Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Legal Review of Legal Protection and Dispute Resolution Regarding Alleged Malapractice by Medical Personnel in Law Number 17 Of 2023 Concerning Health Widia Wirawan; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Sendi Sanjaya
JIHAD : Jurnal Ilmu Hukum dan Administrasi Vol. 8 No. 3 (2026): JIHAD : Jurnal Ilmu Hukum dan Administrasi
Publisher : Lembaga Penelitian dan Pendidikan (LPP) Mandala

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.58258/yzd8xt47

Abstract

Law No. 17 of 2023 concerning Health, an omnibus law that has been in effect since August 8, 2023, is expected to provide better legal protection for medical personnel compared to the existing law. However, in reality, cases of alleged medical malpractice disputes are increasingly emerging and even going viral. Generally, alleged medical malpractice disputes arise because the results of healthcare services do not meet expectations or demands. The public no longer considers whether there was intent to harm the patient (mens rea), how healthcare services are delivered, or the individual variability of each patient, which sometimes results in the inability to fully adhere to standard operating procedures. This thesis aims to answer the following questions: The implementation of Law No. 17 of 2023 concerning Health in providing legal protection for medical personnel in carrying out their profession, and the procedures for resolving alleged medical malpractice disputes under Law No. 17 of 2023 concerning Health. The purpose of this thesis is to determine the implementation of Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health in providing legal protection for medical personnel in carrying out their profession, and to determine the procedures for resolving medical disputes involving alleged medical malpractice. The results of this empirical normative research, which involved 26 respondents, all medical personnel at the Dr. Midiyato Suratani Naval Hospital in Tanjungpinang, revealed that all respondents (100%) felt that Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health was inadequate in providing legal protection for their profession. Only one respondent (3.8%) stated that the implementation of Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health was worse in terms of legal protection and the procedures for resolving disputes involving alleged medical malpractice. Eleven respondents (42.3%) stated that it was better, eight respondents (30.8%) stated that it was the same, and six respondents (23.1%) stated that they did not know. In terms of medical dispute resolution, 23 respondents (88.5%) stated that Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health has not provided a sense of justice for medical personnel, while 2 respondents (7.7%) stated that it has provided a sense of justice and 1 respondent (3.8%) stated that they did not know
Legal Analysis of Teaching Hospital Liability for Resident Physicians’ Actions under Indonesia’s Health Law No. 17 of 2023: A Case Study of Decision No. 228/Pdt.G/2025/PN Jkt.Pst Yulis Setyaningsih; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
JIHAD : Jurnal Ilmu Hukum dan Administrasi Vol. 8 No. 3 (2026): JIHAD : Jurnal Ilmu Hukum dan Administrasi
Publisher : Lembaga Penelitian dan Pendidikan (LPP) Mandala

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.58258/yff2sj77

Abstract

Teaching hospitals perform a dual function as healthcare providers and clinical education institutions, creating complex legal issues regarding liability for medical actions carried out by resident physicians. The enactment of Indonesia’s Health Law No. 17 of 2023 introduces a new legal framework governing teaching hospitals and establishes the Professional Disciplinary Council (Majelis Disiplin Profesi/MDP) as a prerequisite in civil medical malpractice claims. This study aims to analyze the legal construction of teaching hospital liability for resident physicians’ actions and to examine the evidentiary value and legal standing of MDP recommendations in civil litigation through the analysis of Decision No. 228/Pdt.G/2025/PN Jkt.Pst. The research employs a normative juridical approach using an intrinsic case study design. Primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials were analyzed qualitatively through content analysis, statutory interpretation, and doctrinal analysis based on the theories of vicarious liability and informed consent. The findings demonstrate that teaching hospital liability is primarily founded on the doctrine of vicarious liability, as reflected in Articles 243–248 and Article 193 of Health Law No. 17 of 2023. However, the court dismissed the plaintiff’s claim after determining that the defendants had complied with professional standards, service standards, and standard operating procedures. Furthermore, the study finds that MDP recommendations possess substantial evidentiary value but are not legally binding, requiring judges to assess them alongside other admissible evidence. This research contributes to the development of Indonesian health law by clarifying the legal responsibilities of teaching hospitals, strengthening patient protection, and promoting greater legal certainty in medical malpractice litigation involving resident physicians. It also recommends clearer statutory guidelines concerning the evidentiary status of MDP recommendations and greater harmonization between Health Law No. 17 of 2023 and the Indonesian Civil Code to ensure balanced legal protection for both patients and healthcare providers
Crypto Assets as Property in Indonesian Law: Substantive Qualification and a Partial Lacuna Legis in Their Proprietary Consequences Adalin Ali; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela
Law Development Journal Vol 8, No 3 (2026): September 2026
Publisher : Universitas Islam Sultan Agung

