Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Health Security Policies: A Comparative Study Through Constitutional Frameworks and the Insights of Veronica Rodriguez-Blanco Budiono, Arief; Gulyamov, Said Saidakhrarovich; Nugroho, Heru Santoso Wahito; Al Mamun, Abdullah; Mustaffa, Aminuddin
Volksgeist: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum dan Konstitusi Vol. 8 Issue 2 (2025) Volksgeist: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum Dan Konstitusi
Publisher : Faculty of Sharia, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Profesor Kiai Haji Saifuddin Zuhri Purwokerto, Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.24090/volksgeist.v8i2.10524

Abstract

In Indonesia, the 1945 Constitution mandates the establishment of health social security. Similarly, Section 15 of Article II of the Philippines’ 1987 Constitution asserts that the state has a duty to protect and promote the right to health for its citizens. Bangladesh’s Constitution, while not explicit, recognizes healthcare as a fundamental human right under Articles 15 (which addresses the provision of basic necessities) and 18 (which pertains to public health). Through a classic socio-dogmatic research method—a type of normative legal research—this study interprets how these constitutional provisions are implemented in practice. While Indonesia’s constitution clearloy requires the state to ensure health security, the government often falls short, lacking sufficient financial supports. In the Philippines, health security initiatives are gradually expanding but also suffer from inadequate funding. In contrast, Bangladesh has not prioritized health security, focusing instead on food security without emphasizing health as a state responsibility. Applying Rodriguez-Blanco’s theory reveals that Indonesia’s approach to social security leans towards an insurance model due to its reluctance to allocate adequate funds. In the Philippines, there is progress, albeit slow and underfund, while Bangladesh’s lack of health security development stems from its prioritization of basic food needs over health provisions.
Co-Authors Abdul Ganing Abdul Latif Abdullah Al Mamun Abdullah Al Mamun Abdullah Al Mamun Achmad Gatot Sunariyanto Acob, Joel Rey Ugsang Agus Sarwo Prayogi Ah Yusuf Ainur & Moch.Achwandi, Ika Al Mamun, Abdullah Alfian Helmi Ambo Dale Ambo Dalle Aminuddin Angelito E Alvarado Angelito E Alvarado, Angelito E Angelito E. Alvarado Angelito E. Alvarado Angelito E. Alvarado Anik Tri Haryani Arief Budiono Aries Prasetyo Aris Handayani Astin Nur Hanifah Astuti Setiyani, Astuti Athayalillah, Armedya Labiba Atik Badi'ah Atik Badi'ah Atik Badi'ah Atik Badi'ah Atik Badiah Atik Badi’ah AUTA, Tanko Titus Azwarni Azwarni A`im Matun Nadhiroh Badi'ah, Atik Baharuddin Bahtiar Bahtiar Bahtiar Bahtiar Bahtiar Bahtiar Bahtiar Bahtiar Bambang Hadi Sugito Bondan Palestin Bringiwatty Batbual Budi Santoso Budi Susatia Chitya Widya Ayu Raswati Desita Cut Aja Nuraskin David Ackah David Ackah David Ackah David Ackah, David Dessy Arna, Yessy Dewi Rika Miranti Dudi Hartono Dyah Adriantini Sintha Dewi Edmelyn B. Cacayan Elfida Elfida Emy Rianti Eva Sulistiany Evi Irianti Fahmi Hafid