Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Comparative Diagnostic Accuracy of the STUMBL (Battle) Score and Chest Trauma Score for Predicting In-Hospital Mortality in Adult Blunt Thoracic Trauma: An Age-Stratified STARD-Compliant Study at an Indonesian Tertiary Referral Center Yoshua Ramothy Siahaan; Arie Hasiholan Lumban Tobing; Theodorus
Sriwijaya Journal of Surgery Vol. 10 No. 1 (2026): Sriwijaya Journal of Surgery - Issue in Progress
Publisher : HM Publisher

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.37275/sjs.v10i1.182

Abstract

Background: The Chest Trauma Score (CTS) evaluates anatomical injury, whereas the STUMBL (Battle) score also incorporates physiological and comorbidity parameters. Objective: To compare their accuracy for predicting in-hospital mortality in adults with blunt thoracic trauma. Methods: This retrospective study included 106 adults hospitalized at Dr. Mohammad Hoesin Hospital, Indonesia, from January 2024 to September 2026. Admission scores were evaluated using receiver operating characteristic curves, Youden thresholds, and age-stratified analyses (18–60 versus >60 years). Results: Thirteen patients (12.3%) died. Non-survivors had higher median CTS (6.00 versus 4.00) and mean STUMBL scores (28.77 versus 14.89; both p < 0.001). STUMBL had an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.974 and CTS an AUC of 0.966 (pairwise p = 0.546). At thresholds of ≥25 and ≥6, respectively, sensitivity was 92.31% for both scores. Specificity was 91.40% versus 90.32%, positive predictive value was 60.00% versus 57.14%, negative predictive value was 98.84% versus 98.82%, and accuracy was 91.51% versus 90.57%. Among adults aged >60 years (n = 23), STUMBL ≥28 had specificity of 95.00%, compared with 75.00% for CTS ≥6; sensitivity was 100.00% for both. Conclusion: Both scores showed excellent mortality discrimination in this cohort. STUMBL had numerically higher specificity in older adults; prospective validation is needed.
Co-Authors Abda Arif Abrar Arbhiwa Tanguirsyaf Siregar Abu Bakar Lutfi Adenan Abadi Adenan Abadi admin Adnan Abadi Asnawi Adnan Abadi, Adnan Afifa Ramadanti Afladhanti, Putri Mahirah Agustina Br. Haloho Agustinus William Agustria Z. Saleh Alfajri Amarel, Fahma Alfarizqy Amir Fauzi Amirah Novaliani Anak Agung Gede Sugianthara Andriani, R.A. Linda Andriansyah, Yulius Andrina, Hana Angelica, Ellen Callista Anugrah Onie Arie Hasiholan Lumban Tobing Aura Salsabilla Putri Awan Nurtjahyo Awan Nurtjahyo Azhar Susanto Azhari Azhari Azhari Rozali B, Firmansyah Benedictus Wicaksono Widodo Bernolian, N Bernolian, N Billy Sujatmiko D Saputra, Akbar N D.Y. Riyanto, D.Y. Dahler Bahrun Dandi, Dandi Daniatiek, Soneta Dastamuar, Shalita Debby Handayani Harahap Debby Handayati Harahap Devy Octarina Ditto Ruldifar Pribadi Doni Kurniawan Dwi Tantri Marylin Elvi Widiastuti Elza Iskandar, Elza Esterani, Esterani Evi Lusiana F, Amir Fahma Alfarizqy Amarel Fakhrudit, Emir Fauzit, Amir Fedriyansyah Fedriyansyah Feizal Faturahman Ferdi, Roni Ferry Yusrizal Firmansyah Basir Fita Asfianti Forbes, Darlin Gita Dwi Prasasty H.M. Nazir H.M. Nazir Hamzah, Haidar Ali Harahap, Debby Handayani Hartanto, Kristian S Heriansyah, Jhon Hidayat, Syarief Taufik Hilmawan, Bagus HM Nazir Hz Ika Kartika Ilham Taufan Ikramiawan Indira, Tissa Ismail Bastomi, Ismail Julius Anzar Kamaluddin Kamaluddin Kamaluddin, MT Kamaluddin, MT Khrismawan Khrismawan Kms Yusuf Effendi Kms Yusuf Effendy kurniati, nova Kusuma Harimin Leni Wijaya, Leni Lestari, Mayang Indah Lorenza, Geofanny Lutfi, Abu Bakar M Kamaluddin M. T. Kamaluddin Mahacakri, Eke P Mahadika, Febrinata Manan, Heriyadi Marta Hendry, Marta Martadiansyah, Abarham Maulani, H Maulani, H Maulani, Henni Mgs. Irsan Saleh, Mgs. Irsan Mgs. M. Irsan Saleh Muhammad Faisal Muhammad Hafidh Komar Muhammad Irsan Saleh Muhammad Rizqi Firyal Muhammad Totong Kamaluddin Mulawan Umar Mulawan Umar Muzakkie Muzakkie, Muzakkie Nadhif, Aufa Muhammad Nadira Rifda Utami Nita Parisa Nopriansyah Darwin Novianesari, Putri H Novianty, Novianty Nugraha, M Daffa Nugroho, Achmadi S Nur Qodir Nurul Islamy Nuswil Bernolian Nyiayu Fauziah Kurniawati Octarina, Bertha Oktariana, Desi Pangemanan, W T Pangemanan, W T Pangemanan, Wim T PATIYUS AGUSTIANSYAH, PATIYUS Puspita, Yusni Putri Mirani Putri, Safa Nabila Raden Ayu Kusuma Andini Rafiyandi Rafiyandi Rahima Rahima Renny Apliza Nasution Resiana Resiana Resti Resti Riani Erna, Riani Rika Saputri Rini Purnamasari Risa Vera Rizal Sanif Rizani Amran Rogatianus Bagus Pratignyo Romadhan, Muhammad Despriansyah Rose Mafiana Rostika Flora Rostika Flora Rusydi, Syakroni D Sabrina, Tia Sahab, Abdullah Saleh, Masagus Irsan Salim, Eddy M Salni Sari Octarina Piko Sastradinata, Irawan Shaleh, Agustria Z Silvana, Rista Silvia Triratna Siti Rusdiana Puspa Dewi Sonlimar mangunsong Stevanny, Bella Sudarto Sudarto Sujatmiko, Billy Sulbahri, Robby P. Suriani Rosida Sutomo Tanzil Syakirah, Fatimah Syarif Husin Syarif Husin Syarinta Adenina Tahany, Hanifah Tanzil, Sutomo Tindar, Mirzah Tissa Indira Tribowo, Anang Trijoso Permono Usman, Fatimah Vandy Ikra Veronita Veronita Veronita, Veronita Wahyu Pranata, Wahyu Pranata Weldy, Weldy Yohanes Febrianto Yoshua Ramothy Siahaan Yulia Iriani, Yulia Yuliana Yuliana Yundari, Yundari Yuniza, Yuniza Yusuf, Kemas Zainal, Rizal Zanaria, Rima Zulkifli Zulkifli