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.30659/ldj.8.3.1360-1370

Abstract

The number of crypto asset users in Indonesia reached 21.70 million by April 2026, yet its status as property (benda) under the Indonesian Civil Code (KUH Perdata) remains undefined. This normative legal study employs statutory and conceptual approaches to analyze the classification of crypto assets as objects of property rights. The findings indicate that crypto assets substantially meet the criteria for intangible movable property under Articles 499 and 503 of the Civil Code, as they possess economic value, are identifiable, and are technically controllable via private keys. However, possession of a private key serves merely as an indicator of factual control rather than automatic proof of ownership or a basis for droit de suite; legal ownership must still be established through transaction histories, agreements, and custodial arrangements. This substantive classification has not yet resulted in uniform property-law consequences. The numerus clausus principle does not preclude classification as property but necessitates clarification regarding the associated legal consequences. Furthermore, the principle of publicity remains unsatisfied, as the link between wallet addresses and holder identities is inaccessible to third parties. This situation creates a partial lacuna legis regarding proof of ownership, transfer, inheritance, security interests, seizure, and execution, placing crypto assets in a zwevende rechtspositie (suspended legal position) between substantive classification and formal regulation. Consequently, legislation is required to clarify the property-law implications of crypto assets and to establish publicity mechanisms compatible with their cryptographic nature.
Pendaftaran Merek Beriktikad Tidak Baik Pada Putusan Pengadilan Niaga Jakarta Pusat Nomor 87 Tahun 2025 Denny Cahyadi Tiono; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
Locus: Jurnal Konsep Ilmu Hukum Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Juli
Publisher : LOCUS MEDIA PUBLISHING

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56128/jkih.v6i2.1045

Abstract

Pelindungan hukum merek terkenal di Indonesia seharusnya menjamin kepastian hukum sesuai amanat Undang-Undang Nomor 20 Tahun 2016. Namun, penegakan hukumnya masih diwarnai maraknya permohonan pendaftaran beriktikad tidak baik untuk mendompleng reputasi pihak lain. Inkonsistensi parameter penilaian “merek terkenal” dan “iktikad tidak baik” oleh Direktorat Jenderal Kekayaan Intelektual (DJKI) maupun hakim pengadilan memicu disparitas putusan yang berakibat pada ketidakpastian hukum. Penelitian ini bertujuan menganalisis pengaturan pelindungan merek terkenal serta penafsiran hakim dalam Putusan Pengadilan Niaga Nomor 87/Pdt.Sus-HKI/Merek/2025/PN Niaga Jkt Pst, sekaligus merumuskan rekomendasi untuk memperkuat pelindungan tersebut. Metode penelitian yang digunakan adalah yuridis normatif melalui pendekatan perundang-undangan, konseptual, dan studi kasus yang dianalisis secara kualitatif. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa dikabulkannya gugatan pada Putusan Nomor 87/2025 menegaskan bahwa pelindungan hukum terhadap merek terkenal telah diakomodasi secara normatif dalam undang-undang. Sebagai langkah penguatan, diperlukan pembentukan regulasi turunan yang memuat parameter lebih rigid dan selaras dengan standar internasional terkait indikator merek terkenal dan iktikad tidak baik. Selain itu, DJKI perlu bersikap lebih proaktif dan ketat dalam tahap seleksi pemeriksaan substantif untuk mencegah terjadinya sengketa pendaftaran merek di kemudian hari.
Upaya Perlindungan Konsumen E-commerce dalam Kesepakatan Transaksi Online Ditinjau dari Perspektif Hukum Perdata Kencana Wulan; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
Locus: Jurnal Konsep Ilmu Hukum Vol 6 No 2 (2026): Juli
Publisher : LOCUS MEDIA PUBLISHING