Fajriansyah Fajriansyah Farida Halis FRANSISKUS SALESIUS ONGGANG Gede Dalem Gilang Mahajaya Putra Gulyamov, Said Saidakhrarovich Hadi Prayitno, Hadi Hammad Hammad Handayani, Tinuk Esti Handoyo Handoyo Handoyo Handoyo Hapsari, Rafif Naufi Waskitha Hari Basuki Notobroto Hendrik Hendrik Hendriyani, Feftin I Ketut Gama I Ketut Sudiantara I Putu Suiraoka I Wayan Mustika ilyas - ibrahim Ilyas Ibrahim Imam Sunarno, Imam Intening, Vivi Retno Ismoyowati, Tri Wahyuni Izziyana, Wafda Vivid Jane Leo Mangi Joel Rey Acob Ugsang Joel Rey U. Acob Joel Rey U. Acob Joel Rey U. Acob Joel Rey U. Acob Joel Rey Ugsang Acob Joel Rey Ugsang ACOB Joel Rey Ugsang Acob Joel Rey Ugsang Acob Joel Rey Ugsang Acob Joel Rey Ugsang Acob Kadar Ramadhan Kamilus Mamoh Karwati Karwati Kasad Kasad Kasiati Kasiati Khambali, Khambali Khudzaifah Dimyati Koekoeh Hardjito Koesmantoro, Hery Kristyani, Devi Kusumawardani, Emi Lameky, Vernando Yanry Lapodi, Abd Rijali Lestari & Catur Prasatia, Indah Lia Herliana Lina Lina M. Fadly Kaliky M. Miftachul Ulum Mardiyanah, Nurul Mareta Bakale Bakoil Mariana Ngundju Awang Matje Meriati Huru Melati, Nimsi Mira Komariah Mufida Aziza Baroroh Muhammad Anshari, Muhammad Muhammad Najib muhammad saleh Muliani Mustaffa, Aminuddin Myrna A. Mercado Myrna A. Mercado N. Surtinah Nadifah, Azkia Izzatun Nana Usnawati Nani Surtinah Nani Surtinah Nani Surtinah Nani Surtinah Nasrul Ngestiningrum, Ayesha Hendriana Ni Ketut Mendri Ni Ketut Mendri Ni Ketut Mendri Ni Ketut Mendri Ni Wayan Rusni Noer Saudah Nur Heliana Sari Nurdin Nurdin nurlailis saadah Nuryani . Nuryani, Nuryani Pertiwi, Nabila Putri Pius Selasa Purwanti, Dwi Rafif Naufi Waskitha Hapsari Ragu Harming Kristina Rahardjo, Sutio Rahayu Sumaningsih Rahayu, Teta Puji Riska Wahyu Utami Risky Ika Septiana Puspitasari Ristya Widi Endah Yani Rizka Rizka Rozan Asyrofi Rakyan Risang Aji Rusdianti, Alfi Sahrir Sillehu Sahrir Sillehu Sainuddin Sainuddin Sanglar Polnok Sanglar Polnok Sanglar Polnok Sanglar Polnok Sanglar Polnok, Sanglar Santosa, Budi Joko Santosa, Budi Joko Sari, Nur Heliana Sarjiyati Sarjiyati Sausan Hanifah Setyowati Setiawan Shelby Indah Cantika Permatasari Sholikah, Nurrochmatin Sigit Sapto Nugroho Siti Syahida Nurani Sri Angriani Sri Utami Sri Wayanti Sri Winarni Stefanus Supriyanto Subagyo . subagyo subagyo Suhatno Sulikah Sulikah Sulystiono, Dony Sumaningsih, Rahayu Sumasto, Hery Sunarto . Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto Sunarto, Sunarto SUPARJI Suparji Suparji Suparji Suparji Supriyanti Supriyanti Surtinah, N Surtinah, Nani Susi Ahmawati Susi Milwati Susiani Tri Wahyuningsh Sutio Rahardjo T. Iskandar Faisal Tanjung Subrata Tanko Titus Auta Tanko Titus Auta Tanko Titus Auta Tanko Titus Auta Tanko Titus AUTA Tanko Titus Auta Tanko Titus Titus Auta Taqwin Taqwin Teta Puji Rahayu Teuku Alamsyah Titik Endarwati Titin Wulandari Tri Johan Agus Yuswanto Trisna Sumadewi Tuhana, Veki Edizon Tuhu Pinardi, Tuhu Verlingga Diah Oktiasa Putri Vincentius Supriyono Vincentius Supriyono Wahyurianto, Yasin Wayanti, Sri Wella Nur Hidayah Widjiati Winarko, Winarko Windhu Purnomo Wiwin Martiningsih Yulianus Sudarman H Melangka Yuni Purwati Yunita Satya Pratiwi Yustiana Olfah Zulkarnaini Zulkarnaini