Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

EPISTEMOLOGI KONTEKSTUAL DAN TEKSTUAL: TAFSIR WAHBAH AL- ZUHAILI DAN SAYYID QUTB TERHADAP AL-MAIDAH 44, 45, 47 Muhamad Hamdan Tauviqillaah; Edi Komarudin; Wildan Taufik
MUSHAF JOURNAL: Jurnal Ilmu Al Quran dan Hadis Vol. 4 No. 3 (2025): MUSHAF JOURNAL : Jurnal Ilmu Al Quran dan Hadis
Publisher : CV. Adiba Aisha Amira

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar

Abstract

This article aims to study, identify, and compare the epistemology of contextual and textual interpretation of Wahbah Al-Zuhaili and Sayyid in interpreting Surah Al-Ma>’idah verses 44, 45, and 47. This research is qualitative with a comparative analysis method based on library research. The results of this study indicate that Al-Zuhaili interpreted the verses contextually without absolutely justifying infidels by applying specific khit}a>b targets and detailing the context of the infidel status, so that his views are flexible by prioritizing the realization of maqa>s}id al-shari>’ah. Al-Zuhaili's interpretation is based on sources and methods of interpretation that integrate al- ma’thur>r and al-ma’qu>l guided by the analysis of narrations, opinions of companions, and tabi’in, aspects of Islamic knowledge, and opinions of scholars and interpreters. Meanwhile, Sayyid Qutb's interpretation is textual by universalizing the status of kafir for anyone who does not rule by Allah's law, anytime and anywhere. Qutb's interpretation is based on the integration of history and reason with an emphasis on the goals of ideology within the framework of al-tas}awwur al-islam>mi> with an approach to analysis of history, muna>sabah, and reflection on reality. The similarity between the two is that both uphold the authority of history and believe that Allah is the main source of law in all aspects of life and those who deny Him doctrinally (belief) are included as kafir.
Co-Authors adhia nugraha Ahmad Aqiel Azkiya’ Ahmad Asep Fathurrohman Ahmad, Nurwadjah Akhmad Sobarna Alijaya, Adudin Ananda Rizky Maulana Apriani, Laelati Dwina Aryanto, Redi Asep Ahmad Fathurrohman Asep Ahmad Fathurrohman Baehaqi Dayudin, Dayudin Dedi Junaedi Dedi Supriadi Dedi Supriadi Deuis Sugaryamah, Deuis Dyan Fachri Maulana Fangesty, Maolidya Asri Siwi Fathurrohman, Asep Ahmad Fatimah, Nisa Fitri Meliani, Fitri Fitriana Lubis, Mumun Fitriansyah, Muhammad Bayu Fuad Salim Habibah Hidayah, Asep Taopik Ice Sariyati Ihin Solihin Ilma Amalia Ilma Amalia, Ilma Imam, Jahira Salsabila Nurul Irfan Nurzaman Jahira Salsabila Nurul Imam Jajang A Rohmana Kafiyah, Fitroh Ni'matul Kafiyah, Fitroh Ni’matul Kodir, Abdul - Kusuma, Dwiki Laelani, Lilih Lu'lu Abdullah Afifi Maolidya Asri Siwi Fangesty Maulana, Aldi Rifki Mohammad Irfan Farraz Haecal Muh. Asriadi AM Muhamad Hamdan Tauviqillaah Muhamad Hamdan Tauviqillaah Muhamad Khabib Imdad Muhamad Yoga Firdaus Muhamamd Nurhasan Muhammad Abdul Aziz Muhammad Arif Muhammad Bayu Fitriansyah Muhammad Hasan Ali Muhammad Nur Hidayat Muhammad Nurhasan Muhammad Rijal Maulana Muhammad Yahya Muhammad Yahya Munawar, Zacky Yudin Nida Husna Abdul Malik Nisa Fatimah Nur Afiffah, Syifa Nurdin, Aldi Nurhayat, Tasya Putri Nursidik, Ihsan Purwa, Dyas Rahayu, Tami Dewi Puspa Ramadhan Syaeful Bahri Revky Oktavian Sakti Riyani, Irma Rizal, Rony Muhammad Rizki Maulana Putra Rohanda Rohanda Safrudin, Ramadhan Salsabila, Syifa Satia SAPTANADI YUDISTIRA Sholikul Hadi Siti Nurhaliza Sudjatnika, Tenny Suryana Alfathah Syam, Ishmatul Karimah Syawaluddin, Fauzan Akbar Syifa Satia Salsabila Tarek Yalouli Taufik, Wildan Taufiq, Wildan Wahyuni, Neneng Sri Wildan Taufik Wildan Taufik Wildan Taufiq Yadi Mardiansyah Yusanti, Noviana Zikro Elok Al Faein Zulaiha, Eni