Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Constructivist Pedagogies And Critical Literacy: Contrasting Problem-Based And Project-Based Learning Outcomes Among Pre-Service Indonesian Language Teachers. Abdul Munir; Muh. Arief Muhsin; Erwin Akib; Yulis Sitiowati
Journal of Educational Studies Vol. 4 No. 3 (2026): October
Publisher : Lembaga Bale Literasi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.58218/jes.v4i3.3727

Abstract

The main purpose of this study is to compare the implementation of the Problem Based Learning (PBL) and Project Based Learning (PjBL) model on the critical literacy skills of students of the Indonesian Language and Literature Education Study Program. The research design applied was quasi-experimental with a pretest-posttest control group design. The research sample was 64 students divided into two classes, each class consisted of 32 people. The data was collected through a critical literacy test that had been validated by experts, then analyzed using an independent t-test at a significance level of 0.05 and N-Gain calculation to assess the effectiveness of each model. The results of the study showed that both models had a significant effect on improving students' critical literacy skills; The PBL group experienced an average increase of 15.63 points, while the PjBL group increased even higher, namely 22.06 points. The results of the N-Gain distribution analysis concluded that PjBL not only increases critical literacy skills higher, but is also more consistent with student activities. These findings imply that the integration of the PjBL model in Indonesian language learning needs to receive more attention in the development of higher education curriculum to support more optimal critical literacy mastery.
Co-Authors A, Ruslina A.Amran Asriadi Abd Kadir Hakim Abdul Munir AdhyPutra, Achmad Pangeran Ahmad, Jamilah binti Aida Azis, Sitti Andi Aswani Andi Tenri Ampa Andi Tenri Ampa Andriani Anggy Giri Prawiyogi Ariana Askin, Amelia Asriadi, A.Amran Asriadi, Amran Asrianto Setiadi, Muhammad Astuty Ar, Aprilyanti Widya Ayu Erianti Ayyub B Azis, Awalia Bahrun Amin Bahrun Amin Dedi Setiawan Farisha Andi Baso Fitrah Rachmadani Ghaffar, Mohd. Najib bin Abdul Hadrawi Hakim, Patahuddin Hambali, Uyunnasirah Hamma, Syah Ibi Handayani, Yulmi Hanisa Masuku Haslinda Haslinda, Haslinda Hasmila Hasmin, Fauzia Herlina, Rika Hermanto Hermanto Iin Dwi Aristy Putri Inayah , Nurahdatul Irawati Amir Irfan Supriatna Ismail, Hamid Ismawati Ismawati Junaid Junaid Ma'ruf, Amar Maharida Mannong, Andi Bulkis Maghfirah Martuty, Arie Mega Fatimah Rosana Mirfan MT. Hartono Ikhsan Muhammad Akhir Muhammad Akhir Muhammad Astrianto Setiadi, Muhammad Astrianto Muhammad Erwinto Imran Muhammad Rifqi Mahmud Muhammad Yaumi Muhammad Zia ul Haq Muhsin, Muh Arief Muhsin, Muhammad Arief Mukhsinah Mukhsinah Munirah Kusnadi, Munirah Munirah Munirah Munirah Munirah Muryono Musmita, Musmita Muthia Mutmainnah Darmuh Nasrullah A Nita S Noni, Nurdin Nur Rahmi Ratmeilia Nurlina Nurlina Nursalam Nursalam NURUL HIDAYAH Nurul Hidayah Quaraisy, Hidayah Rahman, Fikri Abdu Rasyid, Richa Yunita Ratu Yulianti Natsir, Ratu Yulianti Rina Asrini Bakri Rosmaladewi Rukli Rukli Rum, Eka Prabawati Sadriana Ayu Saiful Saiful Saiful Saiful Saiyidah Mahtari Satriana, Eny Selvi Selvi Sitti Aida Azis Sitti Aida Azis, Sitti Aida Sri Damayanti Sri Wahyuni Sudiarna Ningsih Sujariati Sukarwati, Nasrah Suparmin Suparmin Syah Ibi Hamma Syahruni Hambali Syam, Andi Multa Syamsiarna Nappu Syamsiarna Nappu, Syamsiarna Syatriana, Eny Syawal, Syawal Talis, Sri Sherli Novianti Tarman A. Arif Valeryevna, Petrosyan Nelya Wildhan Burhanuddin Yulis Sitiowati Zukhraeni Zukhraeni