Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : JURNAL HUKUM

The Legal Isomorphism in Indonesian Constitutional Amendment: Interplay Between Foreign Influence and National Identity Azhari, Aidul Fitriciada; Rizka, Rizka; Setiawati, Diana; Almira, Sekar Diah Ayu; Salmande, Ali
Jurnal Hukum Vol 41, No 4 (2025): Jurnal Hukum
Publisher : Unissula

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.26532/jh.v41i4.44109

Abstract

The post-authoritarian reform era in Indonesia (starting in 1998) was characterized by a push to democratize the state system, leading to the adoption of several foreign, democratic, or "globalized" constitutional concepts. This process demonstrates legal isomorphism where Indonesia aligned its constitutional framework with prevailing international democratic standards. This article analyses the patterns of legal isomorphism in the Indonesian constitutional amendment by examining the dynamic interplay between foreign influence and national identity. For that reason, the research aims to determine a legal isomorphism that can harmonize and balance both foreign influences and the desire for a national identity in the constitutional amendment in Indonesia. To achieve these objectives, the study employed a qualitative research method with a socio-legal and comparative law approach. The research finds three distinct patterns of coercive legal isomorphism concerning the constitutional amendment process in Indonesia. Meanwhile, comparatively, a mimetic isomorphism regarding unamendable provisions of basic structure can be considered for harmonizing and making a balance between foreign influences and national identity in the constitutional amendment. The novelty of this research lies in its identification and classification of legal isomorphism patterns within Indonesia’s constitutional amendments, providing a new perspective on how external legal influences interact with national identity. This study contributes to the broader discourse on constitutional development by offering a framework for analysing the complex relationship between global legal trends and domestic constitutional transformations.
Co-Authors a Widya Margaretha, Karelina Adriansyah Pradipta, Rifanov Afifah Hapsari Afdah Aflit Nuryulia Praswati Ahmad Agung Febrianto Ahmad Agung Febrianto Ahmad Fausi Ahmad Fauzan Ahmadzaki Fadhila Aidul Fitriciada Azhari Ainanur Faizah, Fatimah Al Fairuz, Muhammad Ranadhif Al Jawi Putri, Prisitina Alaysia, Amaylia Noor Alif Budhi Santosa Almira, Sekar Diah Ayu Alsyad Dedin Ryan Syahputra Althea Rinanda, Rima Anadila, Kharisma Tsalsabila Anggraeni, Chintya Anisahaq, Nabila Apriansah, Rizki Arief Budiono Ariffudin Nur Fadly Rosyid Arifkha Gita Zahara Assadath, Frido Davi Aulia Rahma Hafizha Ayu Astutik, Zulfiana Azhar Alam Baehaqi Bayu Aji Fadiansyah Bella Nova Silvia Benanda Bunga Natasha Berliana Azizah Carisa Maharani Chammellia Annastasya Melati4 Chintya Anggraeni Chrisna Bagus Edhita Praja Cindy Laksintya, Amelinda Della Puspitasari Dian Novitasari Dian Novitasari Anggraeni Dick Tjandra, Billie Dwi, Cindy Edho Setyawan Eka Saputri, Nurani Elvia Ghina Nismara Endah, Qori Enno Haya Gladya Naranta Enno Haya Gladya Naranta Evan Yusuf Priyokusumo Fadhila, Dhea Salsa Fajriansi, Andi Fanny Martdianty Farid, Achmad Miftah Fauziyah, Hanifah Febriani, Hanifah Frensiska Ardhiyaningrum Frontieka Ayu Rahmanto Frontieka Ayu Rahmanto Galang Andi Sunarto Ganeva, Irvan Ghaizka Figo Alfaeza Ghalib Rizki Luthfianto Hakim, Hary Abdul Hanifa Khoirunnisa Hanifah Fauziyah Hanifah Febriani Harjuna Nurfattah Hary Abdul Hakim Hasby Yoga, Fahmi Adam Haszmi Alfateh Hisanah Putri Ariyanto, Amelia Ibrahim Sholahudin Ika Sahwa Damayanti Indah Ayu Dewi Maharani Indah Maulani Irma Salvia Nisrina Isman Kanaya Ayodya Indra Prasta Karisma Cakraningrat Kevin Kurnia Yuli Ardikha Kinanthi Mukti, Berliana Latifah Kurniasih Linda Rose Rohidah M. Aldeon Putra Adi Surya Maghfirani, Syakira Mahendra Jaya Gumilang Mahfudz Rizal Setiawan Marsheila Audrey Nuralisha Mashari, Hanif Bagus Maulana Putra, Rafie Mira Eka Erlina Mozart Tiasylva Syah Nuhandika Mukti Fajar ND Mur Febianti, Selvi Mutimatun Ni'ami Nabila Ikbal Narusweta, Arasyel Noor Vinki Nayla Putri Aryani Nike Cahyaningrum Nilam Arum Sari Nirwa Rizkyana, Elsa Nirwago Danar P Noviana Pramesti Nur Andriyani Nur Fadilah Syahraya, Muhammad Nur Hidayah Nur Isa Herda A Nur Rizqi Febriandika Nuria Siswi Enggarani Nurmalitasari, Safira Pancawati, Angelina Pangaribuan, Leviadi Panji Nagaro Panji Nagaro Permata Dewi, Tyas Perwithosuci, Winny Pramesti, Noviana Presetiyo, Wibowo Heru Putri Dwi Arianti Putri Dwi Arianti Putri, Aulia Aninda Ektya Putri, Erna Putri, Thaasafina Sitasari Qusay Alya Difatta Rahma Rini Khalisa Firdausi Rahma Syifa Az Zahra Rahmanto, Frontieka Ayu Raihanita Raihanita Raka Dhamang Pangaribawan Rakhmat Dian Hidayat Rakhmat Dian Hidayat Ramadhani, Ichinoty ramadhani, zulfa Rika Septiani Rima Mila Wati Ristiana, Lisa Ristiani, Najwa Alya Riyandi Riyandi Rizka Rizka, Rizka Rizki Andriyanto, Aditya Rofi Aulia Rahman S Soepatini Sabrina Diyang A.P Sabrina Diyang Awandi Putri Saif Maulana Putra Susila Salma Nur Halizah Salmande, Ali Sandy, Fadillah Saptafasya, Viola Puti Saputro, Triyono Adi Shabrina, Kania Putri Soepatini Sopyan, Hisma Yuliet Abu Spaltan, Bita Gadsia Suarnianti, Suarnianti Suharso Suharso Syahputra, Adam Syakira Maghfirani Taufiq Taufiq Tiara Vergita Mahanani Triyono Triyono Tsalsabila Anadila, Kharisma Tyas, Erni Wardani, Lusyka Widya Wibowo, Rio Pradita Widya Ayu Khairunnisa Yanita, Salma Yasmin Safinatunnajah Yati Nurhayati Yuliana, Khozin Zahra Difa Setyawan, Charlintang Zainab Diva Amanda Zuhdi, Syaifuddin Zukrufi Ashof Almaunah Zulfiani Ayu Astutik