Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Jurnal Pendidikan Islam

Tree HR as a Multilevel Heuristic Framework for Human Resource Management and Development in Islamic Educational Institutions: A Systematic Scoping Review Tengku Ramly, Amir; Sinta Dewi, Reni; Lisnawati, Santi; Iba, Zainudin
Jurnal Pendidikan Islam Vol. 15 No. 1 (2026): Online First Articles
Publisher : Faculty of Tarbiyah and Education, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Sunan Kalijaga Yogyakarta

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.14421/jpi.2026.151.17-37

Abstract

Purpose – This study aims to map evidence on HRM and HRD in Islamic educational institutions and to formulate a multilevel conceptual framework based on Tree HR to read the conceptual interconnections among values, competencies, character, institutional context, and educational outcomes. Design/methods/approach – The research used a systematic scoping review based on PRISMA-ScR. The search was conducted in Scopus, Web of Science, ERIC, and secondary searching for the period from 2010 to 2025. From 151 records, 4 duplicates were removed, 147 records were screened, 56 were excluded, and 91 studies were analyzed through charting, thematic synthesis, methodological characterization, and mapping to the Tree HR components. Findings – The findings show an increase in publications from 2023 to 2025, with a peak in 2025 of 38 studies or 41.8%. The highest thematic concentration was in Trunk, namely competencies and HRD, which appeared in 62 studies, as well as Fruits/Leaves, namely performance, service quality, and educational outcomes, in 61 studies. Roots appeared in 44 studies, whereas Personality/Character appeared in 34 studies. The main gaps include weak multilevel testing, heterogeneity of indicators, the dominance of non-causal designs, and limited instrument validity across contexts. Research implications – This framework can be used as an initial tool for reflection and diagnosis of human resources in madrasahs, pesantren, integrated Islamic schools, and Islamic Religious Higher Education Institutions (PTKI), particularly for training planning, performance assessment, career development, and the formulation of human resource policy indicators for Islamic education.
Co-Authors A. Rahmat Rosyadi Abdul Aziz Ade Hasim Agung Sri Hendarsa Agus Triyanto Ahmad Juwaini Aisah, Elis Nur Ami Pujiwati Andi Irawan Andriyansah . Anggraeni, Frida Nur Anggraini Sukmawati Anisa Husnul Khotimah Ardiasih, Lidwina Sri Arif Rahman Saleh Arif Rahman Saleh Arina Nur Farida Aris Munandar Arizal, Arizal Asep Sunandar Avif Hanif Fadlun Azkiya Banata Budi Handrianto Cicih Sukarsih Dadang Misbahudin Dalilah Dalilah Darwis Sunandar Darwis Sunandar Daryl Januar Isya Daud Bachtiar Dedi Supriyadi Desi Permata Sari Dhewani, Prima Niendya Sukma Dudung Abdul Syukur Erny Indrayanti Ety Yuliaty Firdaus, Rhendy Akhmad Firdayanti B Hakim Firdayanti, Firdayanti Gumelar Adi Wijaya Gunawan Hasanuddin Hasanuddin Hidayah, Zainur Hubeis, Aida Vitayala Sjafri I Nyoman Nugraha Ardana Putra Iba, Zainudin Ibdalsyah Ibdalsyah Ilham Ilham Imas Kania Rahman Indupurnahayu Intani, Yunita Dwi Cahya Isbaya Isbaya Jana, Niftahul Kirbandoko, Kirbandoko Kurniawati, Nanin Diah Kusuma Siregar, Dina M. Aziz Firdaus M. Syamsul Maarif Made Yudhi Setiani Maryani Yani Masrukhan, Luthfiyah Masyhudzulhak Djamil Mawar Hidayanti Sunarto Misbahudin, Dadang Mohammad Ridwan Muhammad Ashari Natsir Musa Hubeis Nandang Sutisna Niar Yuniarsih Nurhayati, Immas Nurmala Katrina Pandjaitan Priadi, Getama Puji Astuti Puteri Eka Yunita Putra, Awang Darmawan Qurroh Ayuniyyah Rahayu, Yuyun Sri Rahim, Anwar Rahmat Ramli, Ridiarsih Rasiban Rasiban Renea Shinta Aminda Reni Sinta Dewi Rizal, Saepul Saepul Rizal Santi Lisnawati SANTI LISNAWATI Sarah Rifat Alhawari Sayyidah Sayyidah Septianti, Ajeng Shoffan Nizomi Suparman sibuea, yohana Simorangkir, Sendi Romadhon Sinta Dewi, Reni Sofianti, Evin Sri Langgeng Ratnasari Sriyani Suherbi, Didong Sunandar, Jauhari Suparno Suparno Surati Surati Syahruddin Syahruddin Syaiful Syaiful Syaiful Syarif, Usman Taryani, Heni Taufik Hidayat Ulumiyah, Churriyah Warcito Waskita, Kukuh Galih Wida’atullah, Muhammad Rofif Yuli Rohmalia Yuli Rohmalia Yuliati, Ety Yuniarsih, Niar Yusuf Munajat Zainuddin Iba