatah , Abdul Febriandi Berutu Galih Kusumah, Galih Hana Yunita Makhfudotin Haniah Kurniawati, Dilla Hardian Sembellagusto Hasan, Rizqi Hasani Moh. Ali Hendy Irawan, Hendy Huzairin, Regita Amanah Ikhwan Arief Indakto, Ratro Irwansyah Irwansyah Isroiyah, Nurul Jaya, Nur Intan Purwani Jaylu Kosasih Jessi Fatika Berliana Juneman Abraham Keukeu Kaniawati Rosada Khotimah, Siti Dewi Kurnia Ningsih Kolopita Kustiati Kustiati Lestari, Melati Indah Lucky Zamzami M. Hendriansyah Raihan Maryati, Lely Ika Masruroh, Tri Antika Mitra Djamal Moh. Faizin Mohammad Fauziddin Monica Firda Nurjannah Much. Fuad Saifuddin Muh. Firyal Akbar Muh. Firyal Akbar Muhamad Ratodi Muhamad Ratodi Muhammad Ary Taufik Muhammad Asrul Maulana Mukti, Rino Rakhmata Mulyaningsih, Indrya Nafila, Nida Najmy Amien, Muhammad Ningrum, Hesti Noor Fatimah Mediawati Nur Riska Salsabila Nurhazman Abdul Aziz, Nurhazman Abdul Octaviani, Tresnia Oktavia, Herlina Pahlevy, Rifqi Ridhlo Pandu Sarigati Sari Phahlevi, Rifqi Ridlo Prasetiantara, Rafi Pratama, Sandika Putra Pristiwanto, Pristiwanto Purnama, Melati Indah Purnomo, Melati Indah Putra , Guntur Permana Putra, Wildan Revandra Putri Aldora Muaini Rahayu Hartini Regita Amanah Huzairin Rico Ardi Wijaya Rifqi Ridlo Phahlevi Rifqi Ridlo Phahlevy, Rifqi Ridlo Risa Rifa’ul Azizah Rizky Hamdani Robi'atul Adawiyah Romadhon, Fajar Riski Rositasari, Dewi Rudy Condro Safrian Hamzah Sarah Septyaningsih Septalia, Alyani Noor Septian, Septian Septriono Hari Nugroho Sholikhah, Firda Mar’atus Siswapranata, Fadiana Zahra Sobirov, Bobur Sonia, Citra Sparisoma Viridi Sri Budi Purwaningsih Sriyono Sriyono Tertia Mukti, Artanti Utama Alan Deta Visa, Hikmah Tara Widya Wanda Elvinatus Sofie Wardani Aziz Wicaksono, Ageng Widya Visa, Hikmah Tara Wulandari , Shofia Eka Putri Yinta Syifaudiana Yulianti Yunita Makhfudotin, Hana