p-Index From 2021 - 2026
9.318
P-Index
This Author published in this journals
All Journal Jurnal Peternakan Sriwijaya Jurnal Ilmu dan Industri Peternakan Teknosains: Media Informasi Sains dan Teknologi Jurnal Sain Peternakan Indonesia JITRO (Jurnal Ilmiah dan Teknologi Peternakan Tropis) Jurnal Sains dan Teknologi Pangan Numeracy : Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika Pendas : Jurnah Ilmiah Pendidikan Dasar Jurnal Peternakan (Jurnal of Animal Science) Unes Law Review Jambura Journal of Animal Science Jurnal Dedikasi Pendidikan JITPI : Jurnal Ilmu Dan Teknologi Peternakan Indonesia (Indonesian Journal of Animal Science and Technology) Al-Fatih: Jurnal Pendidikan dan Keislaman Jurnal Ilmu Sosial Politik dan Humaniora (Jisora) JATI EMAS (Jurnal Aplikasi Teknik dan Pengabdian Masyarakat) Jurnal Ilmu Peternakan Terapan Jurnal Nutrisi Ternak Tropis (JNT) Jurnal Syntax Imperatif : Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Pendidikan Jambura Geo Education Journal REKA ELKOMIKA: Jurnal Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat Wahana Peternakan Jurnal Nukleus Peternakan DEDIKASI PKM Jurnal Alwatzikhoebillah : Kajian Islam, Pendidikan, Ekonomi, Humaniora Jurnal Peternakan Lokal Tarjih Tropical Livestock Journal Journal of Education Research Educenter: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Jurnal Iman dan Spiritualitas Social Pedagogy: Journal of Social Science Education Journal of Educational Sciences Anoa: Journal of Animal Husbandry Sejahtera: Jurnal Inspirasi Mengabdi Untuk Negeri EINSTEIN (E-JOURNAL) JAS (Journal of Animal Science) KHIDMAH: Jurnal Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat Al Maqashidi : Jurnal Hukum Islam Nusantara Chalaza Journal of Animal Husbandry Journal of Livestock and Animal Health (JLAH) Journal of Public Power Nusantara Community Empowerment Review Riset Ilmu Manajemen Bisnis dan Akuntansi Jurnal Ekonomi dan Bisnis Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat dan Riset Pendidikan EDUCENTER JURNAL PENDIDIKAN Jurnal Studi Islam dan Sosial PESHUM Journal of Public Scientific Contributions Oil and Gas
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

KOMPARASI TAFSIR AL-MANAR DAN TAFSIR AL-MARAGHI STUDI CORAK ADABI IJTIMA’I DALAM MERESPONS MODERNITAS Hidayat, Muhammad Nur; Fathurrohman, Asep Ahmad; Komarudin, Edi
Lisyabab : Jurnal Studi Islam dan Sosial Vol 6 No 2 (2025): Lisyabab, Jurnal Studi Islam dan Sosial
Publisher : Lembaga Penelitian dan Pengabdian Masyarakat (LPPM) Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam Mulia Astuti (STAIMAS) Wonogiri

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.58326/jurnallisyabab.v6i2.467

