Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Progressive Legal Reasoning in Judicial Perspectives on Interfaith Inheritance: A Socio-Legal Study at the Class IA Makassar Religious Court Muhammad Zahir Akbar; Supardin; Andi Herawati
Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum Vol 4 No 2 (2026): Adagium: Jurnal Ilmiah Hukum
Publisher : PT. Meja Ilmiah Publikasi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.70308/9nnp8359

Abstract

This article examines four reported judicial perspectives at the Class IA Makassar Religious Court on progressive legal reasoning (hukum progresif) in interfaith inheritance and the possible use of a mandatory bequest (wasiat wajibah) for non-Muslim relatives. The qualitative socio-legal approach relies on interview summaries reported in the authors’ underlying manuscript—not independently audited transcripts—and a doctrinal reading of the Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI), legislation on judicial authority, and six Supreme Court decisions discussed in the official jurisprudence digest through 2018. The reported judges support fact-sensitive justice within jurisdictional and legal constraints, but differ in their emphases. A non-Muslim family member does not automatically acquire the status of an Islamic heir under Article 171(c) KHI; receiving a mandatory bequest is a distinct juridical route. Its extension beyond adoptive relationships arises from jurisprudential development, not the express wording of Article 209 KHI. The cases show differing beneficiary categories and reported allocations, while several precise holdings and denominators remain unascertainable without full judgments. The article proposes a sequential test of jurisdiction, family evidence, marital-property separation, bequest limits, and protection of recognised heirs. Interview statements are not presented as proof of how the six Supreme Court cases were decided.
Co-Authors A Muh Muharram M A. Rahmani Samsul A. Uswatun Hasanah Aswar Abd. Qadir Gassing Abdul Rauf Muhammad Amin Abubakar, Achmad Akifah, Farah Alwi, Mujahid Aminuddin Aminuddin Amirullah -, Amirullah Andi Herawati Andi Kitta, Andi Abdul Kadir Andi Muhammad Akmal Andi Muhammad Akmal Andi Nurjayanti Asni Asri, Munzil Aty, Nur Sani Cahyadi Sainuddin Dalle, Jumarni Darmein, Darmein Eka Syahriani Eka Syahriani Faisal Abdullah Fatmawati Fatmawati, Fatmawati Fitrah Nisardi Gassing, Abdul Qadir Gunawan Gunawan Gunawan Gunawan Hamid, Helson Hamsir Hamsir Hamsir Hamzah Harun Al-Rasyid Hamzah Hasan Hasbi Haslinda Sabdah Hasnawati Latief Hasnidar Hasri Ani Sahrir Hasta Sukidi Haziri, Achmad Abrar Hendri Hendri Herdianto Herdianto Hindun Umiyati HM, Muhajir HT, Abd. Qadir Gassing Idsam, Suci Anugrah Idwar Ilmiah Imam Makmun Intan Cahyani, Intan Istiqamah Izzah, Ibnu Jaya, Zairipan jiba, Widyawati Widya Juhan, Nawawi Juliana Kartika Kartika Khaerani, Nurul Kurniati Kurniati Liharja Liharja Lomba Sultan M Rusdi Mardiyanto, Arief Marilang Mildawati, Titi Mita Ayu Lestari Muammar Bakri Muh. Jamal Jamil Muhammad Anis Muhammad Anwar Muhammad Basri Dalle Muhammad Iqbal Muhammad Nasrul Hanasir Muhammad Zahir Akbar Munira, Eka Mursyid Fikri Musafir, Ihsan Musyfika Ilyas Nurfadhila Yunus Nurfaika Ishak Nurfatimah Nurfatimah Nurfatimah Nurjannah Nurlinda Sari Abdul Rauf Nurul Alfiah Rahmi Nurul Muthahharah P, Umar Paputungan, Amaliah Miranti Patawari, A. Muh Yusri Patimah Patimah Prayoga, Doni Qadir Gassing Rahim, Wahida Rahma Amir Rahma Amir Rahman, Muh. Akbar Rahmatulla Rahmawati, Rahmawati Ridha, Rahmatur Riyadhsyah, Teuku Ruhana Ruhana Ruhana, Ruhana S, Samsidar Sartika , Suriana Dwi Shesa, Laras Siddik, Jafar Siti Nurul Fatimah Sri Ujiana Putri Suhaebatul Khaerah Suhartati Suhartati SULASTRI Syafruddin, A.Ummu Fauziyyah Syahputra, Rudi Syaifuddin Syaifuddin Syam, Arif Syamsu Rizal Syamsuddin, Darussalam Syarwan, Syarwan Syatar, Abdul Tarmizi Tarmizi Teguh Dermawan Usman Jafar Virgiawa, Rheyza Wahab, Zulkifli Wilda, Nurul Yunus, Yuhanis Zaidathul, Fania Putri