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56128/jkih.v6i2.1047

Abstract

Praktik transaksi e-commerce saat ini sering kali menempatkan konsumen dalam posisi rentan akibat transaksi buta (blind bargain) dan dominasi klausula baku sepihak dalam click-wrap agreement. Kondisi ini mengaburkan esensi konsensus, menghilangkan ruang negosiasi, dan menciptakan ketimpangan posisi tawar antara pelaku usaha dan konsumen. Secara normatif, kontrak e-commerce seharusnya memenuhi syarat sah perjanjian sesuai Pasal 1320 KUHPerdata, di mana setiap bentuk penipuan (bedrog) atau kekhilafan (dwaling) yang mengakibatkan cacat kehendak harus memungkinkan pembatalan kontrak. Selain itu, klausula baku yang membebaskan tanggung jawab pelaku usaha secara sepihak wajib dinyatakan batal demi hukum sesuai Pasal 18 UU Perlindungan Konsumen (UUPK). Penelitian ini bertujuan menganalisis kedudukan hukum kontrak e-commerce serta bentuk perlindungan bagi konsumen yang dirugikan oleh perjanjian yang tidak sesuai dengan prinsip kesepakatan. Melalui metode yuridis normatif, hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa meskipun kontrak elektronik sah menurut UU ITE, secara empiris ia sering menyimpang dari nilai keadilan komutatif akibat hilangnya konsensus. Perlindungan konsumen diimplementasikan melalui instrumen pembatalan kontrak atas dasar cacat kehendak dan pembatalan klausula eksonerasi. Namun, dalam praktiknya, upaya hukum melalui Pengadilan Negeri maupun BPSK sering terhambat oleh rumitnya pembuktian dan biaya litigasi yang tidak sebanding dengan nilai kerugian skala kecil (small claims). Oleh karena itu, sebagai solusi perlindungan optimal, negara perlu memfasilitasi mekanisme Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) yang efisien dan memperkuat wewenang eksekutorial BPSK untuk menjamin akses keadilan yang lebih terjangkau bagi konsumen di era digital.
A LEGAL ANALYSIS OF LEGAL CERTAINTY AND THE IMPLICATIONS OF RECLASSIFYING CIVIL DISPUTES AS EXTRAORDINARY CRIMES Buhit Christian; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Sunarno
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 1 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), October 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

This research departs from the phenomenon of debt collection practices by debt collectors which often exceed legal and ethical boundaries, thus raising the question of whether such actions should be qualified as a breach of contract in the civil realm or as a criminal act or even an extraordinary crime. The focus of the study is directed at the consistency of the application of the principle of legal certainty in civil cases that have the potential to enter the criminal realm, with the main study being Decision Number 311 / Pid.B / 2023 / PN JKT.SEL and its comparison with Decision Number 30 / Pdt.G / 2025 / PNPdg. The difference in the judges’ assessments in the two decisions indicates the existence of legal uncertainty which has implications for public protection and the potential for criminalization of contractual disputes. Therefore, this research emphasizes the urgency of a clear demarcation between the civil and criminal realms to ensure legal certainty is maintained and the principle of ultimum remedium in criminal law is not diminished. The research method used is a normative juridical approach with statutory, case-based, and conceptual approaches. The statutory approach is conducted by examining the applicable legal norms in the 1945 Constitution, the Civil Code, the Criminal Code, Law No. 42 of 1999 concerning Fiduciary Guarantees, and Law No. 8 of 1999 concerning Consumer Protection. The case-based approach is conducted by analyzing the ratio decidendi of judges in relevant court decisions, particularly the South Jakarta District Court and the Padang District Court. Meanwhile, the conceptual approach is used to understand the principle of legal certainty and the principle of ultimum remedium in criminal law. Primary legal materials include statutory regulations and court decisions, while secondary legal materials consist of the doctrines of legal experts, journals, and academic literature. With this method, the research attempts to provide a comprehensive analysis of the consistency of the application of the principle of legal certainty in disputes that have the potential to shift from the civil to the criminal realm. The formulation of the problem in this research is formulated as follows: (1) How is the application of the principle of legal certainty in civil cases that have the potential to enter the criminal realm, especially in the Decision of the South Jakarta District Court Number 311/Pid.B/2023 and the Decision of the Padang District Court Number 30/Pdt.G/2025? The judge’s decision apparatus in distinguishing default disputes from criminal acts in cases of debt collection by debt collectors? (2) What are the legal implications of the inconsistent application of the principle of legal certainty to public protection and the principle of ultimum remedium in criminal law? With this problem formulation, this research is expected to contribute to the development of legal science, especially in preventing the misuse of criminal law as a means of pressure in private disputes, while at the same time strengthening legal certainty as a fundamental principle in the Indonesian legal system.
LEGAL POSITION OF APARTMENT SALE PURCHASE BINDING AGREEMENTS IN DEVELOPER BANKRUPTCY DISPUTES SETTLEMENT IN INDONESIA David Yuwono; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Sendi Sanjaya
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 1 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), October 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

