Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Redefining Medieval Balaghah Epistemology: Theoretical Transformations In The Syarah and Hasyiyah Traditions Milah, Aang Saeful; Sulistiani, Sulistiani; Husaeni, Uum Umaroh; Mugiroh, Mugiroh; Ramadhan, Insan
JURNAL IJ-ATL Vol 10, No 1 (2026): Arabic Teaching and Learning
Publisher : Nurul Jadid University

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.33650/ijatl.v10i1.13656

Abstract

This study reconstructs the epistemology of medieval Balaghah. Its aim is to deconstruct the Western-centric narrative that labels the era of commentary (commentary tradition) as a phase of intellectual decline (‘ashr al-inhithath). Specifically, this study maps the theoretical transformations in three branches of Balaghah resulting from the integration of formal logic (manthiq). The method used is qualitative with a historical-philosophical approach. The researcher applies Michel Foucault’s theory of the archaeology of knowledge to analyze the corpus of primary texts (turats), ranging from the works of Al-Sakkaki (d. 626 AH), Al-Qazwini (d. 739 AH), to the authoritative commentaries by Al-Taftazani (d. 793 AH) and Al-Jurjani al-Syarif (d. 816 AH). Analysis of six cross-cluster cases reveals a robust conceptual refinement. The Syarah and Hasyiyah traditions are shown to operate as independent internal critical ecosystems through the "wa fihi nazhar" method. The integration of syllogism successfully transformed the concept of rhetoric originally subjective and based on linguistic taste (al-dzauq) into deterministic-universal linguistic rules. This is evident in the formalization of the cognitive conditions of Kalam Insya’ and the tightening of the criteria for Qarinah at the level of rational-certain clarity (al-zhuhur al-'aqli). The theoretical implications of this research call for a historiographical repositioning to dismantle the dichotomy between the literary (adabi) and logical ('ilmi) approaches. Practically, this research recommends reforming the global Arabic rhetoric curriculum to appreciate traditional commentarial texts as the pinnacle of logical-linguistic intelligence.
Co-Authors Aang Saeful Milah Abdennasser, Dahmani Abdul Choliq Abinawanto Achmad Dinoto Adi Putra, Deni Adzidzah, Herlingga Zahra Nurul AERMA HASTUTY Ahmad Munawar Aini, Ajeng Nur Albert Albert Alfarizi, Aldi Amalia, Vidia Rizki Amanda, Nifsa Riski Aminuddin Prahatama Putra Andestar, Tomi Andi Salamah Arifin, Azis Asro Laelani Indrayanti Chandrawijaya, Novita Cindya Alfi Dedy Ari Nugroho Dita Kusuma Wardani Dwi Hilda Putri Eka Wulandari Endang Sukara Fatih, Mohammad Fauziah, Riska Fitriani, Mahmudah Nur Furqon, Faqih Nurmaulana Hakim, Akhmad Nur Haryadi, Nicko Haryanto , Haryanto Hasanah, Rakyatul Hasanah, Zakiyah Hayati, Syifa Nidaul Hendriansyah, Weko Herlyaminda, Evi Hery Fajeriadi Husaeni, Uum Umaroh I Wayan Karta Idaul Hasanah Iratutisisilia, Iratutisisilia Irmayani, Ari Ismawati Ismawati Juherna, Erna Karona Cahya Susena Kartimi Kartimi Khusniati, Tatik Khusniati, Tatik Kurniawan, Ryan Feryana Linden, Susana Maharani, Nyimas Desinta Aish Mahmun, Mahmun Manya, Manya MARIA BINTANG Mariatul Kiptiah Marissa, Novaria Marsanda, Marsanda Masrah Masrah Mawaddah, Nada Meutia, Rita Mugiroh, Mugiroh Muh Taufik Muhammad Alif muhammad Anwar Sani Muhammad Ardiansyah Muhammad Zaini Nadiya, Zulfa Nanta, Dhea Loka Nina Nina Novita Sari Nurhikmayani, Nurhikmayani Nurholifah, Nurholifah Nurillahi Febria Leswana Nurmiati Nurmiati Nurmina Nurmina, Nurmina Nursilah Nursilah NURUL HIDAYAH Pitriyani Pitriyani Pribowo, Fitroh Setyo Putro Prihantini, Nur Nunu Putra, Iswidana Utama Rachmat Fajar Lubis Rahman, Erpi Ramadhan, Insan Regita, Liya Ruslaini, Ruslaini Sadewo, Panji Sahni Putri, Rini Sahrir, Dede Cahyati Salamudin, Ceceng Santikayasa, I Putu Saputra, Waldi Saraswati, Dahniar Sena, Hendrikus Septriani, Meti Setyo Eko Atmojo Sharkawy, Abdel Nasser Soeka, Yati Sodaryati Solihat, Melisa Sri Amintarti Suharno Suharno Sunengsih, Ucu Surianti Surianti, Surianti Suwarni Suwarni Syahri Ramadhan, Syahri Tampubolon, Rines Onyxi Tawakal, Anzori Tito Irwanto Tulaili, Nur Alfia Usniati, Ina Vitria, Rina Nur Wahyudi, Sampirman WIBOWO MANGUNWARDOYO Wijaya, Setiawan Ardi Yati Sudaryati Soeka Yoga Wica, Pratama Yustha, Yulia Zein, Nadia Sofia