Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Dilema keberadaan pedagang kaki lima di bantaran Sungai Muaro Panjalinan Hermanita, Reva Putri; Irwan, Irwan; Moeis, Isnarmi; Dewi, Susi Fitria
Journal of Education, Cultural and Politics Vol. 6 No. 1 (2026): Fifteenth Edition
Publisher : Departemen Pendidikan Kewarganegaraan dan Ilmu Hukum Universitas Negeri Padang

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.24036/jecco.v6i1.942

Abstract

The presence of street vendors on the banks of the Muaro Panjalinan River in Padang City creates a dilemma between the economic needs of small communities and the ecological function of the riverbank area, as well as the enforcement of spatial planning policies. This study aims to analyze the actual conditions of street vendor placement from a spatial, legal, and social interaction perspective. It also examines the dilemmas that arise in environmental, social, and economic dimensions. The study employed a qualitative approach with a case study method. Data were obtained through observation, in-depth interviews, and documentation studies with street vendors, local residents, community leaders, the Public Order Agency (Satpol PP), and the River Basin Office (BWS). The results indicate that street vendor placement developed spontaneously without spatial planning and exists under conditions of uncertain legality. This activity has resulted in a decline in the quality of the riverbank environment and increased ecological risks, giving rise to conflicts over the use of space and changing patterns of social interaction. However, it also serves as a primary source of livelihood for the vendors. These findings demonstrate an imbalance in the management of public space and the need for more integrative and equitable planning policies.
Co-Authors Afdol Tasmara Afdol Tasmara Afifa Rifki, Aufi Afiko, Dinang Akmal, Eko Al Rafni Aldri Frinaldi Alvin Gumelar Hanevi Andes Hulfareza Andri Maijar Andriani Andriani Angraini, Nosy Mutia Arieska Dwi Asmil Arisman Trisno Audia, Yevi Ayla Fandhini Azwar Ananda Beska, Prima Indrata Brilliany Dwi Mitry Debi Lizarman Deby Andrila Delmira Syafrini Deno Arifianto Dimaz Oktama Andriyendi Dwi Fitri Rima Yoli Ega Dwi Sandrika Eka Vidya Putra Erianjoni Erianjoni Erlina Pantja Sulistijaningtijas Ersya, Muhammad Prima Ersya, Muhammad Prima Fadli Ilham Fadli Nofratama Fatmariza Fatmariza Febri Yulika Fitri, Aida Gebri Jasman Gustiva Yelviani Hafizhah Hamim Nasution Hanika Gusti Sani Hanuzral, Muhammad Hasibuan, Huwaida Afra Hasrul Hasrul, Hasrul Hasrul Piliang Henni Muchtar Hermanita, Reva Putri Hidayah, Yayuk Hikma Damayanti Hutabarat, Wildan Yusran Ideal Putra Ifijalia Nofila Indah Rahayu Putri Indrawadi, Junaidi Irfan Saputra Irwan Hamdi Irwan Hamdi Irwan Irwan Irwan Irwan Isnarmi Moeis Jandrea Putri, Yunda Jelly Jelly Joni, Erian Julio, Axnes Junaidi Irwandi Junita, Upik Khairani Khairani Khairani Khairani Lely Suryani Nasution Lisa Suhaimar Lisna Waty Ritonga Luthfi, Zaky Farid M. Yusuf Siregar Mardhatillah, Ummi Maria Montessori Marlina, Tika Indra Mesy Maisara Milleniya, Lola Fitri Monda Resta, Nova Monica Tiara Muhammad Ramez Mutia Afwinda Mutia Eka Masputri Mutia Shandy Nada Elva Susanti Nasution, Hafizhah Hamim Nazhifah, Suci Naurah Ningsih, Wella Ayu Nora. AN, Desri Nosy Mutia Angraini Nurjannah Nurjannah Nurman Nurman Nurman S Nurman S Nursaid, Imral Ofianto, Ofianto Oftayanti, Nala Oktaviani, Revi Paluvi, Mutiara Gita Pohan, Mukmin Pratama Putra, Dava Purnama, Tetti Eka Putra, Tommy Pratama Putri Novita Sari Putri Yanti, Putri Putri, Nadia Dwi Rahman, Khawarizmi Rahmat, Afdhalur Rahmi Fauzia Ramadhani, Riska Putri Recy Harviani Zurwanty Restu Diannisa Restu Syahputra Sinaga Rika Febriani Riky Pratama Susilo Riri Trinanda Ririn Oktavia Rivad, Muhammad Rizka Morina Rozani, Devi Sakti, Reza Ginandha Salsabila Salsabila Sandra, Jerli Novia Santia, Windi Saputri, Rahmawati Sari, Yesi Fitria Sayuti, Aldimas Rakasi Servasius Balok Sihombing, Radot Maruli T Sinta Nurjulaiha Siska Pratama Siti Rahmi Sonia Fantika Suri Sri Bunga Oktavia Sri Rahayu SRI RAHAYU Suhono Suhono, Suhono Suryanef Suryanef Susi Karmila Syafri Anwar Syahdina Ahbal Syamsuddin Anas Tama, Deva Alfian Tiara, Monica Tristiadina, Arini Ulpa, Fadilla utami, anis Wirdanengsih, Wirdanengsih Yessica Pratama Naibaho Yetty Oktayanty Yudiana Nofriani Yulia Almira Yulista, Maghfira Yuni Kartika, Yuni Yunita Rozalinda Yurni Suasti Yurni Suasti Yusnanik Bakhtiar Zahara, Nurul Husna Zatalini, Rinia Zhalsa Oktavilia