Abstract

This study conducts a critical-comparative analysis of Tafsir Al-Manar and Tafsir Al-Maraghi, both of which share the Adabi Ijtima'i (Social-Cultural) style, to uncover the root cause of their differences ('illat al-ikhtilaf) in responding to modernity. Using a qualitative approach with the muqāranah (comparative) method and content analysis, this research examines methodological aspects and substantive interpretations of three key verses: Q.S. Yunus [10]: 100 (reason), Q.S. An-Nisa' [4]: 59 (politics), and Q.S. An-Nisa' [4]: 34 (family). The findings reveal that despite sharing a basic style, the two commentaries exhibit systematic divergence. Al-Manar, dominated by bil ra'yi (70%) and an Islahi-Siyasi (Reformist-Political) tendency, produces transformative and polemical responses. In contrast, Al-Maraghi, dominated by bil ma'tsur (60%) and a Tarbawi-Ilmi (Educational-Scientific) tendency, produces stabilizing-educative responses. This study concludes that the primary 'illat al-ikhtilaf lies in the interaction between the Tsaqofah al-Mufassirin (the intellectual-institutional framework of the exegetes) and their historical context. Al-Manar, a product of Salafi-Activist Tsaqofah in the Early Modern era, advocates for transformative-political tajdid (renewal). Meanwhile, Al-Maraghi, a product of Azhari-Institutional Tsaqofah in the Middle Modern era, advocates for stabilizing-educative tajdid. Thus, this study not only maps the differences but also contributes to the science of tafsir by introducing Tsaqofah al-Mufassirin as an analytical framework and two models of renewal (tajdid) born from the Adabi Ijtima'i style.
Co-Authors A. L. Tolleng A. Sriyanti, A. Abd. Fadlan Abdul Hakim Fattah Adik Diniarsih Razak Adrian Lewer Ahmad Ahmad Ahmad Alim Akhmad Arista Al'Ghani, Muhammad Zulfi Al-Amanah, Nisa Alfawzi, Muhammad Irvan Amaliya, Jessika Ambar Syafirlah Azzara Amelinda Amda Dwiputri Amin, Badaruddin Amina Hajah Thaha Amriana Hifizah Anam, Muhammad Choirul Anas Qurniawan Andi Akbar Andi Akbar, Andi Andi Darul Aqsa Andi Ika Prasasti Abrar, Andi Ika Prasasti Andi Kusumayanti, Andi Andi Suarda Andi Suarda Andrian Aziz Burhan A.S Aprisilawati, Meta Arent, Ease Arga Arya Acmadi Awal Asep Anang Asgaf, Khaifah Astati Aulia Putra, Mufti Reza Ayu Lestari AYU LESTARI Azzahra, Karimah Bachruddin Baharuddin Abbas, Baharuddin Bashar Nur Takbir Cinta Rahmi Dewi Resfita Sari Dian Setyawati Mansur Diena Koesmini, Aestien DWP, Ida Aryati Dzul Fadhli Aziz Effendi Abustam Effendi Abustam Eka Fitriani Ekasuci, Zahra Fadilla Endah Wahyuningsih Endah Wahyuningsih Endramawan, Tito Ersis Warmansyah Abbas Ervandi, Mohamad Fadliah. H. Al-Habsy Faradila, Rista Fathurrohman, Asep Ahmad Fayza, Ayu Nur Felis Gunawan Fiorenza Vania Seubelan Fiqri Wijaya Firna Sofia Hairunnisa Handayani Indah Susanti Hanif, Raihan Hardiyansya Hardiyansya Haria Saputri Hawa Minriyadhil Jannah Hazar, Badrizal Al Hendra Candra Huda, Hisbulloh Ibrahim Ichsan Nur Halim Imran, Nur Azisyah Inayatil Maula, Qurratu Indah Dwi Prafitasari Irma Isnafia Arief Irmawaty Irmawaty Irmawaty, Irmawaty Ismawati Asmar Isnaini Muharrifah Isra Mirawati Joned C. Saksana Jumriah Syam, Jumriah Syam Khaerani Kiramang Khaifah khaifah Kresti, Fransisca Estriani Novita Kurniati Kurniati Kurniati Kurniati Laily Agustina, Laily Laksono Trisnantoro Leo Van Gunawan Ludviyah, Ika Putri M. Arief Noor M. Ridha Ilhami Mappanganro, Rasyidah Mashuri Masri Masnaeni Masnaeni, Masnaeni Mauliddiyah, Mifta Ayu Minhajuddin Madi Mkumbachi, Ramadhani Lausi Mochammad Burhanuddin Muh. Daud Muh. Rafli Muh. Rajabatari Gau Muhamad Ghozali, Muhamad Muhammad Arsan Jamili Muhammad Basri Muhammad Basri Muhammad Rizki Muhammad Said Muhammad, Rusny Mukari Muslimin, Ikhwannul Mutmainna, Andi Nabila Soraya Nabilla Akmas Nafisah, Khudrotun Naharuddin SR Ningsih, Sri Wahyu Nugroho, Alka Adi Nur Alam Nur Azmi Nurhayati Nurhayati Nurul Hidayat Nurwahidah J Paduloh Paduloh Pamungkas, Mada Widian Parawansa, Monalisa Indah Piara, Muhrajan Pratama, Muhammad Iksan Bima Aria Purnamasari, Ramdhani Putra, Reyza Fachrezy Putri Septia Ningsih, Adinda Putry, Epy Dwiyanti Qurrotu’aini, Nafia Ilhama R. Edi Komarudin Rahmadina, Angieta Rahman, Azis Rahmi Rahmi Ramelan, Agus Reny Mayanti Restanti, Arlinda Dwi Robbani, Mochammad Burhanuddin Rosliana Rosliana Rosnita RR. Ella Evrita Hestiandari Rusli Rusli Rusny Rusny Rusny Sadiah Alhaddar Sajili, Hasan Siti Julia Siti Rahmaniah Sitohang, Mostars Mathew Iglesias Solikhah, Yuliana Ayunta Sri Purwanti Subata, Imam Suci Ananda Sudarmin Supawi Pawenang Supraptini Syamsuddin Nompo, Syamsuddin Tuti Widjastuti Wahyuni Wulandari Wandasari, Erda winsyahputra Ritonga Yasir Rumuar Yulianingsih, Yulianingsih Yusnadia Achda Saputri Zheyla Novena Rony Zulaiha, Eni