The Apartment Sales and Purchase Agreement (PPJB) is a legal instrument widely used as the basis for legal relations between developers and buyers before the Sale and Purchase Deed or the transfer of rights to the apartment unit is executed. In practice, problems arise when developers are declared bankrupt, creating uncertainty regarding the legal standing of the PPJB and legal protection for buyers who have fulfilled their obligations. This study aims to analyze the legal standing of the apartment PPJB in resolving developer bankruptcy disputes and examine the judge’s legal considerations in providing protection to buyers based on the provisions of Indonesian positive law. This study is a normative legal study using statutory, conceptual, and case approaches. The analysis was conducted on laws and regulations, court decisions, and various relevant literature. The results of the study indicate that the PPJB is a valid agreement and binds the parties based on the principle of pacta sunt servanda. However, in bankruptcy cases, the buyer’s position under the PPJB still faces legal uncertainty due to the conflict between contract law, land law, and bankruptcy law. Therefore, it is necessary to harmonize regulations and ensure consistency in the judges’ considerations to ensure legal certainty, justice, and legal protection for apartment buyers in good faith.
ANALYSIS OF THE CRIMINAL ACTION OF DISTRIBUTION OF COUNTERFEIT MONEY Erwin Hutasoit; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 1 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), October 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

The circulation of counterfeit money is a crime that can harm society and disrupt the country’s economic stability. Normatively (das sollen), Law Number 7 of 2011 concerning Currency prohibits any act of counterfeiting or circulating counterfeit money in order to protect the rupiah as a symbol of state sovereignty and legal tender. However, in reality (das sein), the crime of circulating counterfeit money still frequently occurs in society, even exploiting developments in information technology and social media as a means of obtaining and distributing counterfeit money. This situation presents challenges in the application of criminal law and the process of proving evidence against perpetrators of counterfeit money circulation. Therefore, a legal analysis of the application of criminal law and the judge’s considerations in Decision Number 656/Pid.B/2025/PN Bks is necessary. This study aims to determine the application of criminal law to the crime of distributing counterfeit money based on Law Number 7 of 2011 concerning Currency in Decision Number 656/Pid.B/2025/PN Bks and to determine the judge’s legal considerations in sentencing the perpetrator of the crime of distributing counterfeit money. The research method used is normative legal research with a regulatory and case-based approach. The legal materials used consist of primary, secondary, and tertiary legal materials obtained through literature review and then analyzed qualitatively. The results of the study indicate that the application of criminal law in Decision Number 656/Pid.B/2025/PN Bks complies with the provisions of Law Number 7 of 2011 concerning Currency and applicable criminal law provisions. The judge declared the perpetrator legally proven guilty and committed the crime of distributing counterfeit money based on valid evidence, witness statements, physical evidence, and laboratory examination results of the counterfeit money. The judge’s considerations in handing down the verdict also took into account the elements of guilt, the legal facts revealed during the trial, and the aggravating and mitigating circumstances of the defendant. Therefore, the verdict reflects the application of the principles of legal certainty, justice, and legal expediency in enforcing criminal law against the crime of distributing counterfeit money.
HARMONIZATION OF THE REGULATION OF INHERITANCE RIGHTS OF CHILDREN Fauzi; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Sunarno
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 1 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), October 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

The regulation regarding the inheritance rights of illegitimate children from biological fathers still raises legal issues due to the disharmony between Law Number 1 of 1974 concerning Marriage, Constitutional Court Decision Number 46/PUU-VIII/2010, and the Compilation of Islamic Law. These differences in regulations create legal uncertainty regarding the position of illegitimate children in obtaining inheritance rights from their biological fathers. This study aims to analyze the regulation of inheritance rights of illegitimate children from biological fathers based on the provisions of Indonesian positive law and examine the harmonization of these regulations from the perspective of the Marriage Law and the Compilation of Islamic Law. This study is a normative legal research using a statutory approach, a conceptual approach, and a case approach. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively through literature studies. The results of the study indicate that Constitutional Court Decision Number 46/PUU-VIII/2010 has expanded the civil relationship of illegitimate children with their biological fathers as long as it can be proven based on science and technology or other evidence according to law. However, the implementation of inheritance rights still faces obstacles due to the lack of harmony in the Compilation of Islamic Law. Therefore, regulatory harmonization is needed to ensure legal certainty, justice, and legal protection for the civil rights of illegitimate children.
LEGAL PROTECTION FOR COMPANIES HOLDING CERTIFICATES OF CULTIVATION RIGHTS Hapit Sugandi; Muh. Amin Saleh; Hotman Sinambela; Appe Hutauruk
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 1 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), October 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

