Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Journal of Hadith Studies

Apostasy: between the Death Penalty and the Freedom (Criticizing the Thought of Jamal al-Banna) Riyadi, Ahmad
Journal of Hadith Studies Vol. 1 No. 1 (2018): Journal of Hadith Studies
Publisher : ASILHA (Asosiasi Ilmu Hadis Indonesia)

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.32506/johs.v1i1.15

Abstract

The death penalty for apostasy remains a contentious issue. Contemporary scholars view it as a violation of individual rights, particularly the freedom to choose or change one’s religion. They argue that the punishment stems from historical interpretations of Islamic law, often influenced by political considerations, rather than authentic religious sources. One such critic, Egyptian scholar Jamal Al-Banna, rejects the death penalty for apostates, contending that it has no basis in the Qur'an, hadith, or the practices of the Companions of the Prophet. This paper critically analyzes Al-Banna’s arguments against the death penalty and evaluates the hadiths he uses to support his position. The analysis concludes that the Qur'an and authentic (sahih) hadiths are not in contradiction. Rather, the misinterpretations of the hadiths in Al-Banna’s reasoning reflect a failure to reconcile them with the broader Islamic message. Thus, his critique does not hold up against a proper understanding of the texts.
Co-Authors . Suparjo, . A. Ogotan, Arianti Abdillah, Annas Nur Achmad Noerkhaerin Putra Agil, Muhamad Akmalia, Riski Akrom, Maulana Ambami, Neneng Syaripah Amelia, Yulistia Intan Amiruddin Siahaan Apriyanto, Bagas Asiyah, Asiyah Astuti, Maya Ayuni, Aulia Qurotul Azzahra Lubis, Fatimah Barnamij, Najhah Cahyani, Indah Tri darwis darwis, darwis Deti, Seri Mesi Murnila Dwi Setyaningsih Dwi Wulandari, Faizah Eka Rihan K, Eka Fadilah, Aisyah Fa’iq, Mohamad Ghani, M. ABD Hasanah Hasanah Hastono, Tri Heryawan, Lukman Imroh Atul Musfiroh Islamiati, Siti Hadiyati Dini Joanda, Ivan Rahmat Joupy G Z Mambu Juwartina Ida Royani, Juwartina Ida Khoiri, M Khoiri, M. Khojir Kurniadi, Rahmad Kusniati, Yuli Kusuma Wardana, Ari Leny Prihastuti Lestari, Nurul Indah Maulana, Antan Noraidi Miftahul Ilmi, Miftahul Miftahul Jannah Muchamad Rifki Muhaimin Hamzah Muhammad Andriansyah, Muhammad Muhammad Iqbal Muhammad Nur Muhammad Nur Muhammad Rezza Nur Rahman Muskita, Wellem H. Muttaqin, Katiko Imamul Nadisah, Sylvania Nasnawati, Nasnawati Nasrun Mohd Nawi, Mohd Nur Fitriana Nur Rokhman Nurwati Nurwati Qodri, Laila Rahayu, Umi Margi Raihan Raihan, Raihan Ramadani, M. Rifki Ramadhan, Muhammad Basith Riza, Fikri Rizki Amelia Robiah, Siti Rosita, Nor RR. Ella Evrita Hestiandari Sahrul, Sahrul Saputra, Muhamad Rendy Sari, Liani Setiawati, Yanti Hasbian Siregar, Chikadetry Syalomita SITI MARYAM Siti Maulidah Sri Endang Windiarti Sri Herianingrum Suaib, Sri Olawati Sulaeman, Devi Sulistyo Atmadi Syah, Firdiyan Syahidi, Aulia Akhrian SYOFI ROSMALAWATI Tangdilintin, Annisa Muliani Teuku Tajuddin Tri Sriyanpi, Imar Trimusqirfa, Niken Ayu Ulfain, Ulfain UMMAH, KHURUL AIMMATUL Wellem H. Muskita Widiyanto, S.Y. Didik Widodo Widodo Wildan Saugi Wulandari, Listi Wulandari, Via Febri Zega, Aldika Putra