Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Found 1 Documents
Search
Journal : Equator Science Journal (ESJ)

Physics Teachers' Ability to Reflect on Learning: A Case Study in Palu City Nurjannah, Nurjannah; Supriyatman, Supriyatman; Kade, Amiruddin
Equator Science Journal Vol. 4 No. 1 (2026): Equator Science Journal (ESJ)
Publisher : CV. Dharma Samakta Edukhatulistiwa

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.61142/esj.v4i1.382

Abstract

This study aims to map the learning-reflection ability of Physics teachers in Palu City, Central Sulawesi, at both the planning and implementation levels, and to analyse the influence of Guru Penggerak (Teacher-Mover) status on the quality of reflection displayed. The study employs a qualitative approach with a multiple case study design involving seven Physics teachers from seven public senior high schools, purposively selected on the principle of maximum variation. Data were collected through document analysis of lesson plans (RPP/Teaching Modules), 21 non-participant classroom observations, and triangulation interviews with 21 students. The main instrument was a review-and-observation sheet based on twenty reflection indicators synthesised from the frameworks of Schön, Hatton and Smith, and the revised Bloom taxonomy. The results show that the average reflection ability of the teachers reached only 19% at the planning stage and 21% at the implementation stage, both of which fall within the very low category according to the Larrivee framework. Reflection questions were dominated by ritualistic closed formats at the descriptive-writing level, with four metacognitive indicators not appearing at all across the participants. Guru Penggerak teachers consistently displayed higher reflective capacity (28%) than regular teachers (18%), particularly in the closing stage of the lesson. These findings indicate that academic qualifications and long teaching experience are not automatically correlated with reflective ability, and underscore the importance of developing a standardised reflection toolkit based on Social Emotional Competence to support the implementation of the Kurikulum Merdeka.
Co-Authors A. Samsudin A. Suhandi A. Syukur, Muhammad Syarif Aan Febriawan Abd. Syukur, Muh. Syarif S. Abdul Kamaruddin Achmad Samsudin Adimayuda, Rizal Afadil Afadil Afriani, Rifka Ainun, Nurul Alfani Alfani Alfani, Alfani Amalia Buntu Amelia, Nurafni Aminudin, Adam Hadiana Amiruddin Hatibe Amiruddin Kade Andi mursyidin mubaraq Andriani Andriani Aprilia Ningsih, Andi Arda Ardiani, Ni Kadek Ariana, Sartika Ayu Astija Az’zahra, N. F. Azizah, Wafiq Bayram Coştu Binar Kurnia Prahani Citra Dewi Costu, Bayram D. Rusdiana Darsikin Darsikin F. C. Wibowo Faizin, Mohammad Noor Febriawan, Aan Firmanul Catur Wibowo Fratiwi, Nuzulira Janeusse Gustina Gustina Hera Novia Herdiansyah Saputra Husain, Sadang I Gede Sumertadana I Wayan Darmadi Ielda Paramita Irawan Irawan Irmayanti Irmayanti, Irmayanti Irwandani Irwandani Ismail Ismail Jusman Mansyur Kade, Amirudin Kamaluddin Kamaluddin Ketut Alit Adi Untara Khair, Fathul Lole, Sri Wulandari M. Ali Mangendre, Fazri Mansyur, J. Marungkil Pasaribu Masrifah, Masrifah Masrifah, Masrifah Miftah Miftah, Miftah Mirnawati Mirnawati Mohammad Jamhari Muh. Syarif Abd Syukur Muhamad Yusup Muhamad Yusup MUHAMMAD ALI Muhammad Jarnawi Muhammad Nurtanto Muhammad Zaky Muslimin Muslimin Muslimin N. Novia, N. Ni Putu Murniasih S Ni Wayan Diana Putri Niki Dian Permana P Nunuk Haryanti Nur Fadhilatu Rahmah, Nur Fadhilatu Nurasyah Dewi Napitupulu Nurjannah Nurjannah NURLAELA NURLAELA NURUL AZIZAH Nurul Azmi, Nurul Nuzulira Janeusse Fratiwi Pahriadi Pahriadi Pahriadi Pahriadi Purnama Ningsih Putriyanti Putriyanti Putriyanti, Putriyanti Rafiq Badjeber Rahmawati, Besse Rahmita Rahmita Rahmita Ratman Ratnaningtyas, Delthawati Isti Raya Agni Retno Suko Wardaningsih Rewalino, Yulid Indriyani Rudi Santoso, Rudi S. Supriyadi, S. Saehana, S. Sahrul Saehana Samria Samria Saputra, Herdiansyah Sarintan Kaharu Siti Rabiatul Adawiyah, Siti Rabiatul Suci Fathul Ismi Supriyadi Supriyadi Supriyadi Syamsu Syamsu Syamsu Syech Zainal Syech Zainal Unggul Wahyono Uyun, Uyun Wahyuni, Dewi Steri Wardaningsih, Retno Suko Windia Hadi, Windia Yuliana Sumbung, Dewi