Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Rechtsvinding

Analysis of Decision Number 291/Pdt.G/2024/Pa.Prob Regarding the Revocation of the Mediation Agreement Outside the Presence of the Defendant from the KHI Perspective and Civil Law Ayu, Fitri; Rusly, Fathullah; Irawan, Ahmad Soni
Rechtsvinding Vol. 3 No. 2 (2025)
Publisher : Civiliza Publishing

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.59525/rechtsvinding.v3i2.896

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the legal considerations of the panel of judges at the Probolinggo Religious Court in Decision Number 291/Pdt.G/2024/PA.Prob regarding the withdrawal of a mediation agreement in the absence of the defendant, from the perspective of the Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI) and civil law. The background of this research is based on the fact that mediation is a mandatory stage in civil cases, including divorce cases, as stipulated in Supreme Court Regulation Number 1 of 2016. However, in practice, problems arise when a mediation agreement is unilaterally withdrawn without the presence of one party, creating legal implications for the validity of the agreement. This research employs a qualitative method with normative juridical and empirical juridical approaches. Primary data were obtained through interviews with mediators, judges, and litigants, while secondary data were sourced from laws and regulations, legal literature, and case documents. The findings reveal that the withdrawal of a mediation agreement without the presence of the defendant has the potential to violate the principles of balance and good faith in agreements as regulated in Article 1338 of the Indonesian Civil Code. From the perspective of KHI, such an action is inconsistent with the principles of deliberation and amicable settlement as stipulated in Articles 115 and 116 of KHI. The panel of judges in this decision considered the existence of procedural violations in the withdrawal process, thereby declaring the mediation agreement non-binding. These findings emphasize the importance of the presence of both parties in the mediation and agreement withdrawal process to ensure legal certainty and substantive justice.
Co-Authors -, Zairinayati Abi Sahnan, Vinky Abi Sahnan, Zawi Andri Cole Deswanda Andriani, Bela Anggraini Thesisia Saragih Ariatna Asna Juwaira Barli Kifli Batubara, Muhammad Hasyimsyah Cahayani Adha, Afifah Cahyani Isnaini Chindy Retika Daniel Happy Putra Dara Ilfa Rahila, Cut Daulay, Suandi Della Ardina Desi Ramadhani Devi Anggraini Devi Anggriani Devi Yuliana Devi Yuliana, Devi Diana Diana Diky Ridha Hikmawan Diwangga, Awal Erna M.Si Juita S.Pd Fadiyah Ramadani Fernenda, Larysa Hanifah, Ghina Hasyimsyah Batubara, Muhammad Hazmi, Dolly Henda, Zupri Herianto Herianto Ilmi Faried, Annisa Indra, Hamdi Irawan, Ahmad Soni Isnaeni, Diah Mutiara Johari Johari Kamarni, Neng Larashati, Devi M. Safe’i Maulana Malay, Irvan Mardainis Matondang, Maulidya Mora Melyanti, Rika Mey Deshafira Sari Mira Yosefa Siregar Mita Sari Lubis Mona Triswidia, Dwi Muhammad Muhammad Muhammad Zidan Shiddiq Muhimmah, Siti Musriatul Murtiyana Sari Mustafiyanti Mustafiyanti Mutiara R, Besse Nasution, Asfrianda Mulia Nasution, Azlaini Yus Nasywa Harahap Nazlah Syahaf Nasution Nazma Aliya Nefilinda Nefilinda NINA FADILAH Nizamuddin Nizamuddin Nizamuddin Novita Salsabilla Nursofi Aulia Nurul Azmi Purjumatin Putra, Rizal Effendi Rafsanjany, Mu’ammar Ramayani Rapita Sari, Desti Rayfades, Akbar Rifqatul Husna Rika rina, noorazrina Riyan Saputra Rusly, Fathullah Sailun, Betty Salsabilla, Putri Icha Sanjaya, Firman Lukman Sigit Setijo Budi, Sigit Setijo Sisi Hendriani Sucipto Andika Widiana tasia, Widiana tasia willyansah, willyansah Wira Yudha, Regindra Yulianto Yulianto Yuni Khairina Zairinayati, Zairinayati Zulhermindra