Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

ENGINEERING REASONING GAPS: MODEL KONSEPTUAL DAN TAKSONOMI PADA PEMBELAJARAN CAD 3D Muhammad Hudan Rahmat; Sukardi; Agung Samudra; Harie Satiyadi Jaya; Rengga Dwiva; Joe Sri Simorangkir
Steam Engineering Vol. 8 No. 1 (2026): STEAM Engineering, Vol. 8, No. 1, September 2026
Publisher : Program Studi Pendidikan Teknik Mesin, Fakultas Keguruan dan Ilmu Pendidikan, Universitas Palangka Raya

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.37304/jptm.v8i1.23987

Abstract

3D CAD learning requires not only mastery of software procedures but also engineering reasoning to understand geometry, determine component relationships, and validate modeling outcomes. This study aimed to identify patterns of students’ reasoning when completing a 3D CAD assembly task, develop an exploratory conceptual model of the reasoning trajectories that emerged during task completion, and identify reasoning gaps underlying the observed processes. A qualitative multiple-case study was conducted with five Mechanical Engineering Education students at Universitas Palangka Raya. Data were collected through task-based observation, screen recordings, and retrospective interviews, and were analyzed using thematic analysis with the assistance of NVivo. The findings revealed three reasoning trajectories: the Cognitive Obstacle Path, Pragmatic-Collaborative Path, and Analytical-Independent Path. Cross-case analysis further identified four categories of reasoning gaps: manufacturing knowledge, inferential reasoning, CAD procedural interaction, and spatial visualization, with error attribution identified as a cross-cutting metacognitive dimension. Based on these findings, an exploratory conceptual model was developed to describe the dynamic relationship among task demands, problem-solving strategies, and verification processes during 3D CAD modeling. The findings provide a basis for designing CAD learning that extends beyond software feature mastery toward the development of engineering reasoning.
Co-Authors A. Sandi Saputra Abdi Sampurno Abdurrahman abdurrahman Abelia, Nia Adinda Inayah Wulandari Mangowal Adit Setiawan Aep Saefullah Agung M Pribadi Agung Samudra Agus Romadhona Ahmad Eko Suryanto Ahmad Norwahid Airways Parlindungan Siahaan Anisa Nur'aini Ari Buldzaki Syam Auliya Ataki, Ruli Baiq Indah Nurmayanti Baso Fian Rahmat Candra Agustina Darwin Prima Sakti Debora Debora Devi Dwi Siskawardani Diah Puji Nali Brata Diki Cahyoko Edy Setiyo Utomo Eric Timotius Hartono Fitry Taufiq Sahary Gabriel Alfrans Valentino Juli Galfri Siswandi Galfri Siswandi Galfri Siswandi Gilang Rengku Fadhillah Grees Selly Hanifa Risqiana Harie Satiyadi Jaya Harie Setiyadi Jaya Hildayanti Hisan Fithransah Huzaimah Al-Anshori I Made Supatra Imam Malik Ina Marca Istifar Yogi Prayogi Izhar Husadi Jeremy Imanuel Segah Joe Sri Simorangkir K.P.Suharyono S.Hadiningrat kabib sholeh@ sejarah Lorenta Indrianto Lumbantobing, Marko Ayaki M. Afan M. Syamsudin M.A. Muazar Habibi MARDIANA Maulana, Muhammad Fauzan Maydiant, Endry Merisa Oktaria Moh. Risaldi Mohammad Andika Mufti Hafidhi Muh. Fachrin Agsa Muhammad Asdar Muhammad Hudan Rahmat Muhammad Mahmuda MUHAMMAD TAUFIK Muhammad Zailani Musliadi Musliadi Mustika, Putri Norasikin Nugroho Nad Nur Alinuddin Kaharu Nur Azizah Nur Oktaviani Talinggo Nursaptini Nurul Huda Oktavia, Maharani Pri Ariadi Cahya Dinata Pribadi, Muh. Agung Rachmayani, Ika Randoh Fernando Ratna Pancawati Rengga Dwiva Rika Ayu Lestari Riska Amelia Rochayati , Rully ROCHAYATI, RULLY Roy Jordi Rozi, Fahrur Salima, Rianti Samka Pramuja Septa Nuriana Dewi Soamole, Amrin Sri Murwantini Supardi Ngareng Supriyadi Supriyadi Syafawi, Ahmad Syamsul Arifin Syarpin Syarpin Syarpin Syarpin Syarpin Tazun Nisa Febrianti, Maelani Toriq, Muhammad Tri Ashfiya Sya'bani Valentine Vontas Alfenny Nahan Vontas Alfeny Nahan Wadi, Hairil Widya Wahyuni Asnur Wildan Wiyogo Wiyogo Wiyogo Wiyogo Wiyogo Yudi Pratama Yulando, Steven Yunus Tete Konde Zainudin