Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Evaluating the Effectiveness of E-Learning Implementation in the Professional Teacher Education Program through the CIPPO Model Paat, Wensi R. L.; Katuuk, Deitje A.; Rawis, Joulanda A M; Lengkong, Jeffry Sony Junus; Umbase, Ruth
International Journal of Information Technology and Education Vol. 4 No. 4 (2025): September 2025
Publisher : JR Education

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

This study aims to evaluate the implementation of e-learning in the Professional Teacher Education Program (PPG) at Manado State University using the CIPPO evaluation model, which consists of Context, Input, Process, Product, and Outcome components. The rapid transition to digital learning environments in higher education requires systematic evaluation to ensure the effectiveness and sustainability of e-learning practices, particularly in teacher professional development programs. A mixed-method approach was employed, involving quantitative surveys and qualitative interviews with PPG students, lecturers, and program administrators. Data were collected through structured questionnaires, observation, and document analysis. The findings indicate that the context component demonstrates strong institutional support and policy alignment, while the input component reveals adequate infrastructure but limited digital pedagogical competencies among some instructors. The process evaluation highlights the need for more interactive instructional strategies and consistent learning management system utilization. Product evaluation shows positive student performance and engagement, although variations exist across courses. Outcome analysis suggests that e-learning contributes to improved professional competence, digital literacy, and learning flexibility. The study concludes that the CIPPO model provides a comprehensive framework for assessing e-learning implementation and identifying areas for continuous improvement. Recommendations include strengthening lecturer training, enhancing technological infrastructure, and developing standardized e-learning guidelines to optimize the quality of PPG e-learning programs.
Implementation of External Quality Assurance System in North Sulawesi E. Wawo, Merry; A.M. Rawis, Joulanda; A. Katuuk, Deitje; S. J. Lengkong, Jeffry
International Journal of Educational Research & Social Sciences Vol. 2 No. 3 (2021): June 2021
Publisher : CV. Inara

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.51601/ijersc.v2i3.94

Abstract

The role of external institutions in education quality assurance is very important in the External Quality Assurance System (SPME). This research is about the Implementation of Education Quality Assurance in North Sulawesi especially at Bitung City and Tomohon City. This research was conducted on planning the quality of education, quality of education, and evaluation of the quality of education in the Department of Education and Culture of Bitung City and Tomohon City. The research problems are: 1) How is the quality of education planning in Bitung City and Tomohon City?; and2) How is the implementation of the quality of education in Bitung City and Tomohon City?.This study used a qualitative approach with descriptive methods designed for a multi-site study design. Data were collected through observation, interviews and documentation. The data analysis used includes simultaneous process flow of activities, namely data reduction, data presentation, and conclusions.The results of this study indicate that: 1) Education quality planning in Bitung City and Tomohon city is carried out through joint meetings to focus more on program activities and strengthen appropriate and targeted activity programs. Planning for quality fulfillment in Bitung City is the result of recommendations for improvement from quality mapping activities, namely quality data analysis, namely standards, recommendations for improvement, volume, funding requirements. Quality planning in Tomohon City is carried out by implementing the implementation steps of the preparation of a quality fulfillment plan within the Tomohon City Education and Culture Office carried out by forming a regional education quality assurance team (TPMPD).2) Implementation of Education Quality Fulfillment in Bitung City is focused on process standards, facilities and infrastructure standards and educator standards. This is adjusted to the conditions during the COVID-19 pandemic. Teacher Competency Improvement Program, namely activities carried out in the form of Distance Learning (PJJ) socialization, RPP Simplification Workshop, and Basic Competency Analysis. The implementation of quality fulfillment is carried out online and face-to-face for certain areas that are difficult to connect to the internet by paying attention to health protocols.
Co-Authors A.M. Rawis, Joulanda Achmad Paturusi Agnes M. Rumagit Allan Giovani Gigir Ariel N. Rengkuan Ariestyawan, I Made Devastha Arje Cerullo Djamen Christar Arstilo Rumbay Christine Rawis Davison Pagawak Debie Kalalo Deddy F. Kumolontang Delli Sabudu Deysti Trifena Tarusu Donal Mateos Ratu Dondokambey, Robby E. Wawo, Merry Elni Usoh Eunike G.M. Mangundap Felicita, Bella Freida F Masoko Gerick, Steven Gilly Marlya Tiwow Gloridei Lingkanbene Kapahang Hadi Ignatius Untu Hartini Ngadiorejo Heinrich Saneba Hendrie Joudi Palar Ignatius Javier C. Tuerah Jeanne M. Mangangantung Jeffry Sony Junus Lengkong Johan Reimon Batmetan Jonathan Deske Solang Joulanda A. M. Rawis Kalalo, Debie K.R Kaparang, Maria Wihelmina Kapoh, Timothy Waraney Kaunang, Sinta E. J. Ketsia Zeke Koessoy, Herman Koessoy, Herman M. Koleangan, Christoforus Adri Pieter Kowal, Marsela Vera Krety Debora Welong Lando E. Sumarauw Lapian, Jeff Larry J. Mandey Liode, Lily Lola, Marjuni Tiku Lolong, Rima F. Lord Ebe Steward Lovihan, Mike A. K. Lumapouw, Harold Refly Lusia Sumenda1 Lydia Ivana Kumajas Majaan, Telly Mamahit , Engelbert A. Ch. Mamuaja, Marlin Penina Mamuaja, Pricilia P Manansang, Denny Manengkei, Steven Bons Manueke, Teddy Maria R. Walukow Marshela - Pondaag Marsumi, Marsumi Marthinus Krowin Masinambow, Christo J. R. Mercy Hosang Meytha Meyske Wongkar Michella Supit Mongdong, Romi J. Munir, Suldin Narosaputra, Dewo A. N. Natalya Tirsa Mokorowu Nikolas Fajar Wuryaningrat Non Norma Monigir Nur Afny Sumaa Paat, Wensi R. L. Palandeng, Rian W. Pali, Nathaniel E. Prycilia Pingkan Mamuaja Punuh, Grace Rahardjo, Ryan T. Rawis, Joulanda A M Refien K. S Rawung Resina Dintje Kaunang Richard Daniel Herdy Pangkey Rima Fien Lolong Rinny Meilani Tinangon Rotty, Viktory Nicodemus Joufree Rotua Hutagalung Rumagit, Selvie Serly Ruth Sriana Umbase Ruth Umbase S. J. Lengkong, Jeffry Samuel Harry Mossey Shelty D. M. Sumual Silow, Jimmy Clif Singal, Cicilia Indry Sjamsi Pasandaran Sumilat, Margareta O. Suprapto, Denny U. Tini Mogea Tinneke Evie Meggy Sumual Tresia Cornella Kalangie Tumakaka, Ria Angelia Victory Nicodemus Joufree Rotty Vidlina Lie Virginia H Saneba Wakerkwa, Tori Walewangko, Stief Aristo Watulingas, Marcia Imelda Widdy Harce Frans Rorimlpandey Widdy Rorimpandey Willem Hanny Rawung Yean M V Rasu Yeane Koyongian