The legal vulnerabilities faced by holders of Land Use Rights (HGU) certificates, particularly those related to the phenomenon of land occupation by third parties and administrative obstacles in renewing rights, have the potential to harm the investment climate. This study aims to analyze legal protection efforts for companies holding HGU certificates based on Law Number 5 of 1960 concerning Basic Agrarian Regulations (UUPA) and examine legal certainty in the process of extending HGU certificates to ensure investment sustainability. The research method used is normative legal research with a statutory approach and a case approach through an analysis of Case Decision Number 90/Pdt.G/2024/PN Kis. HGU certificates provide preventive legal protection as a strong means of evidence, but in practice, repressive protection still faces obstacles in execution and judges’ interpretation of the social function of land. Legal certainty in HGU extensions is a crucial pillar for the sustainability of corporate investment, where the state is obliged to guarantee the stability of land ownership for rights holders who have fulfilled their constitutional obligations. This study recommends the need for synchronization of land regulations to simplify the bureaucracy of land use rights renewal in order to minimize agrarian disputes in the future.
Co-Authors Abizar Algifari Adalin Ali Adalin Ali, Ade Rifa Salsabilla Adi Saputro Aditya Dwi Prasetyo Adzim Munawali Agus Setiyawan Agus Susetyo Akhmad Dinul Kholis Anwar Appe Hutauruk Apud Abdul Aziz Arief Prayoga Arief Widodo Aswin Suwardi Ayahandono Kussetyadi Baihaqi Ramadhan Benny Wijaya Biochandra Hutapea Boy Three Immanuel Hutasoit Buhit Christian Caesar Daffa Nugraha Cahyo Priyono Charles DL Pardede David Yuwono Dede Ardiansyah Denny Cahyadi Tiono Dimas Arifianto Suryo Edmon Derson Simamora Edy Surpiyanto Edy Susanto Erwin Hutasoit Faizal Imam Muharam Fakhry Rozi Mujoko Fauzi Fauzi Jamal Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean Fendy Hutahaean Filemon Gunawan Dirjanto Franky Bangkit Sumardi FX. Suyud Margono Gunawan Hadi Nugroho Gusthi Satya Kurniawan Hadi Wijaya Hapit Sugandi Harriani Bianca Daryana Hendry Maxi Kewas Hera Widjayanti Hermawan Wibisono Putra Heru Mario Hotma Mentalita Ida Ayu Asti Manuaba Intan Trisna Metiarni Iqba Alkholidi Ivana Barnesa Janti Saragih Jaozi Jasatua Jody Agy Napitupulu John Hendry Suryo Wibowo Jois Candra Panjaitan Jusak Budiman Soehardja Kefi Firdaus Thon Kencana Wulan Kharismawati Lamhot Hutahaean Lamhot Hutahaean Lasbok Marbun Lim Sang Hong M. Amin Saleh Mardiman Sane Maria Prihadiyanti Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean Mas Agus Priyambodo Maskur Muchamad Ariyanto Pradana Muhammad Amin Saleh Al-Habsy Muhammad Arafah Muhammad Nasir Muhenri Sihotang Muhenri Sihotang Muslih Anhar Mutia Sakti Najwa Aulia Ramadhani Natalia Vivi Natan, Antonius Nawang Kusuma Bastari Nico Wandiredja Nurkenda Panti Silaban Panti Silaban Purwanto Budi Santoso Raden Sihar Martogi Sinambela Raden Sihar Martogi Sinambela Rahmad David Djauhari Relita Hafsidiany Ricky Kurniawan Suriana Rifai Lumbantoruan Robert L Simanungkalit Robert L. Simanungkalit Rony Eli Hutahaean Ruby W H Oktolina Samosir Ruby W H Oktolina Samosir Rudyanto Dahlan Saifudin Wahid Selamat Rapama Sihombing Sendi Sanjaya Setia Jaya Siti Munawaroh Stanisius Leo Stenly Minti Sugi Hariyanto Suharyono Suhermi Suhermi Sularto Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Supadmi Sutarso Sutarso Suyud Margono Tatang Ruslih Tricia Elisabeth Napitupulu Widia Wirawan Yendrizen Yogi Fajran Qausar Yohanes Higayon Yulis Setyaningsih Yusuf Chornia Zul Ashari