Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Ulumuna

Criticism of Mustafa Azami's Critical Thoughts in Study of Hadith Isnaeni, Ahmad; Susanto, Is; Haqiqi, Abdurrahman Raden Aji
Ulumuna Vol 27 No 2 (2023): December
Publisher : Universitas Islam Negeri Mataram

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.20414/ujis.v27i2.758

Abstract

The existence and authenticity of hadith have become two of the most essential objects in the discourse of hadith among Muslims, especially after coming into contact with criticism from Orientalists. This article describes explicitly and criticizes Azami's hadith thought in the hadith debate among Orientalists. This research is an analytical descriptive research based on content analysis. The results reveal that Azami can position himself as a critic of the Western thesis by presenting historical data as a basis for his thoughts. The rhythm of the scientific debate modeled on by Western thinkers can be dived into and followed convincingly so that their responses and criticisms reach the Orientalists. Orientalists believe that Azami's criticism has not been able to divert the orientation of the general thesis that hadiths are not historically authentic. Azami's defense still needs convincing, and the arguments are still circular. This model of thinking has yet to satisfy the scientific desires of the Orientalists, so it has a small implications.
Co-Authors Abdul Malik Ghozali Agus Hermanto Ahmad Isnaeni Alamsyah Alamsyah - Alamsyah, A. Ali Abdul Wakhid andriani, riski Anggraeni, Ade Irma Any Eliza Ariyanti, Eliya Asfiah, Farida Azzahra, Adisti Mutiara Badriyah, Hasna Bahrudin, Moh. Dewi Kurniawati Dinda Fali Rifan Erike Anggraeni Ersi Sisdianto Evi Ekawati Faisal Faisal fatimah Fatimah Fatoni, Fatoni Fauzan . Femei Purnamasari, Femei Fitri, Al Fitri, Aliyatun Gandhi Liyorba Indra Ghoni, Mei Arrafi Gustika Nurmalia Hanif Hanif Haqiqi, Abdurrahman Raden Aji Harjoni Harjoni Henisah, Ratih Heri, Mad Hervin Yoki Pradikta Ika Wahyuningsih Ishomuddin, A. Jadmiko, Purbo Julaihah, Siti Junita Aurelia, Nindia Khairuddin, K. Liky Faizal M. Ngisomudin M. Yasin Al Arif M. Yusuf Bahtiar, M. Yusuf Madnasir Madnasir Maksum, Endang Ali Mardhiyah Hayati Marwin Marwin Masrukhin Muhsin Maulana, Bintang Mochammad Imron Awalludin Moh. Bahrudin Moh. Mukri Moh. Mukri Muhamad Rizki Muhammad Iqbal Muhammad Iqbal Fasa Muhammad Kurniawan Muhammad Zakiy Mukminatul, Diah Ningsih, Nur Wahyu Northa Idaman Pratama, Heri Okta Putra, Rizky Hamdala Qohar, Abd. Qotadah, Hudzaifah Achmad Rafi, M Al Rafi’Syaiim, Salsabila Ramadhan, Rudiansyah Dwi Ridwansyah Ridwansyah Rochmad - Rochmad Rochmad S. Suharto Sadari, S. Salsabila, Hana Zalfa Saputra, Edriagus Sari, Sherly Etika Saskia, Elsa Septa Aryanika SITI MAHMUDAH Tanasya, Levina Faza Taufiqur Rahman, Taufiqur Thonsa, Elsi Alga Todi, Dhiya' Salsabila Umi Habibah Yulistia Devi Zamil, Pradita Dien Ayu Putri Zuhraini Zuliandika, Muhammad Rizki Zuliansyah, A